The next day, Zheng Feng, along with representatives from Three Purities and a group of patent lawyers, began settlement negotiations in a conference room.
In the Eagle Country, lawsuits typically involve both parties being accompanied by their lawyers for a routine out-of-court settlement negotiation before the trial.
This is a necessary procedure, after all, not every party involved wants to get bogged down in a protracted lawsuit.
Unless it's a dispute over the ownership of CRISPR technology patents, where the two sides cannot share the patents and can only fight to the death.
In cases like Three Purities's patent infringement, the plaintiff's demands are essentially twofold: either a ban or payment. It's obvious to anyone that the latter is the primary demand, making an out-of-court settlement the best option.
Three Purities's representative was Yang Haoran, the general manager of its overseas branch, who also brought a laptop computer.
After both parties were seated, he placed the computer on the head of the table, and after some operation, a young and handsome face appeared on the screen.
"President Wei, hello. The meeting is about to begin. This is Dr. Zheng Feng from the Broad Institute, and their lawyer..."
With a smile, Yang Haoran introduced them to both parties one by one, "Dr. Zheng, this is President Wei of our Sanqing Group, and our lawyer..."
"President Wei will be present to listen in. I will be the one to negotiate the settlement. Of course, President Wei will also speak if necessary."
Zheng Feng looked at the opposite side with curiosity. He had long heard of Wei Kang's name, and today he finally met him in person.
This face, just like the legend says, is excessively young, with sharp features and a commanding presence. From the outside, it looks more like a movie star than a renowned entrepreneur.
The other party appeared very calm, with his limbs outstretched and his body leaning back in his chair. He exuded a sense of ease and confidence, as if he were facing not a lawsuit, but an internal company meeting.
A sense of envy welled up in his heart. Such a rich and handsome man was rare even in the Eagle Country. Moreover, he had turned the tide, reborn from the crisis, and built his own pharmaceutical empire, leaving the rich second-generation in the world far behind.
However, he quickly suppressed this emotion and instead felt a sense of pride and satisfaction.
He rose from humble beginnings, from a penniless test-taker to his current position, enjoying both fame and fortune, with a promising future ahead.
Even someone as unapproachable as Wei Kang, who was once untouchable, now has to sit at the same table with him, negotiate, be manipulated by him, and obediently hand over the profits from Gene Drug.
The stronger the opponent, the more intense his pleasure in reaping them.
I wonder how long you can keep that relaxed look on your face?
He sneered inwardly, but put on a friendly and amiable smile and greeted Wei Kang in a cordial manner.
"It's great to hear from you, Mr. Wei. I've heard so much about you."
Wei Kang nodded, smiled, and waited quietly for the peace talks to begin.
Today's first out-of-court settlement is just the beginning of a long legal battle.
He has conveyed the company's general message to Yang Haoran, entrusting him with full authority over the lawsuit.
I'll just sit in on the conversation first, and then we'll discuss it if I have any questions.
This lawsuit is a tough battle, far from the harmonious situation it presents.
He knew all too well that the key to winning or losing this case lay not on the scene, but off the scene.
It must be said that both sides' lawyers were very professional, both being well-known patent lawyers in the Eagle Country, with great reputations and high prices.
First, the lawyers appeared, and after a heated debate, things turned serious and they really got down to business.
"Three Purities's Gene Drug for Thalassemia uses our Gene Editing Technology, but it has not obtained our authorization and has not paid any Patent Fee. This is an absolute infringement."
"This is the evidence we have collected, which is irrefutable. It includes samples of Gene Drug, testimonies from the Hematology Department at the Mayo Clinic, evidence of patients receiving treatment, and proof of payment. All of this proves that Three Purities not only committed serious infringements but also made a large amount of illegal profits."
The Broad Institute's lawyers presented a thick stack of supporting documents.
Three Purities's lawyer read the document and then offered rebuttals.
"First of all, the patent for CRISPR technology has always been controversial. You only own the rights in the Eagle Country. In Europa and China, the patent belongs to the University of California team, while Three Purities is a China company that obtained the patent license in China a long time ago."
"Even in the Eagle Country, you only recently obtained this patent, and the University of California team has been filing lawsuits. It is difficult to determine the final outcome, and it is questionable whether it will still belong to you."
"Since the launch of Three Purities's Gene Drug, we have been in contact with the Broad Institute to discuss the issue of patent licensing in the Eagle Country, but we have not received a response."
