Crosswise and Lengthwise Divisions (Part 1)
"I hope that everyone in the village can be like one family, and that everyone can live a good life."
Seeing the determined look in Namikaze Minato, Uchiha Kei nodded.
Namikaze Minato's thinking has always been the same.
Perhaps it was Jiraiya's good upbringing, but many of his ideas are very similar to those of his son, Uzumaki Naruto.
They were all acting in accordance with Jiraiya's will, or rather...
The will of the giant Toad of Mount Myoboku.
That so-called Toad Sage has been living since the time of the Sage of Six Paths!
In a sense, this guy tricked the Sage of Six Paths and his brother into joining forces against their mother, Kaguya.
It's not that this is bad; on the contrary, without this approach, there probably wouldn't be the Ninja World we know today.
But the idea of 'mutual understanding and the elimination of conflict' is really too lofty and goes against reality!
Perhaps the concepts of 'nation' and 'village' didn't exist before, and the break between Asura and Indra, on the surface, also appeared to be one of hatred.
Therefore, the idea of 'mutual understanding between people' is still very valuable and has much room for discussion.
But things are different now; the establishment of the "one country, one village" system has replaced the previous family system.
Issues such as geography and resources also arise.
For example, the Land of Wind is entirely desert, making agriculture impossible. They yearn for an oasis to develop an agricultural economy.
At the very least, we should be self-sufficient, instead of relying on others for sales and causing ourselves to lose a large sum of money every year.
Other countries also have various shortcomings, and it can be said that the seeds of disaster were sown when they were first established as nations and villages.
Smaller countries are even more unfortunate, as they are forced to become the main battleground for larger powers due to geopolitical issues.
Almost every time Ninja war broke out, they were the ones who suffered, simply because they were caught in the middle of various major powers.
In fact, the most likely reason for allowing them to establish their own countries and villages was to use them as a buffer zone, thereby diverting the destruction caused by war.
The major powers showed no mercy, and various wars broke out for the interests and needs of their respective countries and villages.
"Captain Minato, your idea is good, but I must remind you that it's only suitable for the village."
Uchiha Kei pondered for a moment, then spoke earnestly to Namikaze Minato.
"I was talking about the village," Namikaze Minato asked, somewhat puzzled.
"Just the village is enough. Hoping everyone is well is a dream, a great dream."
But even within the village, not everyone will necessarily agree, let alone in other villages.
Uchiha Kei said somewhat cryptically, but he didn't dwell on the topic any longer. "What I need to tell you now is my current understanding of the village. I need to know how you plan to transform the village in the future."
"Please speak, Kei-kun." Namikaze Minato nodded.
He didn't dwell on the meaning of Uchiha Kei's previous statement; he roughly knew what Uchiha Kei meant.
Although he was a little curious about where the kid had found out, he couldn't be bothered to think about it anymore, considering that Jiraiya- sensei liked writing books.
What he was more curious about now was what Uchiha Kei wanted to tell him; describing the village as a melting pot was indeed brilliant.
The village is the furnace, and they are the ingredients inside the furnace.
His vision for the village was that everyone should be closely connected.
"I wonder if Minato has a clear understanding of the current division of the village?" Uchiha Kei said calmly.
"The Hokage, the Konoha High Command, clan Ninja, Commoner Ninja, and villagers—that's the structure of our village," Namikaze Minato blurted out almost without thinking.
Indeed, this division is explicit, even if it's hoped that everyone, every Ninja, has the right to equal dialogue.
However, Namikaze Minato must also acknowledge that some people and some identities are not truly equal.
In terms of clan Ninja versus Commoner Ninja, clan Ninja are inherently more competitive than Commoner Ninja.
Perhaps it's due to my Kekkei Genkai, or perhaps it's because I received a good education from a young age.
From this perspective, there isn't much equality among them.
Namikaze Minato knew that he couldn't actually change these things; all he could do was try to make the two sides get along better.
"Indeed, but have you noticed why we talk about so-and-so in the village?"
My first reaction was, 'Which clan does this guy belong to?' or 'This guy is a Commoner Ninja,' not 'He's Konoha Ninja.'
Uchiha Kei shrugged. "Perhaps you're being too serious, thinking this is just a problem within the village. But in reality, it's not much different outside the village. Take me, for example. If you were an enemy Ninja, what would your first reaction be upon seeing me?"
"Alright, Ninja from the Uchiha Clan."
Namikaze Minato had a feeling that something was wrong, but he didn't know exactly what was wrong. He could only follow Uchiha Kei's lead.
Indeed, Namikaze Minato was led astray by Uchiha Kei, but in reality, he wasn't completely deviated from the original understanding.
This problem is common throughout the Ninja World, once you reveal certain characteristics of a 'Kekkei Genkai Clan'.
