Dumbledore put down his knife and fork, picked up his silver teaspoon, and stirred the black tea in his cup.
"My advice is..." He picked up his teacup, took a sip, and looked at Scott, "Your decision is up to your heart."
Scott returned a questioning look.
Dumbledore put down his teacup, smiled, and said, "What I mean is, you can join the Scholars League."
Under Scott's surprised gaze, he continued, "But remember, you'd better treat their [Knowledge Bank] as just a trading platform, making necessary transactions with discretion, and of course, always be careful to maintain your rationality and not be tempted by greed."
He said earnestly, "If you can do these things, then joining the so-called Scholars League won't have any negative impact on you."
Scott, wanting to know more, so he said, "It seems this organization isn't as harmless as Miss Grubbly-Plank said."
"The Scholars League is led by seven wizards who have earned the title of 'Grand Scholar,' and Nico was once one of them," Dumbledore said. "Since Nico's death, I have been unable to obtain any information about them."
Scott listened quietly to his story.
Dumbledore gave him some more useful information.
I can tell you two things.
"First, Nicole had hinted that there were also ideological differences among the [Grand Scholar] who led the Scholars League."
"Secondly, Nico once showed me some things that could be redeemed with credits within that organization, and after seeing them, I was actually glad I didn't join them."
"Could you please elaborate?" Scott requested, dissatisfied with the somewhat vague information he had received.
Dumbledore did not refuse Scott's request and explained the situation to him in detail.
"Nico initially joined the Scholars League simply to exchange Alchemy, but as he lived longer and his fame grew, he eventually earned the title of 'Grand Scholar.'"
"Over a hundred years ago, at the initiative of another [Grand Scholar], seven [Grand Scholar] at the time collaborated to create what they called the ultimate masterpiece of fusion magic rituals and Alchemy —the [Knowledge Bank]."
"The emergence of the Knowledge Bank was initially a good thing for the Scholars League. That magical device, which could be called a great one, facilitated communication among the members of the society and brought the previously loosely organized members together more closely."
"More importantly, its existence allows the Scholars League to better preserve the wisdom of wizarding civilization, and also makes it easier for this magical society to achieve its goal of passing on wizarding civilization."
"But there must be a 'but' next," Scott thought.
As he expected, Dumbledore immediately said, "But."
"However, in the decades following the emergence of the [Knowledge Bank], two different schools of thought emerged among the members of the Scholars League."
"Some wizards believe that they only need to remain unknown, gather the wisdom of the masses, and devote themselves to research. When they have new knowledge that is beneficial to the overall wizarding civilization, they should secretly promote it and subtly drive the wizarding civilization forward."
"Another group of wizards believes that the advancement of a civilization requires the best of the best to step forward and guide the ordinary masses. They believe that the Scholars League, who gather the wisdom of many and possess profound knowledge, should step forward to become the leaders of the wizards."
Indeed, wherever there are people, there is conflict.
Scott thought.
Even within the same organization, it's unlikely to have absolutely unified ideas, especially an ancient magical society like the Scholars League.
Dumbledore stopped there.
He ate a few bites of cream cake and drank half a cup of black tea before speaking again.
He asked Scott with great interest, "I'd like to hear your thoughts, Scott. Which of these two schools of thought do you think is more correct?"
Scott thought for a moment and replied, "Their ideas are both right and wrong."
"Oh?" Dumbledore looked at him curiously.
Scott explained, "If their ideas could actually be realized, they could indeed promote the development of wizarding civilization. Their differences lie only in their methods of achieving their goals, so I would say that their ideas are both correct."
Dumbledore nodded slightly upon hearing this, then asked him, "Then why do you say they are all wrong?"
Scott said without hesitation, "Because they take it for granted that they are superior to everyone else, looking down on everything and arbitrarily deciding how to advance civilization. This is absolute arrogance."
Dumbledore looked surprised, seemingly not expecting Scott to say that.
He asked, "Do you think wizards who hold the first view are also arrogant? Even if they just want to conduct academic research quietly and subtly promote the progress of wizarding civilization?"
Scott laughed and said, "If their research, which brings together the wisdom of many, can truly advance civilization, wouldn't it be better to publish it openly and be admired?"
He genuinely had some doubts about this, saying, "I think this is an honor, not something that needs to be hidden from the public."
Quietly and unnoticed... subtly and gradually... he always felt that this kind of expression was an awkward and pretentious thing to say.
As well as...
"What historical contributions did they make to the development and progress of wizarding civilization? Without them, would our civilization have been unable to progress?"
"No." Dumbledore blinked gently. "Ever since the members of the Scholars League disagreed on their views, they've been so busy trying to persuade each other that they've neglected other matters."
Scott was speechless.
This Scholars League is even more impressive than he imagined.
While Dumbledore's statement may sound somewhat exaggerated, it is enough to illustrate that the organization has now strayed from its original purpose.
Dumbledore sighed. "For the last ten years or so, Nico has stopped participating in the affairs of the Scholars League. He believes that once scholars' attitudes toward scholarship become impure, the organization established in the name of scholars is completely corrupted."
Scott understood.
He said to Dumbledore, "It seems you don't think much of this ancient magical society, even though they possess the great [Knowledge Bank]."
"Yes," Dumbledore acknowledged. "Nicole isn't worried that they'll cause any uncontrollable trouble, because the magical device he helped build, not some wizard, is the embodiment of everyone's collective wisdom."
Scott understood again.
"Master Flamel is not worried about the knowledge stored in the [Knowledge Bank] being stolen by some wizard."
