Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Library
  • Read
    • Popular
    • Charts
    • Browse
    • Categories
    • Wikis
    • Glossary
  • Request
  • Activity
  • Leaderboard
  • Help
Our Apps
  • DaoSearch
  • Narratorr
Social
  • Discord
  • Patreon
Stepping into the Unscientific
Chapter 721

Theft of Hawking's Livelihood (Part Two)

3,894 words 13 min read 0 views 1mo ago Source ​
Skip to the end of the chapter
Prev
Next

"."

After hearing Xu Yun's idea of merging the two black holes.

There was no reply from Chen Ning Yang on the other end of the microphone; instead, there was the rustling sound of pen and paper calculating.

Instead of throwing a small ball into a black hole, two black holes merge.

The two are similar at the behavioral level, that is, they are two things that come together and become one, but their importance to each other is completely different.

The former is considered to be of the opposite sex and is somewhat common, while the latter is practically equivalent to male ketosis.

If a ball dropped into a black hole experiences entropy increase due to its radius, then theoretically, the same should happen when black holes merge.

That is to say...

Both the surface area and entropy of a black hole will increase irreversibly as a result.

"."

This time.

Chen Ning Yang's calculations lasted a full twenty minutes. During that time, since there was no sound of conversation coming from inside the room, Lu Guangda outside couldn't help but push open the door and peek at the situation.

Twenty minutes later.

A complex sigh quietly came from the other end of the microphone in Xu Yun's hand:

"As expected, in the spin-merge state, the event horizon of a black hole increases with its mass."

"Little Xu, you're right."

Chen Ning Yang's tone was not dejected, but rather extremely emotional.

Although the physics community has not yet witnessed the merger of black holes, or even observed ordinary black holes.

But anyone with a modicum of common sense can imagine that the merger of two black holes is not an instantaneous event—this is relative to the observer.

If the two black holes are at an angle to each other, they will rotate before aligning again, a process that could take millions of years or even longer.

Therefore, it's like a small ball merging with a black hole.

When two black holes merge, the concept of [radius] will definitely exist.

The radius here is not the radius in classical physics, but rather a certain thickness—in layman's terms, mass.

The above logical progression may seem simple and somewhat inexplicable from a later perspective, but as the saying goes, perceptions differ from era to era.

Just like the so-called truth that "the heavier the object, the faster it falls," proposed by Aristotle, it was not until the 16th century that the physics community refuted it with experiments on balls of different sizes.

The same principle applies to the experiment involving large and small spheres, and also to the experiment involving black holes and spheres.

By the way...

Many people have learned in textbooks that Galileo used balls of different sizes to refute Aristotle's story at the Leaning Tower of Pisa, but Galileo actually did not conduct this experiment.

This was actually just a thought experiment by Galileo. Later, Galileo's student Simon conducted the iron ball experiment at the Leaning Tower of Pisa, which was written into the biography of Galileo by another of his students, Viviani.

Furthermore, the results of this two-ball experiment in reality are not ideal. The Leaning Tower of Pisa is 55 meters high, and the iron ball only takes three seconds to fall to the ground. The difference between the size of the balls is not enough to refute Aristotle's theory—although Galileo's thought experiment itself is correct.

Let's return to reality.

Of course.

At this moment, Chen Ning Yang was not marveling at how he hadn't thought of such a simple logical principle, but rather at the result he had arrived at:

The event horizon of a black hole does indeed increase with increasing mass, and it does not decrease irreversibly.

The event horizon here can be equated to the entropy of a black hole.

The equivalence here is not just a literal statement, because you can get the entropy of a black hole by dividing its surface area A by the square of Planck's constant h and then multiplying it by a dimensionless number.

Chen Ning Yang then looked at the formula in front of him for a while, and then said to Xu Yun:

"Little Xu, following your line of thinking, I have two more questions I'd like to confirm."

Xu Yun quickly sat up straight and said:

"Please tell me, I will do my best to answer."

Chen Ning Yang paused for a moment, then asked:

"Regarding the first question, although time was limited and I haven't performed specific calculations, I can judge based on the mass-energy equivalence theorem."

"If black holes really do have entropy, then there should also be information inside them—at least limited information?"

Xu Yun nodded and affirmed:

"That's right."

