"Soul."
The moment Snape uttered that word, even Dumbledore had to become serious. "A fine tactic indeed."
"We're likely to be held back by this hurdle for some time..."
"Gurgle?"
Just as Dumbledore deep in thought, Fawkes, who had been perched on his shoulder, suddenly flapped his wings and jumped down. His claws gripped the edge of the stone basin firmly, and he waved his beak over the potions before looking at Dumbledore with a pleading expression...
"Uh, no need for that."
He shook his head with a slight chuckle, letting Fawkes jump aside. "Although I haven't tried it myself, it's not hard to guess that drinking this stuff wouldn't feel good..."
"But ultimately, we still need to find a living being with a soul to drink it."
Snape's gaze remained fixed on the potion. "A soul, a mind... perhaps we can bring a few prisoners from Azkaban?"
"Fudge probably wouldn't agree to such a request."
Dumbledore shook his head in denial. "He just wants to serve his term peacefully until the end, and he can't tolerate any trouble for that reason. Taking it upon Azkaban to suggest conducting inhumane experiments on prisoners would generate very negative public opinion against him... Sometimes I even suspect that even if Voldemort were to be resurrected, he wouldn't believe it until he sees Voldemort in person."
"That's outrageous?"
Snape raised an eyebrow, then his mind, honed from his time in the dark wizarding world, began to work. "Speaking of which, if beings with souls can drink these potions... then if I had a bowl-shaped Horcrux, could I move it away?"
"Dumbledore, what do you think of that bottle you used to seal Voldemort's soul?"
"..."
Dumbledore momentarily at a loss for words when it came to how to evaluate the idea.
"... no."
After a moment of stunned silence at the idea, he slowly shook his head and explained, "Putting aside the fact that this idea is just a conjecture without any basis yet, the device that suppresses Voldemort's soul must not be touched carelessly—this potion alone has already proven how highly accomplished he is in the field of soul magic. How could I dare to use him directly for experiments in the soul realm?"
"So what do you plan to do? You don't mean you want to drink it yourself, do you?"
"Ha, please, Severus —I want to live a few more years."
Dumbledore shook his head and chuckled, but the smile quickly faded as he looked at the emerald green potions with a deep gaze, "Moreover, after seeing these potions, I have a vague sense of crisis..."
"A sense of crisis?"
Snape was somewhat surprised. "What could possibly make the great Dumbledore feel threatened?"
"Soul magic".
Dumbledore remained intently focused on the potion, his voice low, as if talking to himself. "When Voldemort created these potions and placed them here, he was only in his fifties at most, and for the first fifteen years of his life he had no contact with the realm of the soul. That means he only spent about forty years studying the realm of the soul, and yet he already possessed an attainment that even you and I cannot reach..."
"Do you think this is something one person could do, Severus?"
"..."
Snape did not speak.
"For a long time, the magical world has deliberately avoided the study of the soul..."
Dumbledore, seemingly not expecting an answer from Snape, continued on his own, "Because no one knows where the soul goes after death. Therefore, to study the soul, one must experiment on living people... This is unacceptable to magical society."
"But in the shadows, dark wizards have no such restrictions. They allow themselves to wantonly destroy life—no, it should be said that they don't even have the concept of 'life' as we understand it... Therefore, they can capture living people without hindrance, and conduct experiments and research in their desired fields without any scruples or restraint. Even our understanding and knowledge of the soul largely originates from the research of dark wizards. And this system has been in place for hundreds and thousands of years..."
"The dark wizard's understanding of the soul far surpasses that of us living in normal society."
Snape finally answered without any expression.
"That's right."
Dumbledore nodded heavily. "And soul magic is so direct, so dangerous, so powerful..."
I know what you're going to say.
Snape continued, his tone tense. "This will lead to dark wizards—especially the top dark wizards—becoming unexpectedly powerful, like Voldemort. It will also make the dark wizarding community increasingly bizarre and powerful, difficult to contend with. If this continues, no one can predict how powerful the next Voldemort, or the Voldemort after that, will be, and at that time, no one can guarantee that an even more powerful Dumbledore to oppose him."
"Just like what we're facing now—a few Horcrux are forcing us into a frenzy; a single Potions can put even the greatest wizard in trouble..."
"You've hit the nail on the head, Severus."
Dumbledore subconsciously rubbed his temples, his face showing signs of fatigue. "Solving these problems is far more difficult than defeating Voldemort head-on."
"However, I think this potion in front of us might also be an opportunity, a chance for a normal magical society to come into contact with the soul realm in a way that does not harm humanity—the existence of this potion has already proven that we can use non-living matter to create products that can affect the soul, hasn't it?"
"... You want to study the soul by analyzing these potions?" Snape's brow furrowed even more.
"I think it's worth a try."
"But what about the Horcrux inside?"
"That's our good fortune—time is now on our side."
A smile finally returned to Dumbledore's face, "Since Voldemort is powerless to reverse the situation, and there doesn't seem to be any other dark wizard as powerful as him emerging to regroup—why don't we seize this opportunity, make the most of all the favorable conditions, and contribute more to the magical world?"
"... I see."
"Perhaps I could create a dedicated research topic on this."
He stroked his silvery-white beard thoughtfully. "After all, it's not very meaningful for me to conduct this research alone. I could gather some professors or trustworthy scholars to participate in the research here, and discuss my concerns about the future with them... Perhaps I could also get some students involved?"
"Student?!"
Snape even took two steps back in shock. "Are you crazy, Dumbledore?!"
"It's not as exaggerated as you imagine. The vetting standards for students are exceptionally strict, even stricter than the selection process for Champion in the Triwizard Tournament..."
Dumbledore smiled. "Young people always have some wild and imaginative ideas, and these ideas will be invaluable when exploring unfamiliar territory. Besides, I think it will be good for some students to understand the mystery and danger of the soul in advance..."
"Perhaps one of our gifted students will be of great help in these studies?"