Dumbledore smiled slightly. "Indeed, that was Nico's proudest creation. He used Alchemy to construct the core of the [Knowledge Bank], which means that the great magical device is flawless."
Scott said, "That is to say, even the [Grand Scholar] who lead the Scholars League today must formally exchange academic credits for knowledge within the [Knowledge Bank]."
Dumbledore nodded again, then said, "Even Nicolas, who has lived for over six hundred years, possesses far less knowledge than he could ever exchange for all the knowledge in the Knowledge Bank."
Scott understood completely.
"It seems I can indeed join the Scholars League," he said. "At least the knowledge transactions in the [Knowledge Bank] are equal and harmless."
At this point, Dumbledore gave him another piece of advice. "Remember, don't let greed blind you."
Scott solemnly agreed.
Dumbledore, instead, spoke of the past, saying, "When I was young, I held different ideas than I do now. I even proposed creating a new world order dominated by wizards for the greatest good."
Scott kept quiet and listened attentively to his story.
"Later..."
Dumbledore's voice became somewhat low and hoarse.
"After experiencing some things, I began to recognize my own arrogance, and at the same time, I began to acknowledge that the world has never needed anyone to dominate it. So I made a new choice and embarked on a different path from that of my youth."
He recounted his past in an extremely brief manner, but his tone conveyed a unique emotion and power.
Then, he quickly smiled again. "Interestingly, it was only after I fully realized what was going on that Nico showed me some things that could be redeemed with credits in the Scholars League."
At this point, he showed an expression of amazement.
"Some things are truly amazing," he said. "I can't help but be glad I didn't join them when Nico first invited me."
He doesn't shy away from the mistakes he made when he was young, and is even relieved that he didn't cause more serious consequences.
"Back then, my younger self might have been blinded by greed, driven by the so-called 'greatest interests,' and used the existence of the [Knowledge Bank] to do some irreversible things."
Scott was somewhat moved.
Dumbledore is glad that he didn't join the Scholars League when he was young, but he doesn't stop Scott from joining now.
This shows that he doesn't trust his younger self, but is willing to trust Scott, who is also young now.
Of course, from another perspective, it could be that he was fully aware of his own destructive power in his youth, but did not believe that Scott could cause any trouble.
But Scott decided to look at the old principal from a more positive perspective.
After that, they started chatting, enjoying their food while discussing lighthearted topics.
After watching as the over-100-year-old Dumbledore devoured five seemingly overly sweet cream cakes without batting an eye, Scott took his leave.
After thanking and saying goodbye to Dumbledore, he went directly out of the Headmaster's Office through a side door on the Seventh Floor, walked through several corridors to Professor Flitwick's office.
Perhaps because he let out a meaty burp as soon as he entered, Professor Flitwick did not greet him with snacks as usual.
Scott, supporting his slightly bloated stomach, sat down and told Professor Flitwick the purpose of his visit—to explain Grubbly-Plank's invitation and inquire about the Scholars League.
After listening to Scott's account, Professor Flitwick first asked Milton a few questions.
"How is Mr. Graves?" the professor asked with some concern. "It seems that the boy has been regretting losing his musical talent."
Professor Flitwick, who is always sentimental, also has a strong sense of empathy, and he seems to understand Milton's feelings very well.
"I will talk to him," he said.
He wasn't surprised by Grubbly-Plank's true identity, suggesting he had known about it all along.
"Oh, the Scholars League," he said to Scott. "I received an invitation from that organization before, but I turned them down."
Scott asked curiously, "Can you tell me why you refused to join them?"
"I don't approve of them," Professor Flitwick said, frowning.
He seemed to have absolutely no good impression of the Scholars League.
"I don't agree with their system of quantifying all knowledge and trading it as a bargaining chip," the professor said. "I also don't think academic research needs any organization. I believe that I can find more, better, and more like-minded wizards to exchange ideas with on my own."
As he spoke, he looked at Scott again.
"Of course, I don't object to you joining them," he said. "Everyone has the right to make their own choices."
He lowered his head, took a sip of hot tea, and then continued speaking.
"When I was younger, I had a fiery temper, and I would often teach those who mocked me a lesson."
He spoke in a nostalgic tone.
"The wizard who wanted to recruit me into the Scholars League was a German wizard who participated in the dueling tournament with me, and his attitude was far too arrogant."
He began to calmly recount the things that had once angered him.
"I still remember his eyes, his tone. He invited me to join them almost like it was a handout, as if it were the greatest honor I had ever had. Of course, I firmly refused him and taught him a lesson during the competition."
At this point, Professor Flitwick laughed.
"In the days that followed, I also came into contact with some other members of the Scholars League." He lowered his voice as he spoke, "And I even felt that some of the people in this organization were abnormal."
He looked at Scott again, "Just like Miss Grubbly-Plank you encountered, the fact that she would think of using Mr. Graves's matter to threaten you is undoubtedly a disastrous invitation!"
Professor Flitwick shook his head, his expression one of disapproval.
"The wizards of the Scholars League are always like this; they're practically driven mad by the remaining credits on their cards."
Seeing that Scott seemed a little confused, Professor Flitwick explained, "In the Scholars League, credits are everything. Their credits are like a regular wizard's savings account at Gringotts; the amount always causes them anxiety."
Scott nodded repeatedly, indicating that he understood.
He did understand.
In his past life, he had also felt anxious about the money in his bank Cary; he understood that feeling.
Moreover, Grubbly-Plank's way of extending the invitation was not exactly normal; it was downright crazy.
After talking with Professor Flitwick for half an hour, Scott left and went to the Room of Requirement.
He plans to discuss this with his Mentor Ravenclaw as well.