The One Who Stole Hawking's Thunder (Part One)
After receiving Xu Yun's affirmative reply.
Chen Ning Yang subconsciously drew an "O"-shaped circle on the Abacus paper in front of him, his eyes flickering with an inscrutable expression.
"A black hole?"
As mentioned before.
In the late 1940s, people successfully quantized various material fields in flat spacetime.
So they naturally tried to quantize the matter field in curved spacetime, and the gravitational field itself.
Even when establishing a self-consistent theory of quantum gravity encounters enormous difficulties and obstacles, it does not prevent people from establishing quantum field theory in curved spacetime.
At that time, spacetime was still classical, while the matter field was quantum.
However, unlike classical physics where Newton's first and second physics concepts can be verified simply by finding an open space, the concept of a "field" is easy to calculate, but it is somewhat difficult to verify it through phenomena—at least for the technological level of the 1960s.
Black holes are undoubtedly a powerful testing ground for quantum field theory of curved spacetime.
The concept of black holes was proposed very early, so early that it may have overturned many people's understanding:
The concept of a black hole first appeared in 1783.
That's right.
It wasn't 1983, nor 1883, but 1783.
This year marked the 48th year of Qianlong Emperor's Huaxia. After completing his fourth eastern tour to Shengjing, the emperor had squandered a considerable sum of money.
Meanwhile, on the fifth day after Qianlong arrived in Jilin.
John Michell, then a professor of geology and clergyman at Cambridge University, speculated on the influence of the sun's gravity on its radiation during a lecture at the Royal Society of London.
Earlier than him, Romer determined in the 17th century by observing the timing of solar eclipses on Jupiter that the speed of light is finite. Therefore, Michell believed that photons from the sun would slow down as they left the sun due to the sun's gravity.
His hypothesis suggests that if the sun's diameter were 500 times larger than it is now, while maintaining the same density, its mass would be 10^8 solar masses, and gravity would prevent light from escaping from the sun.
Then in 1915, Einstein articulated the theory of general relativity, obtaining a coherent theory of how gravity affects light.
1916.
Schwarzschild solution based on Einstein field equation has been developed.
1939.
Oppenheimer proved that if a dying star has a mass greater than a certain limit, it will be unable to resist its own gravity and form a black hole of infinite density, which is the famous Oppenheimer limit.
At this point, our mathematical and physical understanding of black holes has been deduced to a level that, while not perfect, is at least relatively mature.
Theoretically speaking.
By observing the gravitational effects around black holes, scientists are able to verify predictions of relativity—such as the bending of light and the warping of spacetime.
Furthermore, by observing the accretion disk and jets of black holes, the physics sea can study the behavior of high-energy matter in extreme gravitational fields, which is almost the cornerstone of the introduction to plasma and radio wave-related fields.
Of course.
The above statement is made from a later perspective; at this stage, our understanding and exploration of black holes are still very rudimentary.
The name "black hole" is not yet fully established; besides black hole, it also has other names such as black star and dark star.
Then Chen Ning Yang touched the inside of the circle he had drawn with the tip of his pen and said to Xu Yun:
"Little Xu, from what you're saying, you believe there's new physics hidden in black holes?"
Unlike his previous broad concept of the universe, Chen Ning Yang's value in black hole research is relatively clear—it is still relative.
Xu Yun quickly nodded:
"Mr. Yang, I believe this statement should be considered a statement of fact."
Chen Ning Yang's expression remained unchanged as he countered with a question:
"So what's the evidence? You should know that almost all current deductions about black holes are just mathematical conjectures."
"To put it extremely, it's not even certain whether black holes exist at all."
"If the very existence of a black hole is like this, then one can only imagine the physical state inside it."
"Unless you can provide me with evidence that it contains new physics, I personally have reservations about this project."
Xu Yun tapped his fingers on the table a few times:
"Theoretical evidence? Or actual phenomena?"
Chen Ning Yang's tone remained calm and composed.
"Of course, the former is enough. If you can produce the latter, I'll really have to suspect you're some alien donkey that has come to life."
The physics community has barely discovered any signs of black holes yet, so asking Xu Yun to provide phenomenological evidence is clearly asking too much.
Moreover, in Chen Ning Yang's view...
Even if it's just theoretical evidence, Xu Yun probably can't produce much.
After all, this is different from the Proto-hadron Model. No matter how far ahead of its time the Proto-hadron Model may be, it is still a framework built on accelerator experimental reports.
