At this moment, the last external judge, the famous Third Ring prophet, Hao Brooks, also arrived at the judges' table, which meant that the defense could officially begin.
Locke glanced at the wizard Edgar in the audience, Edgar nodded to him from his seat.
Locke then nodded in response.
Meanwhile, Locke turned his attention to the Witch Catherine.
This was the first time my cooperating wizard mentor had come to watch my defense of the grant application project at the Truth Institute.
The seats that were supposed to be hers were empty the first three times.
Was it because the Special-Grade Funding was unusual? Locke scratched her head. However, most of the main participants in a Special-Grade Funding were her students, so it really wouldn't be right for her not to come.
The Green Dragon Throne rose and announced the start of the debate, inviting Antoine to the stage for the first time.
After she called Antoine's name twice, no one came up on stage. The Green Dragon Throne then announced expressionlessly, "A ten-minute countdown begins now. If Antoine does not appear, his defense will be considered complete."
Clearly, if he were to miss this defense, his application for the Special-Grade Funding would certainly not pass the department's internal review.
Time passed by, minute by minute.
Locke looked up at the alchemical clock on the ceiling of the conference room. Ten minutes passed quickly. The alchemical clock monitored the time at the particle level, making it extremely accurate.
It seems Antoine won't be returning for the time being. I heard he's trapped in the collapsed World Ruins. Many wizards in the Elder Council even thought he could make it back in time for his defense, but it seems they were just wishful thinking.
Many of the Elder Council faction wizards present turned and left immediately.
Since Antoine wouldn't be attending the defense, it successfully turned into an internal academic struggle between factions within the Academic Committee.
No, it should be said that it was an internal competition within the Academic Lineage of the Witch Catherine, since the Truth Institute was under the control of the Witch Catherine.
This grand defense session turned into a one-man show by the academics of Witch Catherine.
Many wizards understood that Witch Catherine had achieved a certain level of control over Golden Crown Mountain.
It's likely that she will wield considerable influence at Golden Crown Mountain over the next twenty years.
A High-Ring Wizard can influence the entire Wizard University through their students.
Ten minutes passed, and the moderator of the defense, a Star-Ring Wizard, walked onto the stage and announced that Antoine had automatically abstained from the contest.
Next, the Green Dragon Witch announced that several more wizards should come forward to answer questions.
Those who went up were mostly wizards who were researching Crystallized Magic Plants. They either chose to Crystallization Second-Ring Magic Plants or explored combining traditional breeding methods with Crystallization to enhance traditional breeding methods with Crystallization technology.
A Second-Ring Wizard, a senior researcher at the Truth Institute, said, "My research project is to develop Grafting Cultivation Method based on the Magic Plant Crystallization. The five Basic Cultivation Methods plus the Spiritual Breath Cultivation Method are powerful tools for us Breeders to modify magical plants, but they are all too traditional. Now I want to transform the Grafting Cultivation Method among the five Basic Cultivation Methods into an advanced grafting cultivation method— Crystallized Grafting."
"This is of great significance; the importance of Crystallization technology is self-evident..."
This Second-Ring Wizard spoke eloquently.
The thirty Second-Ring Wizards from Golden Crown Mountain, who were on the judging panel behind the judges' seats, all nodded in agreement.
Although only five judges can score the wizards participating in the defense, the average of the scores given by the five judges is the final score that the wizard receives.
The player with the highest score wins.
However, these review panels are all responsible for asking questions and brainstorming during the defense process. Essentially, the five judges don't need to say much during the entire process; they only need to score. Of course, they can ask questions if they want, but under normal circumstances, these High-Ring Wizards rarely do this.
Of the thirty Second-Ring Wizards, some had Moon Rings, some had Star Rings, but none had Sun-Ring.
Because Sun-Ring Wizards are special among Second-Ring Wizards, the judging panel usually selects wizards below Moon Ring. In principle, they will not invite Sun-Ring Wizard Sun-Ring Wizards, who should be seated on the judging panel.
At this moment, many of the Second-Ring Wizards in the review panel nodded in approval of the senior researcher.
Crystallized Magic Plant technology has indeed become an important and popular research direction in Cloud Marsh Wetland. The fact that this Second-Ring Wizard wants to use the support provided by the Special-Grade Funding to explore whether the traditional five basic grafting methods can be integrated into Crystallization technology is indeed a very meaningful research direction, and it also captures the hot topic.
A Star-Ring Wizard suddenly spoke up and asked, "So, Valentinian, what research methods are you using? Are these just castles in the air, or are you confident in your abilities?"
The wizard Valentinian smiled confidently.