The situation Chen Ning Yang described is the Bekenstein limit mentioned earlier, one of the few theories that was proven in 2023 along with the formula for the area of a black hole.

"."

Chen Ning Yang wasn't particularly surprised by Xu Yun's affirmative answer; his purpose in raising the question was actually to elicit a later conjecture:

"So, black holes also obey the Second Law of Thermodynamics?"

Xu Yun took a deep breath, his chest rising and falling slightly:

"That's right."

As is widely known.

In the original history.

The development of black hole physics is largely related to Wheeler.

John Wheeler, as a disciple of Einstein, like his teacher, believed that the key to the laws of nature lay in gravity.

However, Wheeler had also worked and exchanged ideas with Bohr, the master of quantum physics, so he was also a believer in quantum mechanics.

He is somewhat similar to an ancient figure named Ye Tianshi, who studied under many masters and eventually combined the strengths of various schools to become a big shot himself.

In 1967.

Wheeler became very interested in the gravitationally collapsed objects described by Schwarzschild in 1917, which are black holes.

Wheeler believed that a black hole is a standard end-all; whatever is thrown into a black hole, the disorder of the system disappears forever because no object can escape from a black hole.

Subsequent work has proven that black holes are indeed highly ordered ultimate compressors; no matter how chaotic things are, they will be compressed into infinitesimal sizes at the center of a black hole, including information.

This description is somewhat similar to the atheist's definition of "death"—there is no breath of life, and no soul going to hell or heaven.

But Bekenstein, Wheeler's student, disagreed.

He suggested that perhaps the information did not disappear into the black hole, but rather transformed into part of the black hole.

Unfortunately, no one believed Bekenstein's idea at the time, until Hawking calculated the area law of black holes, which inspired Bekenstein.

He then went on to derive the famous Bekenstein Limit, proving that black holes contain information and that there is an upper limit to that information.

Of course.

Initially, Hawking didn't believe Bekenstein's conclusion either. As a staunch supporter of general relativity, Hawking thought the young man was trying to take advantage of him.

At the same time, although Bekenstein had the right idea, his reasoning was not very accurate, and there were many uncertainties in his calculations.

For example, he simply said that the entropy of a black hole is proportional to the area of its event horizon—in physics, direct/inverse proportion is actually an elusive term.

For any proof, physicists require a precise scale.

For example, gravity is inversely proportional to the square of the distance, and magnetic field strength is inversely proportional to the cube of the distance. So what about the entropy of a black hole?

Whether it's twice the area or half the area, that number needs to be decided.

Just like bonus chapters in online novels, authors with fast typing speeds only get bonus chapters if they write 20,000 words, while authors with slow typing speeds only get bonus chapters if they write 7,000 words.

However, what's interesting is...

Later, Hawking suddenly realized that due to the Uncertainty Principle of quantum mechanics, black holes do indeed emit a tiny amount of radiation, and this radiation satisfies the formula for Black-body radiation, namely Hawking radiation.

In this case.

Hawking then accepted the Bekenstein upper limit, and with his fairly good mathematical skills, he helped calculate the thermodynamic relationship of black holes, correcting the proportionality coefficient to 1/4.

Therefore, this formula is called the Bekenstein - Hawking equation, also known as the famous BK equation group.

The BK equation group were developed a full 14 years later.

Therefore, Chen Ning Yang still seemed somewhat surprised when faced with the results he had calculated himself.

But that's not right.

Yang Chen Ning Yang drew a horizontal line under the formula [SBH=Akc^3/4G] that he had calculated, frowned, and asked Xu Yun:

"Little Xu, besides mathematics, what's the logical reason why black holes obey the Second Law of Thermodynamics? Don't they increase entropy?"

Logically speaking

If a black hole has entropy, then it should also have temperature.

If something has a temperature, then even if that temperature is very low, it will still produce thermal radiation.

However, this raises questions about the theoretical volume of black holes.

More importantly...

It would prevent supermassive black holes from existing.

"Little Xu, look."

Chen Ning Yang circled the formula a few more times and continued his explanation:

"The particle temperature and particle energy are related by the formula kT=E=hf, and the minimum frequency f can only be 1 Hertz."

Therefore, the minimum temperature can only be T=h/K, and the minimum radiation temperature of a black hole can also only reach T=h/K.