The concept of black holes is still very new. It's not difficult to obtain some mediocre results through mathematical and logical deductions alone, but groundbreaking results are almost impossible.
However, to Chen Ning Yang's surprise, after a moment, Xu Yun's voice came faintly from the other side:
"Mr. Yang, to be honest, I can actually produce this evidence."
Chen Ning Yang was taken aback for a moment, and subconsciously said:
"What evidence?"
Xu Yun remained silent for a while:
"For example, entropy exists within a black hole system."
Entropy?
Because of the poor telephone signal at that time, Chen Ning Yang did not realize what Xu Yun was referring to when he first heard the word.
But then...
Splash--
Chen Ning Yang suddenly stood up from his seat, his voice so loud that even Lu Guangda outside could hear it:
"What did you say? Black holes have entropy?!?!"
Xu Yun nodded firmly, then added further weight to his words:
"To be precise, the entropy of a black hole is proportional to its surface area."
More than ten seconds later.
Recovering from the shock, Chen Ning Yang tried to calm himself down, only to find his cheeks trembling slightly.
"."
To be honest.
If Xu Yun hadn't demonstrated a strong foundation in physics beforehand, and if the Chinese government hadn't endorsed the phone call, Chen Ning Yang would probably have flipped the table by now.
Do black holes have entropy?
How is that possible?
Entropy.
This is a thermodynamic concept, but throughout history, various factors have given it a very rich connotation, bringing it into the view of many disciplines.
This concept is very complex to define, involving Shannon, Clausius, Boltzmann, and others, as well as thermodynamic entropy, information entropy, chemical entropy, and so on.
But it can actually be explained in a very simple way:
Simply put, entropy represents the degree of disorder in matter.
Those of you with bedrooms should know this.
If someone lives in your bedroom, it will become increasingly cluttered if you don't tidy it up.
At first, clothes might become a mess, then books, mentally challenged objects, pens, data cables, and delivery boxes start appearing in various places, eventually turning into a doghouse.
The chaos in a room is defined as entropy; the higher the degree of chaos, the higher the entropy, which is also known as entropy increase.
Entropy reduction refers to the decrease in the entropy of a Closed System over time—which is impossible under normal circumstances unless you manually clean your bedroom; a house cannot clean itself.
Concise and clear. JPG.
The concept of entropy increase also holds true from a cosmological perspective. The physics community generally agrees that the entropy of the universe is constantly increasing because planets are constantly changing.
Some planets collide with each other and break into smaller pieces, while others reach the end of their lifespan and become red giants, and so on.
But
Many scholars have different opinions about black holes:
They believe that black holes do not have entropy.
Based on the example of cleaning the house above, even the most complex things become simpler in "state" after being swallowed by a black hole, which theoretically falls under the category of entropy reduction.
However, entropy reduction is not allowed in an independent system, so a black hole can only be in a state of "nothingness"—no life, no light, and no entropy.
This is also known as the unitariness principle.
Unexpectedly
Xu Yun not only claimed that black holes have entropy, but he also actually said that the entropy of a black hole is proportional to its surface area?
You need to know.
The surface area of a black hole is constantly increasing. If the entropy of a black hole is proportional to its surface area, wouldn't that mean the black hole system is in a state of increasing entropy?
Thinking about this...
Chen Ning Yang couldn't help but take another deep breath, suppressing the urge to refute heresy, and asked Xu Yun:
"Little Xu, words are no proof. Where is your evidence?"
Xu Yun glanced at the clock on the wall; she realized that her conversation with Chen Ning Yang had already lasted for an hour.
"Mr. Yang, first of all, we need to clarify one point: theoretically, parameterizing a black hole only requires three quantities."
"So, mass M, charge Q, and angular momentum J, is that correct?"
Chen Ning Yang nodded:
"Um."
As mentioned before.
The earliest and most famous particular solution to Einstein field equation is called the Schwarzschild solution.
The object described by this solution is a black hole, and the limit of the black hole's apparent distance is called the Schwarzschild radius. Therefore, some black holes are also called Schwarzschild black holes.
Schwarzschild black holes are static, spherically symmetric black holes with only one parameter, namely mass M, and are also the simplest black holes in the model.
Building upon the Schwarzschild black hole, physicists then deduced the concept of rotating black holes, also known as Kerr- Newman black holes.
It is a generalization of the Q=0 Kerr black hole, and also the most common type of black hole in the entire universe.