"I've prepared experiments on various advanced grafting methods, including cleft grafting, grafting with budding, and more. I plan to use the Red-Earth Holly, the Strongest and resource-intensive of the Second-Ring Magic Plant and First-Ring Magic Plants, to explore which grafting method is most suitable for combining with Crystallized Magic Plants. I can also analyze the characteristics of Crystallized Magic Plants after using various grafting methods using the Ice Magic Mirror and the Queen's Chessboard..."
The Star-Ring Wizard nodded.
But another Star-Ring Wizard suddenly spoke up, "But I think you have a problem with cost control. It seems you plan to use the Queen's Chessboard once for each type of magical plant grafted."
Valentinian paused for a moment.
"Sir, is this not acceptable?"
Master Richie Finch, seated on the five judges' panel, smiled slightly and said, "With this kind of usage, the Special-Grade Funding you will soon be exhausted, and you won't be able to finish this research."
Valentinian swallowed hard, knowing that while he was writing the application and boasting, he had overlooked some cost control.
Of course, this was mainly because he felt somewhat disoriented when rushing to finish the cost control part.
After all, he hadn't even completed the first step of what he was talking about, yet he was expected to handle the final cost control steps. Naturally, there would be inaccuracies in his fabrication.
The problem lies in the details.
Right now, Richie Fincher's sudden reminder to him is essentially a helping hand, making him realize where the critics' dissatisfaction lies.
Next, the wizard Valentinian tried to downplay the key points of his research plan and avoided answering detailed questions about cost control.
It was clear that the wizards on the review panel were somewhat speechless at his behavior, but considering how excellent and popular Valentinian's research topic was, they actually held back quite a bit in their comments.
After all, although his research methods were not perfect in the eyes of many Second-Ring Wizards, his ideas were not clear enough, and his cost control was extremely disastrous. To put it simply, the second half was basically written in a daze. This was probably because Valentinian was forced to do his research.
Therefore, he made do with many things as they were.
However, sometimes choosing a good topic is enough to win. After all, this is only Special-Grade Funding. In principle, the wizard does not necessarily have to produce a result. So as long as the topic is good and the judges can be convinced, the grant can be obtained.
In this world, there are wizards who are particularly good at choosing topics but not at finishing them, and there are also those whose topics start strong but end weakly.
It's good to be someone who sees things through to the end; that's a rare quality.
After finishing his defense, the wizard Valentinian breathed a slight sigh of relief. Although many of his points had raised some objections, the overall presentation was acceptable. While the judges on the panel were critical, they also nodded in approval of his research direction.
To reiterate, as long as the research path of Magic-Plant Crystallization Technology is followed, this choice is ultimately correct.
Even if he doesn't get the Special-Grade Funding this time, he can still use this project to participate in other competitions or apply for specific funding.
It's much better than choosing an obscure topic, where failure would leave you with nothing but trouble.
The wizard Valentinian exhaled a breath of stale air. Although the five judges, apart from Master Patrick, the other four Third-Ring Wizards were all expressionless, they only occasionally picked up their magic quills to jot something down, which could be an evaluation of his performance, or they could simply be dealing with other matters.
It was a bit cold, but it wasn't a problem.
Because at the Special-Grade Funding meetings held in the academy last year, the year before last, and the year before that, these wizards of the Third Ring and above were almost equally indifferent. Basically, the questions were asked by the review panel composed of Second-Ring Wizards, while the Third-Ring Wizards just took notes and gave scores.
They wouldn't have made any special statement anyway.
The wizard Valentinian reassured himself that it wasn't a big problem; he had performed quite well.
I imagine the Third-Ring Wizards wouldn't rate him too low.
He glanced at the audience out of the corner of his eye. At that moment, the Witch Catherine seemed to be handling some business with her head down, holding Lingzhi Magic Plant. However, most of the audience still applauded him.
The Blue Dragon Throne frowned and suddenly asked a question.
"Valentinian, you say you want to perform grafting between Crystallized Magic Plants, but explain to me the mechanism by which grafting between Crystallization cambium layers can still occur after the cambium outer layer of a magical plant has been Crystallization?"
The wizard Valentinian was stunned, because his research was only half done, done in a hurry and in a scramble.
He seemed to have a mental block, stammering and vaguely fabricating several untenable theories, making many of the audience members around him feel embarrassed for him.
However, the wizard Valentinian managed to fool them after all.
Although his answer was reluctant and he seemed completely unprepared for the question.
But he still managed to smooth things over.
When the wizard Valentinian stepped down from the stage, half an hour later, he touched his back and found it was covered in sweat.