"Oh? Is that so? How come I didn't know?" Zheng Feng suddenly interjected with a surprised look.
"I have emails as proof." The lawyer looked at him calmly and showed him an email.
It was an email sent by Three Purities's patent personnel to the Broad Institute, proposing a patent licensing collaboration in English, three months ago, when Three Purities had just begun its clinical trials in the Eagle Country.
Zheng Feng chuckled, "This isn't my email address, so it's normal that I don't know. I can confirm that our staff didn't receive this email. After all, you know, email addresses from China are easily blocked as spam. I often miss emails from my China friends."
The lawyer next to him nodded. "This doesn't prove anything; Three Purities has still infringed on your rights. Even if there's no response to the email, you can still come to our office to discuss it."
Yang Haoran coughed lightly and said, "Let's get straight to the point. What are your demands?"
Zheng Feng and the lawyer exchanged a glance and remained silent.
The lawyer from the Broad Institute turned serious and slowly said, "We demand that Three Purities apologize to the global media for its infringement, pay Patent Fee for all marketed Thalassemia Gene Drug, and also pay back fees for all Gene Drug that have undergone clinical trials. If there are any further infringements in the future, they will have to pay huge compensation."
"Otherwise, we will file a lawsuit in court to prohibit Three Purities from using any CRISPR technology globally, and at the same time pay $2 billion in infringement damages."
As soon as he finished speaking, Yang Haoran sat up straight and blurted out, "That's impossible."
Three Purities's lawyer's expression also turned ugly.
On the screen, Wei Kang's expression remained unchanged, only a cold glint flashed in his eyes.
The lawyer from the Broad Institute said sternly, "These are our conditions. If you don't agree, then we'll have to see you in court."
Yang Haoran said with a livid face, "You have no sincerity in reconciliation at all. Whether you appear in court or not, these conditions are too harsh."
Three Purities's lawyer also spoke up, "Dr. Zheng, we greatly respect the patent of the Broad Institute, but this is not a reasonable solution. We hope you can relax the conditions a bit and talk again."
Yang Haoran added, "I want to reiterate that there is absolutely no possibility of us apologizing."
"Heh," the lawyer from the Broad Institute sneered, "If you respected this patent, you wouldn't have committed this infringement. We now own this patent, and its potential in Gene Therapy is enormous. Your use of it without warning is a serious infringement of our technology patent, so it is perfectly normal and reasonable for you to apologize."
Three Purities's lawyer shook his head. "But you only own this patent in the Eagle Country. My client has not infringed on any patents in China or other regions, so how can you issue an apology globally?"
The opposing lawyer was speechless for a moment, and immediately changed his tune, saying, "Then we must issue a public apology in the media in the Eagle Country. Three Purities has many patients in the Eagle Country now, and they all need to know that this technology belongs to my clients, not Three Purities. Three Purities has only stolen the results of the Broad Institute."
Yang Haoran retorted angrily, "What are you saying? We've worked so hard to develop this Gene Drug, and all you've provided is the underlying technology. So you're saying we've worked for nothing and it's all your achievement? The patent for the Thalassemia Gene Drug belongs to us, not your Broad Institute."
"If all else fails, we will withdraw from the Eagle Country market, but we will never apologize."
"If you want to go to court, then we'll see. We're not afraid."
A hint of surprise flashed in the eyes of the lawyer from the Broad Institute. He hadn't expected the other party to be so tough. He had no choice but to bite the bullet and say, "Heh, I hope you won't regret it. Without CRISPR technology, such a useful Gene Editing tool, you simply wouldn't be able to continue developing Thalassemia Gene Drug."
Yang Haoran laughed angrily, "You talk as if having CRISPR technology means you can develop Thalassemia Gene Drug. Open your eyes and look around. Besides our Three Purities, which other company in the world has developed Gene Drug using CRISPR technology?"
The opposing lawyer was instantly speechless. He opened his mouth as if he wanted to say something, but he was unable to refute it.
Because apart from Three Purities, there really isn't another company that has developed Gene Drug using CRISPR technology.
The two sides were on the verge of exchanging barbs and were about to part on bad terms.
At this moment, Zheng Feng said with a smile, "Everyone, don't get so angry, let's talk things out."
