Extra: Discerning Good and Evil by Following Heavenly Principle; Gods, Humans, Ghosts, and Demons Follow Different Laws
When only Mu Jingrou remained, seeing her hesitation, Ling Qing spoke directly to the others.
"Everyone, get back to your work. The talisman will be ready in a few days."
"Thank you, Abbot!"
Upon hearing this, Xiao Qian and the others obediently thanked them and left.
At this moment, only Ling Qing, Yan Chixia, and Mu Jingrou remained in the main hall.
What are your thoughts on this period of time, fellow Daoist?
"Life is worse than death..."
A flicker of fear crossed Mu Jingrou's eyes, then she hesitated before speaking.
"But it's better than death."
The instinct to fear death and seek survival is innate; after enduring so much torment over so many days, she has changed a lot.
Unlike when I was imprisoned in the Nether Passage, even when evil thoughts were churning in my heart...
He kept cursing Ling Qing, thinking about how to skin him alive, tear him apart, and burn his soul in flames.
Unless one is trying to break free or attack the formation, they will generally not suffer from the torment of the Demonic Sha.
However, now that he is under a restriction, as long as he harbors evil thoughts, he will be devoured by Demonic Sha energy.
This was a hundred times more painful for her than being in the tunnel.
At first, he felt a surge of malice when he heard Ling Qing doing her homework, and sometimes he would get angry when he saw that Xiao Qian and the others were not as respectful to him as before.
Then the chains will be activated, imprisoning cultivation and subjecting the soul to the torment of Demonic Sha.
After doing this three times, I finally calmed my mind a bit.
Gradually, I've become able to tolerate the contrast and learned how to calm my mind.
Even if you can't turn evil thoughts into good thoughts, you should at least refrain from having evil thoughts in order to avoid suffering.
Later, Ling Qing saw that her temperament had indeed changed, rather than becoming more obsessed with demons.
Only then did he allow her to choose a Lotus Platform from the lotus pond and transmit the Sweet Dew Karma Cleansing Method.
Begin cleansing yourself of your sins and transferring them to the Lotus Platform.
However, she was deeply mired in sin, and during the purification of her karma, her sins often surged and her heart was filled with evil thoughts.
However, if they do this, their cultivation will be restricted by the chains.
However, with the change in mindset and the shift in negative karma, the situation has greatly improved.
Now I can chant scriptures and do good deeds with everyone.
She's become increasingly different from the fierce and arrogant Tree Demon Grandmother she used to be.
"You should know that eliminating evil is doing good, and now the seed of goodness in your heart is indeed growing."
Ling Qing was naturally aware of the changes in her during this period, so she nodded and continued.
"Although you have endured some hardship, fellow Daoist's achievements are indeed extraordinary, which I greatly admire."
After undergoing trials, you will understand the preciousness of life and will no longer treat sentient beings with contempt.
This is also a meritorious act of your character.
"I understand," Mu Jingrou nodded in agreement.
"Even the toughest iron needs to be tempered by fire; this is truly not an exaggeration."
Yan Chixia looked at Mu Jingrou and nodded in agreement.
"Previously, someone complained that Brother Dao was going to great lengths to convert people in this way."
If it were up to someone else, they would simply cut him down with a single sword stroke, and that would be the end of it.
However, it is true that the Tree Demon of the past has already been slain by the Daoist.
However, unlike some others, this fellow Daoist was still able to create a thousand-year-old demon spirit with a heart inclined towards goodness."
Then, turning to Ling Qing, he exclaimed in praise, "Fellow Daoist, you are truly compassionate and compassionate, saving all beings."
"Haha, fellow Daoist, you are mistaken."
Hearing his praise, Ling Qing shook her head and laughed out loud.
"I am merely a Daoist who cultivates his own path. I may have some small acts of kindness in my heart, but I have no great compassion whatsoever."
"Brother Dao, you are too modest."
Upon hearing this, Yan Chixia couldn't help but shake his head and laugh.
"This humble Daoist is not being modest, for this is the path I follow, and I cannot practice the great compassion of universal salvation."
Ling Qing looked at him seriously and said...
"Even if I save the common people, it's mostly because it benefits my own cultivation, rather than because I'm truly benevolent and compassionate, with the common people in my heart."
Yan Chixia was taken aback upon hearing this, because Ling Qing had actually said this more than once before.
I am merely a Daoist who cultivates himself and seeks enlightenment for himself; I have no heart for the world or for saving all sentient beings.
He had initially thought Ling Qing was merely being modest because he lacked strength, but he hadn't expected her to be so serious today, which showed that she wasn't just being modest.
"May I ask the Abbot, what is good and evil?"
After so many days of Demonic Sha training, she naturally knew how to avoid triggering the chains' restrictions.
But they don't understand why this distinction is made, why this is considered good and that is considered evil.
That's a good question.
Ling Qing flicked his whisk, praised it, and then looked at Yan Chixia and said.
"Brother Dao, what do you think constitutes good and evil?"
"I have studied poetry and books since childhood, and I admire chivalry. I believe I have a strong sense of chivalry and righteousness."
During the reign of Emperor Zhengde of the Wuzong Emperor, there was a Confucian sage named Wang Yangming, who was highly regarded by a certain school of thought.
He once said:
The mind in its original state is neither good nor evil; its movement gives rise to good or evil intentions. To know good and evil is innate knowledge; to do good and eliminate evil is the investigation of things.
Yan Chixia pondered for a moment before speaking.
He has only been a Daoist priest for a few months now, but before that he had studied Confucian classics for decades, so his conscience was already set on good and evil.
Seeing that Mu Jingrou seemed a little confused, he patiently explained.
"This is true. The mind itself is neither good nor evil; it is the intention that causes us to make distinctions."