"That is to say, when h/k = hc/kr, the black hole radius r reaches its maximum value."

"If the radius of a black hole increases further, it will violate quantum mechanics, and the temperature will be less than h/K."

"Therefore, according to the black hole entropy theory, the largest black hole radius can only be a value of c. So what about supermassive black holes? Don't they exist?"

Although Xu Yun was not by his side at the time, Chen Ning Yang still acted as if they were having a face-to-face conversation.

I don't know why.

He inexplicably developed a sense of confidence in Xu Yun:

He believed that Xu Yun would understand his thoughts even over the phone.

It was as if the two of them had once had a face-to-face conversation.

And as he said.

According to the radiation formula, there should be a limit to the radius of a black hole.

Since the radius of a black hole is r = 2GM/c^2, it can be calculated that the maximum mass of a black hole allowed by its entropy is only M = c^3/2G.

This value is approximately 10^35 kilograms, which is also the maximum black hole mass allowed by black hole entropy.

The mass of the sun is around 10^30 kilograms, which is approximately 10^5 times the mass of the sun, or 100,000 times.

According to Schwarzschild's black hole model, supermassive black holes, not to mention 100,000 times more massive than the sun, should theoretically exist as well.

So either there's a problem with the black hole's entropy, or...

There are no supermassive black holes.

And that's not all.

If the latter has a problem, then the black hole-related theories that support it must also have problems—at the very least, they should be patched and corrected.

Such a correction would inevitably require changing or adding/subtracting a certain parameter, which would then cause problems in the derivation of black hole entropy.

In other words...

This is a logical closed loop, somewhat similar to the grandfather paradox of later generations, which is a discussion of who killed whom.

As expected.

Just as Chen Ning Yang had expected, Xu Yun on the other end of the phone only pondered for a very short while before quickly replying:

"Mr. Yang, I think you may have fallen into a misconception."

Chen Ning Yang raised an eyebrow and tapped his pen erratically on the table a few times:

What misconception?

Xu Yun wrote down the exact same formula as Chen Ning Yang on the paper, and circled another parameter:

"The frequencies in black hole radiation are not quantum frequencies, but mechanical frequencies."

Chen Ning Yang stopped abruptly, his pen poking at the paper, and turned his gaze back to his Deduction Process.

Not quantum frequency?

At the same time, Xu Yun on the other end of the phone said:

"Mr. Yang, as you said, in quantum mechanics, energy must be an integer multiple of h. There is no energy quantum of 0.1h, much less of 0.01h—zero-point energy is an exception, but we will not discuss zero-point energy today."

"But the radiation spectrum of a black hole is a continuous spectrum, and the frequencies are not discrete—because black hole Black-body radiation."

"This problem can also be understood from the formula. The recursion kT=E=hf is actually incorrect. kT=E refers to the average kinetic energy, while E=hf is for a single particle."

"If we think about it from this perspective, do you think it makes sense?"

Although he was pointing out Chen Ning Yang's mistakes, Xu Yun did not underestimate this bigwig in the slightest.

The frequency of black hole radiation is a mechanical frequency.

This is a sharp problem that has tormented many physicists, and countless people have been driven to the brink of despair by it.

Like blackbody radiation, black Black-body radiation is a continuous spectrum, and its frequencies are not discrete, so there is no mechanism that requires ν to have a minimum value of 1.

For example, in the Photoelectric effect, electrons can only be emitted one at a time; you can't say that 1.5 electrons are emitted at once—this is quantum frequency.

In practical applications, however, frequencies below 1Hz are very common.

For example, the Hertz gravitational waves that are currently very popular have a frequency of less than 1 Hz.

Therefore, even if the Black-body radiation temperature is lower than the minimum energy of a single surface particle, it does not mean that particles cannot be emitted.

Over a longer period of time, there will always be radiation on average; at most, the intervals between radiated particles will just increase.

After all, black holes are systems with extreme gravitational fields; they are not the kind of things that can be represented by a single temperature.

Let me give you another example.

An LED is a simple system that operates at two or more temperatures.

LEDs emit different colors of light, and their color temperature can be calculated using the Black-body radiation formula.

But which LED's surface particles feel that temperature to the touch?