According to the Kerr- Newman line element model, describing a black hole only requires mass M, charge Q, and angular momentum J.
Then Xu Yun listened carefully to the sounds on the other end of the phone. Soon, a click came from the other end.
This is the sound of Chen Ning Yang placing his pen on the table, indicating that Chen Ning Yang has finished writing the equation.
So Xu Yun quickly added:
"Based on this, Robert Jelesi proposed a thought experiment that refuted the generalized second law."
"That is, slowly moving an object to the event horizon of a black hole and throwing it into the black hole."
"At this point, we can observe that the entropy of the black hole has not increased, while the entropy of matter has decreased. Therefore, the generalized entropy decreases during this process."
Chen Ning Yang nodded. This is a very famous thought experiment.
Xu Yun then took a deep breath and continued:
"But actually, since objects have thickness, for the sake of simplicity, let's assume we're using a sphere for the experiment."
"For a spherical object, because it has a finite radius R, it's practically impossible to reduce it to the level of a black hole's event horizon before throwing it in—the limit is R (proper distance) above the event horizon."
"At this point, the entropy of the black hole will increase slightly, while the entropy of matter will disappear, thus ensuring the validity of the generalized second law."
Chen Ning Yang immediately squinted; this was quite a novel angle.
Before Chen Ning Yang could think it over, Xu Yun spoke up again:
"So, Mr. Yang, if this process isn't a ball and a black hole, but rather..."
What if two black holes merge simultaneously?
"Black hole merger?"
Chen Ning Yang subconsciously looked at the [O] he had initially drawn on the paper to represent a black hole. His gaze was momentarily unfocused, then he caught his breath and quickly picked up his pen to write.
"A typical steady-state black hole satisfies dM = κ8πGdA + ΩdJ + ΦdQ".
"If we assume that black holes merge with each other, then from the sphere example, we know that dA/dt ≥ 0, and we also introduce angular momentum."
Hearing Chen Ning Yang's mutterings during his calculations, Xu Yun couldn't help but show a hint of emotion on her face.
Black hole.
This is a very special topic in the history of physics.
Its uniqueness lies not only in the nature of its phenomenon, but also in its time span.
As mentioned above.
The concept was first proposed in 1783, when Xiao Mai's father was still a fertilized egg.
However, it wasn't until the second decade of the 19th century that the physics community gained a certain mathematical understanding of it.
However, this is just the beginning.
According to historical development.
Starting in 1920, research on black holes in physics would stagnate for another fifty years, until a crucial breakthrough occurred around 1970.
This breakthrough is the black hole area law proposed by Hawking, and the Bekenstein limit proposed by Jacob Bekenstein based on Hawking's law, also known as the Bekenstein - Hawking entropy.
The Bekenstein limit is complex to explain, but it can be summarized in one sentence:
For a sphere of radius r, with a total energy (including the energy corresponding to its rest mass) of E, the maximum entropy of this sphere is 2πkcEr.
From this perspective, the statement "[human imagination is limitless]" is actually wrong.
The human brain weighs approximately 1.5 kg and has a volume of 1260 cm^3. If it were considered a sphere, its radius would be 6.7 cm.
Based on the size and mass of the average human brain, a person can only have a maximum of 10^42 thoughts.
Even if people's consciousness is uploaded and becomes flowing thoughts within a giant computer, this boundary still exists.
Even a computer or "brain" the size of the Earth can only process a maximum of 10^75 thoughts.
A 256-bit key might allow a computer to calculate for two minutes, while a 512-bit key might take nearly 10 to the power of 72 years to calculate—therefore, the plot in some novels where a character can deduce the past and present with a single thought simply doesn't exist. In reality, it might not even be possible to crack a combination lock, cough cough.
Also limiting this is the Bremermann limit: the fastest computation speed that 1 kg of matter can achieve in 1 second is 1.36 * 10^50 bits. Let's not ruin fantasy novels, though.
All in all.
The Bekenstein limit proves that black holes possess black hole entropy, which is proportional to the area of the black hole's event horizon.
Although this process is purely mathematical derivation, the gravitational wave event GW150914 observed by LIGO in 2015 proved the correctness of this derivation.
At the same time, it is quite poignant.
The Bekenstein limit, a concept you might encounter in later online novels like "Walking into the Local Donkey," is now considered a complete mystery and profound knowledge.
Even a big name like Chen Ning Yang had never heard of it before.