He exhaled a breath of stale air.
"Special-Grade Funding is incredibly difficult."
"My qualifications are only average to begin with. If it weren't for the research on Crystallized Magic Plants, I probably wouldn't even have a single paper in the Q2. I only have one paper in the Q2, and qualifications are an important factor in the overall evaluation score."
Ultimately, the essence of this defense is not to evaluate whose research is more impressive, but to evaluate whose research is more meaningful and has a better chance of being realized with limited funding and time.
After all, it would be ridiculous for a wizard to make a boast that is completely impossible to achieve.
Therefore, at this moment, both the review panel composed of Second-Ring Wizards and the five judges were somewhat skeptical, worried that the project proposals submitted by these wizards were simply impossible to complete.
Moreover, based on historical experience, unfortunately, this may simply be a product of certain realities.
Because for a large portion of project applications, even the applicants themselves never believed they could complete the project.
Therefore, for the review panel and judges, past qualifications, such as how many articles you have published, how many projects you have worked on, and what championships you have won, are very important guarantees!
In the audience, the wizard from Mysterious Heaven remained expressionless, while the Throne Wizard from the Starfield Sea nodded with a smile.
"In the years I've been away from Cloud Marsh Wetland, quite a few interesting things have happened here. Will even more interesting things happen next?"
The Sea Queen Throne took a sip of the Wizard Wine, then tossed the bottle aside. She crossed her legs, her platinum-gold high heels nearly kicking the wizard to her right.
The wizard was somewhat angry but dared not speak out, though he regretted sitting in such a prominent position.
Sea Queen Throne stared at the defense with bleary eyes.
Meanwhile, the reporters from Cloud Marsh Wetland newspapers, sitting in the highest seats at the back of the audience, were frantically using the Illusion School's alchemy equipment to record these scenes.
One of the largest newspapers in Cloud Marsh Wetland is the Frog Newspaper Office. At this moment, a Star-Ring Wizard editor-in-chief from the Frog Newspaper Office said, "A large number of High-Ring Wizards from the Starfield Sea, Mysterious Heaven, and Cloud Marsh Wetland have gathered here. This means it can't just be a simple Special-Grade Funding. Although I don't know exactly what happened..."
He said to the First-Ring Wizard journalists beside him, "We need to record this historic moment immediately. My gut feeling—well, I'm just a wizard journalist from the Illusion School, but I think my intuition is pretty accurate—I believe something extraordinary, something we don't know about, must have happened here today."
"Hmm? You're asking me what's so extraordinary? If everyone knew what was so extraordinary, what would be the point of us reporters? Anyway, let's record this scene first, so we can use it when the extraordinary thing actually happens!"
The First-Ring Wizard reporters nodded in agreement.
After the wizard Valentinian, the wizard Droma went up.
To be honest, Droma's experiments were even more inadequate. She was probably too eager to eliminate her competitors and was always up to no good, so she didn't put much effort into her research. As a result, her application was rather unsatisfactory, and her defense was a complete disaster.
The Third-Ring Wizards didn't ask him any questions, but the Second-Ring Wizards' critique panel bombarded him with a series of questions, throwing the wizard Droma into disarray.
The sorceress Droma was now somewhat regretful; she shouldn't have had so many ulterior motives.
In retrospect, he truly wasted his time as a petty person.
Those geniuses were no match for him. He couldn't even get past the judging panel composed of Second-Ring Wizards. Even with the Magic-Plant Crystallization Technology, he still failed to seize the opportunity.
After the Droma Zhuoma came down, she sighed deeply and sat back down in her seat as a participant in the defense.
However, since the wizard Droma also followed the route of Magic-Plant Crystallization Technology, the judges were still kind to him. Some Second-Ring Wizards even thought that his project had its merits and that he could polish it up again next year before participating in the competition.
Or, you could do a similar project, put the project out for sale first, and then recoup the costs incurred from the preliminary experimental data.
But when the applicant from the Deacons Group participated in the defense, the Second Ring review panel really went all out. This wizard chose a Fire Magic Spell Model for research, but even his research methodology was problematic. Almost none of the wizards on the Second Ring review panel were optimistic about him.
For the entire half hour, this Second Ring witch named Kurt Panberry was completely numb from the barrage of questions, and in the end, she didn't even bother to answer them seriously.
Kurt Panbelle replied blankly, "Ah... how to dispel this fire Spell Model..."
A Star-Ring Wizard impatiently interrupted her, saying, "Alright, you can leave now. That's not even the question I asked. It's utterly nonsensical. With this level of preparation... don't come here again and embarrass yourself."