The radiation temperature of a black hole is simply the color temperature of the black hole's light, while the temperature of the average kinetic energy of the surface particles is something else entirely. Therefore, the two cannot be considered as a single entity and then solved in simultaneous equations.

Although Chen Ning Yang's vision is not as broad as Xu Yun's now, his comprehension ability has not diminished in the slightest since returning to China.

Upon hearing Xu Yun's suggestion, he felt as if a window had opened before him, and he quickly picked up his pen to face the sunlight streaming into the room:

"Then let's add a Boltzmann constant, kB, as an equilibrium dimension. Entropy, in traditional thermodynamics, can be defined as S=∫dQ/T, where the upper part represents the absorbed heat and the lower part represents the temperature of the heat source, so the dimension is J/K."

"If it's a mechanical frequency, then surface gravity needs to be considered to characterize acceleration, and its dimension can be directly assumed to be LT2."

"For entropy, you can divide by the square of the Planck length to cancel out the dimension of area; for temperature, you can multiply by a factor of '/' (°C)."

More than three minutes later.

Chen Ning Yang picked up the microphone again with some delight:

"Little Xu, it's true! The two match up!"

"Black holes actually do obey the Second Law of Thermodynamics; they both increase entropy and evaporate."

In conclusion...

Chen Ning Yang's tone was filled with endless emotion.

The Second Law of Thermodynamics is an extremely important concept in classical physics.

The originators of this Iron Rule are William Thomson, the Old Tang from the 1850 Instance, and Clausius appears at the end of the instance.

I won't go into too much detail about Old Tang, but Clausius is a very interesting person.

He was the first to propose the concept of entropy, and even at the end of the 19th century, the unit of entropy was the "Clausius," with the symbol Cl.

At the same time, he was also a well-known Little Ox fan in history, a typical figure collector - more than 30 of the handwritten letters about Little Ox in the Newton Museum at Cambridge University were donated by Clausius after his death.

The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that heat cannot spontaneously move from a colder body to a hotter body without causing a change in the surrounding environment.

A system starts from state 1, goes through process 1 to become state 2, and if there exists a process 2 that can return state 2 to state 1 while eliminating the influence of process 1, then process 1 is called a reversible process.

All macroscopic processes related to thermal phenomena (phenomena in nature related to the degree of hotness or coldness of objects, i. e., temperature) are irreversible processes.

In layman's terms, this means that point masses tend to spread out.

Even when constrained by fixed total momentum and fixed total energy, a point mass still tends to disperse to all possible destinations.

To put it simply, it is impossible to create Perpetual Motion Machine of the second kind.

In the future world that Xu Yun transmigrated to, there are many ways to express the Second Law of Thermodynamics. In addition to the statements of Old Tang and Clausius, there are nearly twenty interpretations, including Le Chatelier's description, Carrara's description, and Calaciodo's description.

The Second Law of Thermodynamics cannot be proven at present, but it can be verified.

Now that we've verified it many times, we're almost at the level of [proof].

By the way...

Clausius later irresponsibly proposed the heat death theory, which states that when the entropy in the universe reaches its maximum value, all other energy in the universe is converted into heat energy, and the temperature of all matter reaches thermal equilibrium, resulting in the heat death of the universe.

At that time, there was no longer any flow of energy in the universe; in other words, there was no energy available to sustain movement or life.

However, this hypothesis is no longer the mainstream theory. In 1872, when no one knew anything about quantum mechanics, Boltzmann used fluctuations to expose the flaws in the heat death theory.

However, although the heat death theory is somewhat unreliable or arbitrary, the value of Thermopylae II itself is still very high.

It is a very important part of classical physics, especially after the concept of information entropy appeared. Quantum mechanics has also become associated with thermodynamics—although every year the PRL has anti-thermal-entropy claims, they have all ultimately proven to be largely sensationalist.

Some people hate Thermodynamics II just as much as they hate relativity, while others like to associate Thermodynamics II with philosophical concepts.

But in this day and age...

Thermodynamics is in a very complex stage, especially after it combines with a black hole.

"Little Xu, to be honest..."

Perhaps stimulated by the amount of knowledge he learned today, Chen Ning Yang unusually recalled some things:

"Back when I wasn't really at odds with a certain rival, I did discuss the relationship between black holes and hot second radians with him."