"Whether or not they apologize, we don't really care. Three Purities is a globally renowned pharmaceutical giant, and we can understand why they are unwilling to apologize for fear of damaging their reputation."
"We are honored that Three Purities has been able to use our patent to develop Gene Drug and save so many patients. This also indirectly proves the feasibility and practicality of our technology. We are overjoyed."
"I have long admired President Wei wanted to cooperate with a world-class pharmaceutical company like Three Purities. Unfortunately, I have never had the opportunity. I hope that from now on, I can cooperate with Three Purities on CRISPR patents."
As he spoke, he looked at Wei Kang and said, "We're all decent people, there's no need to argue over such a trivial matter. How about this, we won't ask for an apology, just pay the Patent Fee, okay?"
Wei Kang stared at him for a while, then suddenly gave a meaningful smile, "Okay."
Yang Haoran nodded. "Then how should the Patent Fee be paid?"
Three Purities's lawyer coldly stated, "To the best of my knowledge, applying this Gene Editing Technology to basic research does not require a patent license. Only the part that is truly commercialized can collect patent licensing fees. Three Purities's clinical trials of Thalassemia Gene Drug fall under the category of basic research and have not generated any profit. Only drugs that have been marketed will be considered as such."
"Moreover, although the Patent Office has granted you Patent Rights, you are still in patent litigation. If we pay you Patent Fee and you lose the case and lose your Patent Rights, we will face huge losses."
"Finally, you have no Patent Rights in China and other regions, and we will not pay a single penny of our commercial revenue in those regions."
"These demands are unreasonable and completely unacceptable to us..." Once the opposing lawyer got to the point, he immediately became energetic and spoke eloquently.
After a heated debate, the Broad Institute insisted on paying patent licensing fees proportionally.
For every unit of Thalassemia Gene Drug sold, Patent Fee must be paid.
The payment ratio is 30%.
Bang!
Yang Haoran slammed his fist on the table and stood up. "You are truly insatiable! There is no Patent Fee this high anywhere else in the world. Are you trying to squeeze all our profits dry?"
The opposing lawyer said sternly, "Do I need to remind you? The pharmaceutical industry is known for its exorbitant profits, which are completely different from the meager profits in other industries. Pharmaceutical companies generally have a profit margin of 90%, and we are already being lenient by taking 30%."
"Moreover, medical expenses in the Eagle Country are known to be high, and there is no such thing as price limits or centralized procurement, so this ratio is very reasonable."
"But Three Purities's Gene Drug have always been relatively inexpensive."
The opposing lawyer coldly replied, "That's your problem. Three Purities can be sold for a high price, and I believe the patients have no other choice but to use your medication."
"Furthermore, although increasing the unit price will reduce sales volume, it will also greatly increase costs and make profits higher. This is actually better for pharmaceutical companies, isn't it? This is also in our interest."
"..." This time, Yang Haoran was speechless.
He knew in his heart that the other party was right. Raising drug prices and maximizing profits was the way most companies survived. Although it did not conform to Three Purities's corporate philosophy, it was an unspoken rule in the pharmaceutical industry.
Gene Drug, in particular, are already very expensive and are unique in the market with no competitors, so there is no worry about a lack of patients and there is absolutely no need to lower the price.
Even if it sells for an exorbitant price, there will still be buyers. Just like the SMA gene drug, which had a unit price of up to 2 million US dollars and made billions of dollars in profit in just two years after its launch.
Three Purities could easily sell its Thalassemia Gene Drug for over a million US dollars, and even with high Patent Fee, its profits would still be substantial.
Yang Haoran sighed inwardly. "Alas, it's a pity that Three Purities isn't Eagle Country pharmaceutical company, but China company. Naturally, we can't do that."
He rallied his spirits and began to negotiate with the other party.
The two sides engaged in a heated debate that lasted until evening before finally reducing the percentage to 25%.
At this point, the other party refused to talk any further.
Ultimately, the two parties reached their first out-of-court settlement.
Although the talks were difficult, initial results were achieved.
For all Thalassemia Gene Drug are marketed, Three Purities will pay an additional patent licensing fee of 25% of the profits.
Everyone walked out of the conference room looking exhausted, but there was no sense of relief or joy in their hearts after their success.
Everyone had a feeling that a storm was brewing.
They all knew that this peace talk was just the beginning, and the resolution of the whole matter would certainly not be so easy.