Several wizards in the audience chuckled softly, while others sympathized with the witch.
After all, everyone saw that the witch initially tried to salvage the situation, but after being relentlessly criticized by the judging panel for half an hour, her brain simply shut down.
Kurt Panbelle could only see the wizards' mouths opening and closing, but she couldn't hear what they were saying.
She didn't dare let the wizards on the review panel repeat their questions.
When Kurt Panbelle turned and left the stage, there were tears in her eyes; she seemed particularly aggrieved.
Kurt Panbelle returned to her seat, and her good friend seemed to be comforting her.
Locke heard her say dejectedly, "It's okay, I'll be leaving the station this year anyway. I'm just here to try, but if I don't pass, that's fine too. This year is already Hell because of the Magic-Plant Crystallization Technology. Even though I wanted to temporarily elevate the significance and value of the research project, it only made me lose my composure. I shouldn't have performed this badly."
Next up were the two wizards from the Shaping School in Wind Magic. They were researching absolute defense within Wind Magic. Their defenses were quite commendable, with no major issues. One of them was even questioned by the Green Dragon Witch, but his answers were generally passable.
The biggest problem for the two is that they cannot prove that their research project is better than the Magic-Plant Crystallization Technology.
This put them at a significant disadvantage.
Furthermore, given their mediocre performance, the panel of reviewers comprised of all the Second-Ring Wizards did not rate them very highly.
The audience members present could also see the bias of the commentary wizards. These commentary wizards seemed to think that the Magic-Plant Crystallization Technology was a hugely popular route, so they highly praised it, while their attitude towards wizards who strayed from this route was somewhat colder.
Locke looked at the two wizards; their problems were, in fact, his own problems as well.
Even if you perform exceptionally well, it can be very troublesome if you're perceived as having lost in the topic selection aspect.
Of course, the review panel is just that—a review panel. To put it bluntly, the review panel only has the right to ask questions.
Of the four silent wizards at this debate, Master Patrick Finch was the one who truly had the decision-making power.
Moreover, since Master Patrick Finch will definitely side with the Magic Plant Crystallization route, I can only win this defense by performing even better.
Of course, there was no need for him to complain, because the person was invited by the Academic Committee faction, specifically to ensure that wizards from the Red Dragon School Lineage could receive Special-Grade Funding.
In other words, it's a tactic used by people on our side.
I was caught in the crossfire.
At this moment, the Academic Committee, and even his own teachers, are quite optimistic about the Magic-Plant Crystallization Technology route. Although they don't know their true attitude towards this technology, they obviously value the fact that this technology makes it easier to obtain projects!
Locke continued to delve deeper into the significance of his research, trying to figure out how to emphasize the importance of Atavistic Evolution a way that would better appeal to the five judges—no, four judges, one of whom he could ignore.
At this moment, Brandy beside Locke appeared very confident and no longer anxious.
He was clearly eager to try, but unfortunately, he drew the last place, three places lower than Locke.
Locke, on the other hand, defended his thesis in front of Brandy and two other senior researchers who were also studying the Magic Plant Crystallization.
At this moment, the Blue Dragon Throne stood up and said, "Next, Zeno Honoran."
Zeno stood up from his seat and walked onto the stage under the watchful eyes of the audience, the wizards of Mysterious Heaven Starfield Sea.
At this moment, the four Third-Ring Wizard judges remained expressionless, merely writing something on a piece of paper.
The Second-Ring Wizards in the commentary panel all nodded in agreement.
"Zeno the Wizard has two Zone 1 papers. His qualifications are quite impressive."
"Indeed, I've read one of his articles in Zone 1, which is related to the restoration of the Golden Trade Route. He has very original ideas in this area. Is this project also related to the cultivation of magical plants for the restoration of the Golden Trade Route?"
Zeno began his defense. Because he was well-prepared, had chosen the right topic, had a clear research method, and a clear line of thought, he finished quickly and no one raised any objections.
Zeno concluded, "Therefore, in summary, Crystallized Magic Plants have little vitality, so they can be used as materials to fill and repair the Golden Trade Route. Due to their special properties, they can even be planted directly on the Golden Trade Route for immediate repair. I believe this is very promising, considering the loss of function in parts of the Golden Trade Route, which has caused many unnecessary losses to the commercial trade of our Cloud Marsh Wetland."
Upon hearing this, the Second Ring review panel fell silent.
They looked at Zeno with the eyes one would use to look at a fool or a madman. Some looked at Zeno with suspicion, wondering if he was deliberately making sensational statements to attract attention for his research.
Master Patrick simply laughed.
What do you mean by that?