The Truth: Hirata Was a Cowardly and Selfish Guy
Seeing Hirata shedding tears of self-blame, Yeyue was speechless. If Hirata took all the blame upon himself, he could overcome his grief and start contributing to the class again.
Yeyue didn't care about any of that, since she didn't have to pay anything in return.
I just didn't expect Hirata to be such a pushover. Even though he had made up his mind, after being seen through, he couldn't even do something as simple as this.
"I'm sorry, I said something that made you unhappy. I'll head back now."
Hirata's eyes were vacant, and he got up to leave like a walking corpse.
"Well..."
Yeyue sighed, her expression calm, and said, "Do you think an apology can solve everything? I haven't forgiven you yet. In exchange, I want you to tell me what happened."
"What has made you like this, unable to even do something as simple as shifting the blame onto me?"
If Hirata ultimately cannot move on from his past, Yeyue won't care; she'll simply treat him as a discarded Hirata.
However, having always carried the weight of the class, Hirata could not possibly be without emotions, even when facing someone as disliked as Yamauchi with a smile.
The problem is, these words can't be said to the classmates, nor can they be contacted to the outside world or told to family members.
Hirata could only keep it all bottled up by himself; he desperately needed someone to confide in.
Hirata was a bit pretentious, so since the other party felt guilty, Yeyue continued to intensify their guilt, making it impossible for Hirata to refuse.
"..."
Unexpectedly, Tenyo was so shameless, actually taking advantage of the situation. Hirata opened his mouth, but after a long pause, he finally spoke.
"I'm sorry, I don't have the energy to think about the past right now, and there's nothing I can tell you."
That's definitely being overly dramatic.
She clearly wanted someone to confide in, yet she also wanted to avoid causing trouble for anyone and wanted to bear it all alone.
There are reasons why Hirata has become what it is today.
Yeyue's expression remained calm. "Why don't you have the spare capacity?"
"Why are you asking me...?" Hirata's face darkened; wasn't this an obvious question?
Why?
"Because Ichihashi dropped out of school..." Hirata said bitterly, "You really forced me to say something outrageous."
"Please sit down."
Yeyue gestured with her chin to the seat opposite her, and Hirata hesitated for a moment before sitting back down.
Yeyue said calmly,
"First of all, when I heard the rules for the Dropout Exam, I had already decided that Ichihashi Ruri would be the one to withdraw from school."
"It was also my idea to have Horikita Suzune publicly identify Kouenji as a dropout, so that everyone would lower their guard."
"If we have to find someone to take responsibility, then the responsibility for Ichihashi's expulsion does indeed lie with me."
Upon hearing Yeyue's response, Hirata remained expressionless, as he had anticipated all of this.
After a slight pause, Yeyue continued, "However, if we don't clearly select those to be expelled, then students like you, me, and Horikita Suzune, who shouldn't have been expelled this time, will also face the risk of being expelled."
"The most correct choice is to expel students of lower value, and Ichihashi is the student of lowest value in my eyes."
"Hirata, is it only because you understand this point that you can't shift the blame onto me?"
Hirata didn't ask about the value of Yamauchi and others, and nodded with difficulty.
It was precisely because he had sufficient strength and knew that this was the most correct answer that Hirata found it difficult to criticize the other party.
Although she already knew the Original Work, Yeyue still wondered, "A normal person, like Yamauchi, would definitely blame me without hesitation."
I'd like to know, what kind of events shaped these Values?
The implication is that you're not mentally sound.
Hirata gave a self-deprecating laugh after being subtly mocked, but his eyes were dull and lifeless.
"Tenyo, you know that Karuizawa was bullied in the past, but have you ever faced real bullying?"
"Young Master from a wealthy family like you will probably never have the chance to be associated with those two words in your entire life."
Yeyue did not refute it. Whether in his past life or this life, he had indeed never been bullied and had never witnessed anything.
However, the perpetrators do have their own stance.
But it was enough to be a compliment at this time. Ye Xue said doubtfully, "Have you ever experienced this before?"
"Hmm." As if recalling a tragic past, Hirata's eyes showed some sorrow.
"I've had a very close friend since I was little; we were classmates from kindergarten to elementary school."
"But after we were divided into different classes in junior high, our relationship gradually became distant, and we lacked communication for a long time, which is quite normal."
"Although we can still maintain good relationships, I spend most of my time with my classmates."
"But what's painful is that he seems to be being bullied in class."
"Looking back now, there were several times when he seemed to want to say something to me, most likely pleading for help."
"..."
As he spoke, Hirata suddenly gripped his hair tightly. "No, actually I noticed a long time ago, but I chose to turn a blind eye because I was afraid of being implicated and becoming the next target of bullying..."
"In the end, my friend couldn't take the pressure and jumped off a building. If I had been brave enough to stand by his side, this wouldn't have happened."
"It's all my fault..."
"..."
It is foolish to be unable to muster the courage to resist and instead expect others to lend a helping hand.
It's easy to stand on moral high ground and criticize others for failing to help someone in distress, but only those involved know the immense pressure they face.
Yeyue frowned and said, "That's not your responsibility. You should blame those who bullied you more."
"Yes." Hirata was well aware of this as well, "But I believe bystanders are equally guilty."
Despite the shadows of his past, Hirata is genuinely a kind-hearted person at heart.
But if that's all there is to it, Hirata is at most someone who can't stand bullying, which is why he's always the first to intervene in class issues.
We will spare no effort to maintain the stability of the class and prevent bullying from happening again.
But not to that extent. To this day, he still harbors resentment over Ichihashi Ruri's dropping out of school and is unable to escape that shadow.
Seemingly sensing Yeyue's (Zhao Haohao's) confusion, Hirata's body trembled slightly, and a hint of ferocity flashed in his eyes.
"I know you have questions, there's more to this story."
"I originally thought that once this matter was over, the unrest would end and the bullying would disappear."
"But no, I saw the unfathomable darkness of human nature in that incident."
"A new bullying began quickly. After the person with the lowest status in the class disappeared, the second to last person naturally became the new victim of bullying."
"Those who were originally bystanders also suffered the same fate, and those who did not participate in the bullying also started bullying others to avoid being the last one."
"Um..."
Yeyue was somewhat puzzled.
While it's clear that bullying at Sakurajima has always been a problem and is difficult to solve, it's quite rare to see it this severe.
He also found it difficult to truly empathize with what Hirata was saying.
But to say that this is the unfathomable darkness of human nature is something Yeyue has only witnessed a small fraction of.