Anduin's judgment was based on a simple premise: if Sirius wasn't lying, there were only two possibilities for why Voldemort found Lily and her husband: either the 'Fidelius Charm' itself had a problem, or the Secret Keeper wasn't Sirius in the first place.
However, in his second year, he discovered that he could not contact Lily, which proved that they were indeed protected by the 'Fidelius Charm' and there was no situation where the curse was broken. At the same time, he also knew that the effectiveness of this Guardian Charm was very strong and could not bypass the rules of secrecy. Whether it was Occlumency, Veritaserum, or torture, the secret could not be known to outsiders unless the Secret Keeper keeping the secret truly revealed it.
Then there's only one other possibility.
Upon hearing Anduin's deduction, Sirius's expression grew even more pained, as if gripped by duty, and he clutched his head with his only hand.
"Stop talking, don't make me recall these painful things. It's all my fault. I betrayed Potter and Lily's trust. I chose the wrong person!" After saying that, Black clutched his head and pressed it tightly against the iron bars, as if he was torturing himself.
"Just as I expected." Anduin ignored Sirius's actions and continued to speculate, "Since you're not the Secret Keeper, then who is the Potter couple's real Secret Keeper? First and foremost, it must be someone you can trust."
"And the people you're closest to are you, Potter, Lupin, Peter Pettigrew. If you weren't the Secret Keeper, and Peter seems a bit timid and cowardly, you probably wouldn't have chosen him. So it's Lupin? He's the Secret Keeper you chose?"
"No, if Lupin betrayed Potter, you would have fought tooth and nail for revenge." Anduin denial, then, recalling the events following Sirius's death after Potter's murder, he immediately realized the key point, "That's right, it's Peter!"
"You've chosen Secret Keeper, haven't Peter? You wanted to fool everyone, but your cleverness backfired. Peter Pettigrew is the real traitor in the Order of the Phoenix, and your new choice is tantamount to directly exposing the secret to the Dark Lord. And after Potter's death, you went to find Peter immediately for this reason—you want revenge?"
After Anduin deduced the sequence of events, the more he thought about it, the more logical it seemed.
When Sirius heard Anduin recount this long-buried past, he immediately trembled and fell silent.
"Looks like I was right, isn't I?" Seeing Sirius's reaction, Anduin was certain his deduction was correct. "Why don't you defend yourself? The one who truly betrayed the Potter couple was Peter; you should be innocent."
"Anduin, you are really smart." Sirius's voice was weak, tears streaming down his face and dripping slowly from his chin. "But if I hadn't suggested changing the Secret Keeper and hadn't believed Peter, Potter and Lily wouldn't have died. I killed them. I'm guilty."
"So you'd rather be locked up in Azkaban and torture yourself?" Anduin found Sirius's thinking incomprehensible after learning the truth. You think you've made a mistake, so you want to torture yourself?
"Only by staying here can I lessen my guilt. Anduin me. Let me stay here to atone for Lily and Potter," Sirius said, his voice choked with emotion. Anduin stirred up his past experiences, causing him immense pain.
"But you are innocent. Locking yourself up here won't help at all. If you really think you're wrong, you should go out and let your actions speak for themselves. You know there are still quite a few Death Eater left outside, and they are all accomplices of the Dark Lord."
Anduin noticed that Sirius had become so negative and dejected, so he had no choice but to patiently persuade him.
"I can't even imagine leaving here, Anduin!" Sirius abruptly looked up at him, his face filled with despair. "I've been here all these years, and I still can't forget the mistakes I made, I can't forgive myself. You should just leave. Let me fend for myself in this dark corner; that's the fate I deserve. As for the other Death Eater, I trust Dumbledore, and I trust you. What you can do on your own, adding me along won't make any difference."
"This..." Anduin hearing Sirius's words. How could someone be so stubborn, refusing to leave prison even though he was innocent?
If Sirius himself is unwilling to go out, then even if he can prove Black's innocence to everyone, what good will it do? Minister Bagnold's promise to him will be impossible to fulfill.
Anduin then continued to try to persuade Sirius, using the allure of the outside world and Lupin, his only remaining friend, but to no avail.
Sirius kept his head bowed low until the very end, clutching it tightly with his hands, showing resistance to everything Anduin.
Anduin could only turn his head away helplessly and look at Minister Bagnold standing to the side again.
At this moment, the minister was still reeling from the shock of the news he had just received. Peter Pettigrew was the Secret Keeper, the real traitor? Bardeno found it hard to believe. After all, the Ministry of Magic had even posthumously awarded Peter Pettigrew the Order of Merlin, First Class, in memory of his death.
If all of this were overturned, the impact could be even greater than releasing Sirius.
However, after seeing the look in Anduin's eyes, Minister Bagnold nodded in support.
After failing to persuade Sirius, Anduin thought of something that might move him.
"Sirius, where's Harry? Are you just going to abandon your godson like this? Potter and Lily are gone, it's your responsibility to take care of their child! Are you really going to let Harry grow up all alone, without any family?"
Anduin finished speaking, he even took out a Magic Photo from his pocket, which was a family photo taken five years ago when he spent Christmas at the Potter family.
Upon hearing his words, Anduin clearly felt Sirius shudder, as if he had touched a nerve.
At the same time, when Sirius saw the family photo that Anduin handed him, he couldn't resist and reached out to take it. Then he stared blankly at the Potter couple in the photo, with Harry already in Anduin's arms.