Then they'll immediately change you from 'a certain Ninja's to 'Ninja from a certain clan'.
It can be said that the rigid notions caused by fixed identities are the same everywhere, and that's exactly what Uchiha Kei Namikaze Minato thought.
"Have you noticed that the entire Konoha, or rather the entire Ninja, is actually the same? Everyone has been stereotyped."
Uchiha Kei calmly said, "Simply put, this is identity politics. Commoner Ninja and Kekkei Genkai Ninja are actually just a fixed mindset."
Commoner Ninja believe that Kekkei Genkai Ninja are just lucky and have innate power, while at the same time they hate that they occupy the vast majority of resources.
Kekkei Genkai Ninja, on the other hand, believe that Commoner Ninja are inherently inferior and that their role and value are merely to serve as cannon fodder.
Two groups that should both be 'Konoha Ninja' are hostile to each other because of their own identities.
The interactions between Commoner Ninja are becoming increasingly closer to 'their own people,' and the same is true for Kekkei Genkai Ninja.
Gradually, the two groups separated themselves into a narrow space, and only acted according to their own identities. This is identity politics.
If we need to go into more detail, let me give you an example: the Uchiha Clan."
Uchiha Kei took the term 'clan' very seriously, and then he stopped talking and looked at Namikaze Minato.
Namikaze Minato listened quietly, silently processing everything. He suddenly realized that Konoha's current situation was indeed as described!
Not only that, the situation is even more serious!
Uchiha Kei had only just begun when he understood what this guy meant!
A clan—a clan is a key aspect of the identity politics this guy talks about!
The Hyuga Clan, the Uchiha Clan, and other clans such as the Nara Clan, Yamanaka Clan, and Akimichi Clan were all bound by a system of identity politics!
Within large clans of Kekkei Genkai Ninja, they can be differentiated by emphasizing their 'clan,' which can create greater 'isolation'.
The three families of Ino-Shika-Cho are an exception, but even if they band together, they are still relatively isolated from other 'clans'.
Namikaze Minato seemed to understand that the hand that had been severed during the reign of the Third Hokage had been divided into a clan, causing them to begin to isolate themselves.
Once these clans are isolated one by one, it will be a good opportunity for the Third to defeat them one by one, and these Ninja clans will naturally know what to do.
The same logic applies here. Because Kekkei Genkai Clan cannot band together and are defeated one by one, the Uchiha Clan appears even more 'isolated'!
Namikaze Minato events. "How could this be!"
"That's the truth. The First Hokage's dream had already been shattered long ago."
Uchiha Kei sighed, "When the First Hokage established the Ninja ranking system, it was precisely to break down the barriers Kekkei Genkai Ninja and ordinary Ninja, and to put them in the same class."
That was the system of Jonin, Chunin, and Genin. Unfortunately, while the system itself has been preserved, it has lost its practical significance.
What was the most advocated during the Third's tenure? Captain Minato, actually?
"Clan Ninja and Commoner Ninja are equal." Namikaze Minato seemed to utter these words with some difficulty.
At that moment, he seemed to understand, completely understood: the Third Hokage had utterly overturned the First Hokage's policies in order to maintain his rule!
At this moment, Namikaze Minato was in a state of turmoil. He seemed unable to point fingers at the Third's actions, given the extremely dire situation when he ascended to the throne!
Furthermore, he couldn't be truly certain whether the First Hokage thought this way, or whether the Third's actions were rooted in the Second Hokage.
It's all a mystery, a mystery that can't be solved at all!
To be honest, Uchiha Kei didn't know either, but he had learned a lot of things when he was in college in his previous life.
Moreover, in this age of information overload, much of the knowledge he's interested in is available online.
For example, learning how to observe the differentiation within a society is one of the things he has learned.
He's simply taking some of the things he learned back then, shifting his mindset, and applying them to his new field.
In fact, Uchiha Kei discovered that this whole thing could really be incorporated, and once he was incorporated, he also saw many things that others didn't know about.
"That's it." Uchiha Kei sighed insincerely.
Who knows what the Third Hokage was really thinking? He wouldn't let such an opportunity to strike slip by.
"We see the village as a melting pot, but in this melting pot, the Ninja within the village are no longer divided by Ninja ranks, as was the case with the First Hokage."
Instead, it's vertical, dividing everything by various defined political identities.
However, this also creates a major drawback.
Captain Minato, the Third Hokage, and Shimura Danzō —were they Commoner Ninja or clan Ninja?
"Them."
Namikaze Minato's pupils contracted slightly; he had absolutely no idea how to answer that question!
Well, this chapter referenced a comment from a fellow reader named Yun Dou. To be honest, I was quite taken aback by that comment.