The first to speak was Cole, the head of the marketing team and a staunch opponent of changing the release date. He slammed the thick budget booklet for offline marketing materials on the table, his tone clearly showing his dissatisfaction. "I absolutely disagree with changing the release date! There are less than four months left until the release, and we've already completed more than half of our marketing campaign across all channels. Changing the date would result in extremely high costs."
Cole meticulously listed the details of the losses, presenting a clear and persuasive argument. "Since March, we've already spent $20 million on marketing and distribution. All the lightbox posters in theaters across the US, bus and subway screens, movie trailer inserts, and offline supermarket promotional posters have been produced and deployed. Outdoor screen advertising contracts in major cities are non-negotiable; online partnerships with mainstream film and television blogs and prime-time TV advertising slots have all been finalized; and Matt Damon's scheduled July roadshow, campus fan meetings, and talk Variety appearances are all locked in. If the release date is moved up or changed, all offline materials will need to be redone and rendered useless. Unilateral breach of advertising contracts will incur penalties, and rescheduling artist roadshows will be another astronomical expense. A conservative estimate is a direct loss of over $5 million, money that could have been saved and invested in the new film's production."
"Secondly, the two films don't overlap in target audience at all. There's no need for us to show weakness and change the release date. Changing the Bourne Identity 2 date would be tantamount to publicly announcing that Universal is afraid of the Fox + Disney co-production! 'The Bourne Supremacy' is a hardcore spy thriller with realistic close-quarters combat, targeting adult men aged 25 to 45 who prefer serious plots and realistic action; 'Pirates of the Caribbean 2' is a fantasy adventure and comedic nautical story, aiming for an all-age audience, primarily teenagers and couples. The overlap in audience is less than 20%. Moviegoers can easily buy tickets to see both films; there's no mutual box office split. Why should we back down?"
After Cole finished speaking, half of the executives in the room nodded in agreement. Many veteran distribution executives present shared the same thought: Hollywood's competition for release dates has always been fierce, and major studios shouldn't make meaningless concessions. Moreover, the other party wasn't releasing in the same week as them, so there was no need to be so afraid. After all, if they easily changed the release date, the industry would judge Universal as cowardly, and their bargaining power in subsequent new film negotiations and theater scheduling would be reduced, which would be a loss.
But Karen, the project's production manager, immediately stood up to refute him, her attitude pragmatic and calm, directly addressing the industry reality. "I oppose acting on impulse. All decisions in the film industry are based solely on profit, not on saving face. Saving face is worth less than box office revenue, and head-on confrontations will only result in mutual destruction."
Karen tapped on the projection screen, displaying box office data for the first * Pirates of the Caribbean * film and previews of the sequel. "The first * Pirates of the Caribbean * film started slowly but finished strong, grossing $712 million worldwide. It garnered widespread acclaim, and Johnny Depp's Captain Jack has become a national icon. The sequel boasts increased production costs, upgraded special effects, and benefits from top-tier Fox theater distribution, Disney's global marketing network, and Echo Pictures' established young audience. Industry estimates predict a minimum box office of $900 million, heading straight for the annual box office record."
"In contrast, our first 'The Bourne Identity' film grossed 210 million yuan and was a well-received production, but its scale, general public awareness, and nationwide viewership are nowhere near the level of 'Pirates of the Caribbean.'"
Karen continued her analysis of the pros and cons, her logic straightforward and brutal. "Even if the audiences don't completely overlap, the overall box office during the summer season is fixed. Theaters will prioritize giving more screenings and prime-time evening slots to the more popular Caribbean films, leaving us with only midday and early morning screenings, which are less popular. Moviegoers always prefer blockbuster hits, so we'll be forced to reduce our screenings, ultimately resulting in a box office drop of at least 30%. What could have been a sure-fire profit will end up as a marginal profit or even a loss."
In her concluding remarks, she stated, "It's not that we're not afraid of strong competitors, it's just that there's no need to proactively confront them head-on. Changing the release date isn't admitting defeat, it's about mitigating risk. We don't need to sacrifice the entire project's revenue and profit for the sake of the company's marketing department's reputation. We're all employees, and everything we do serves Universal's revenue; arguing based on personal feelings is utterly pointless."
The two groups of executives argued back and forth for forty minutes, debating from multiple angles, including marketing costs, target audience, theater scheduling, industry reputation, and subsequent industry influence. The meeting room was deadlocked several times. Richard listened silently throughout, taking notes on all the pros and cons.
He knew perfectly well that the losses Cole mentioned were real, immediate cash flow losses, but Karen's prediction of a box office crash meant even greater long-term revenue losses.
The $5 million marketing loss can be made up for at the box office, but it will run into a Caribbean blockbuster, causing "The Bourne Identity 2" to miss out on the chance to be the biggest hit of the year, and it may even become cannon fodder in the summer season, dragging down Universal's annual financial report.
More importantly, Echo Pictures has been on a roll for the past two years, making a series of breakthroughs in horror, art films and commercial films. With competing films released at the same time, almost all Universal projects have fallen short. Richard doesn't want to directly compete with Irene's projects anymore.
Moreover, this time Pirates of the Caribbean 2 is not an ordinary sequel. The other side is obviously aiming for the annual championship, so there is no need for them to be stepping stones on the other side's road to success.
After careful consideration, Richard raised his hand to end the argument and made the final decision. "Based on the voting results, more than half of the voters support changing the release date. The process for changing the release date will be initiated immediately, and the July 23rd summer release date will be abandoned."
Everyone held their breath and looked at him, waiting for the final decision on the new schedule.
"The summer release has been postponed to November 12th, the fall season." Richard finalized the date, slowly explaining the reasons, "All the summer blockbusters have finished showing in November, leaving no major competitors in theaters. The suspenseful spy genre fits the fall/winter viewing atmosphere, adult audiences have plenty of free time, and word-of-mouth is more likely to spread. At the same time, we've allocated special funds to the marketing department to expedite the redo of promotional materials, pay breach of contract penalties, and reschedule Matt Damon's fall/winter promotional tour, minimizing the negative impact of the rescheduling."
With the resolution finalized, those who opposed it were powerless to change it. Universal's marketing department immediately issued an official announcement of the rescheduling and simultaneously notified theaters across the United States to adjust their film release schedules.
When the news Echo Pictures' offices, Robert immediately saw Universal's official announcement and couldn't help but burst into laughter. He grabbed his tablet and walked over to Irene's side. "Universal chickened out! They moved 'The Bourne Identity 2' to November. Now we can at least dominate the entire August release window. No competition for the whole of August, a perfect gap in the release schedule!"
Irene was flipping through the weekly report on the Canada filming of "Brokeback Mountain," smiling calmly, "I expected this. Big companies are profit-driven and would never risk revenue for personal gain. Everyone says we climbed to the top by stepping on Universal, but this time, we were just going with the flow."