"At the time, we all agreed that black holes do not have entropy. We even discussed whether the universe is a truly isolated system, or even a system that has built itself."

"However, it seems we were thinking a bit too far ahead."

Xu Yun smiled but didn't reply.

Chen Ning Yang's so-called isolated system may seem a bit serious, but it actually refers to parallel universes or higher-dimensional worlds.

Who would have thought that such a Nobel laureate was so immature and eccentric in his youth?

At least in Xu Yun's personal opinion, there is a high probability that extraterrestrials exist in the vast universe, but the idea of higher-dimensional civilizations is somewhat far-fetched.

Then Chen Ning Yang sighed again, it was unclear whether he was lamenting the passing of time or reflecting on the value of knowledge:

"I never expected this, that a black hole, which seems to exist where nothing exists, would actually have a black hole fan."

"If I had said that when I was in school, I would have been hung up and beaten by the teacher."

As they were talking, Chen Ning Yang suddenly asked a question with great interest:

"Little Xu, since black holes exhibit entropy and radiation, do you think some concepts that are already considered to exist might actually not exist at all?"

"For example, the singularity?"

Xu Yun was taken aback.

Singularity?

The singularity that Chen Ning Yang refers to is not some fiction website from later generations, but something derived from the theory of relativity.

A singularity is the point at which spacetime begins to curve infinitely.

Modern science describes singularities as having infinitely small volume, infinitely large curvature, infinitely high temperature, and infinitely large density.

According to the derivation of relativity, there should be a singularity at the center of a black hole.

For example, the supermassive black hole at the center of the M87 galaxy, 5,500 light-years away, which was the first black hole in human scientific history to be photographed, has a singularity that is roughly equivalent to 6.5 billion solar masses condensed into a space smaller than an atom. Its theoretical value is:

0.0000000000000000000000000000000000000000014M.

This isn't even the largest black hole; there's another supermassive black hole in the Milky Way.

I'll say it again.

In later generations, when discussing the size of a sum of money or the weight of an ear, the term "astronomical figure" is often used. This is because any concept related to celestial bodies is represented by numbers that are either so large or so small as to overturn your understanding.

As for the singularity not existing...?

Xu Yun thought for a moment and gave Chen Ning Yang an answer that surprised him somewhat:

"If the singularity doesn't exist, then quantum mechanics and general relativity should have been unified by then, and humanity should have entered a completely new stage of development."

"Quantum mechanics and generalized unification?"

To be honest.

Xu Yun's answer, compared to the rest of today's content, is not particularly shocking.

But

Chen Ning Yang, however, sensed a very special kind of optimism in Xu Yun's words.

That's right.

Optimism.

Chen Ning Yang has discussed the non-existence of black hole singularities with many people in the past. After all, this concept, strictly speaking, is actually a result of the failure of physics.

Therefore, among the people Chen Ning Yang met, the answer was the same for most of them.

If singularities do not exist, then physics does not exist either.

Xu Yun's answer was the only optimistic, or rather, confident, answer that Chen Ning Yang had heard.

Thinking about this...

Another thought uncontrollably popped into Chen Ning Yang's mind:

Xu Yun

Where did this person come from?

At such a young age,

Such a wealth of knowledge

The organization placed such a high level of trust in him, even granting him considerable authority.

You need to know.

This kind of talent cannot be acquired through secret training.

While there might be a slight possibility of secret training for professions like elite soldiers and doctors, theoretical scholars...

Without a sufficient supply of knowledge, how could Rabbits possibly cultivate such individuals?

They couldn't have pulled it out of the crematorium, could they?

However, Chen Ning Yang was well aware that even if he asked the question at this moment, he would most likely not get an answer from Xu Yun.

Of course.

At this moment Xu Yun was unaware of Chen Ning Yang's many thoughts; a thought was also swirling in his mind:

After this whole thing, I reckon I'll be taking Hawking's job away from him.

Note:

After being discharged from the hospital, I noticed my voice was a little unsteady.

End of Chapter
Prev
NovelSummaries
Next

Explore the wiki

Xu Yun
Rabbits
Lu Guangda

Comments

No comments yet.
AboutStatsAPIChangelogStatusContactPrivacyTermsDMCA
© 2026 RandomTranslator·v3.26·RSS