It is self-attachment and ingrained habits that give rise to the distinction between good and evil.
Since intentions arise from the mind, if one wishes to discern good from evil, one should not cling to the self, but return to one's original mind and discern accordingly.
When one understands and follows the principles of Heaven, one is doing good; when one is swayed by emotions, one is doing evil. Thus, good and evil reside in one's own heart.
Then one should do good and avoid evil, purify one's mind, so as to attain conscience and understand morality.
Then one can clearly see that the Way manifests through virtue, and virtue can transform and nurture all things.
Having said that, he paused, looked at Mu Jingrou, and concluded.
Therefore, Yangming School of Mind: following the principles of Heaven is good, while being swayed by external forces is evil.
Good and evil reside in one's own heart, and each person's understanding of the principles of Heaven is different.
When everyone reaches a consensus on good and evil, it can be called a moral standard.
Such actions, which violate morality, are evil; those that conform to the Way and virtue are good.
"Then, were my past actions good or evil?"
I didn't kill Xiao Qian's maids, except for a few who were forcibly killed by me.
The rest were because they couldn't resist temptation and developed lustful desires.
Those who are greedy for money and lustful are, in principle, also violating morality and committing evil.
Such human essence and blood can also help me refine the essence and blood of the Yaksha.
It's clear that even the Yaksha, a demon from the underworld, doesn't object to me killing them.
If I kill them, wouldn't that be eliminating evil?
After hearing his words, Mu Jingrou felt confused again, even though she had just begun to understand the difference between good and evil.
"So, were my actions good or evil? If evil, how evil were they?"
"This... this family used to be known for killing countless people, even the bags used to hold human heads."
It's all because so many people have been impersonating them that they've become a force to be reckoned with.
Logically speaking, those you killed did deserve their deaths, but you do have karmic debts to repay.
If it were up to me to kill, I'm confident I wouldn't have committed such a heinous crime as you.
Yan Chixia hesitated for a moment, "As for why this is so, it is beyond my ability to explain."
"I wonder if the abbot can resolve my doubts?"
Seeing that Ling Qing remained silent but showed no sign of Yan Chixia's suspicion, Mu Jingrou asked.
Seeing her confusion, Ling Qing didn't answer directly, but changed the subject.
"I lost both my parents when I was young, and my grandfather raised me with great care."
Therefore, my ancestor devoted himself to health preservation and prolonging life, hoping to witness the establishment of my family. However, as he grew older, he also passed away.
Later, with the help of elders in the clan, he learned some principles, but continued to live a muddled and aimless life.
Only because my ancestors and relatives did not abandon me, so that I would not fall into evil ways.
Because of these experiences, I am only concerned with living and have no heart to love anyone.
They don't care about good or evil; they only don't abandon people because they love them.
Later, by chance, he acquired a natural art, seeking a method to obtain power from heaven and earth.
However, the course of Heaven is constant; it does not exist for Yao, nor does it perish for Jie. In the words of Yangming Gong, it can be said to be a mind without good or evil.
Heaven and earth are neither good nor evil, and power cannot do good or evil. Therefore, whether one does good or evil is entirely up to my own will.
However, although my mind is uncertain about good and evil, having this power has, on the contrary, inspired by my ancestor's previous thoughts, aroused my desire for immortality.
However, although this technique is wonderful, it only provides a way to prolong life, but not a way to achieve immortality.
Then I heard that there were many cultivators practicing Daoism in the ancient temples deep in the mountains, and that they possessed miraculous methods for achieving immortality.
I immediately went to seek the knowledge, and fortunately, the master was compassionate and accepted me as a disciple. After chopping wood for a year and a half, he finally taught me the wonderful formula and also instructed me in morality.
From then on, I came to know that the Dao values life and offers boundless salvation to all beings.
I have come to realize that all sentient beings possess a spirit, and that we should purify ourselves, refrain from falsehood, and cultivate our character.
I now realize that if one harbors good intentions and pursues longevity, one should cultivate a benevolent heart and help others achieve their goals.
After briefly recalling her past life and expressing her true feelings, Ling Qing suddenly felt a sense of clarity, as if the clouds had parted and the moon was shining through.
Then, his spirits lifted, he flicked the whisk in his hand, and laughed again.
"You were perfectly fine here. Although you killed someone, you didn't provoke me."
However, I have come to your door, using myself to lure Xiao Qian and the others to kill me. Isn't this just like you using wealth and beauty to tempt people?"
"This..." Mu Jingrou didn't know what he meant for a moment, and hesitated without speaking.
"She used wealth and beauty to entice others into greed, and then killed them."
And you, by using your own life to tempt her greed, can then be said to have killed her."
Seeing that Mu Jingrou was hesitant to answer, Yan Chixia thought for a moment and then said...
"They may seem to be the same, but the results are one good and one bad, so there are naturally differences."
"That's exactly right."
Ling Qing nodded to Yan Chixia, then looked at Mu Jingrou and asked.
"Then do you know what the differences are?"
"Is it because I killed them, and you didn't kill us?"
She thought for a moment and then described the differences that were obvious to the naked eye.
"It exists, but it's not the main factor."
Ling Qing nodded, then shook her head and said.
"The most important thing is the heart, the thoughts of good and evil."
A gentleman once said something like this:
If one intends to do good, the good will not be rewarded; if one does evil unintentionally, the evil will not be punished.
It is clear that whether something is good or evil depends entirely on the goodness or evil of one's intentions.
However, if one does evil unintentionally, even without punishment, it is still evil and has its consequences; if one does good intentionally, even without reward, it is still good and has its merits.
Therefore, the Daoists say: Do no evil, do all good, do not fall into karmic entanglements, and you will always live in a prosperous age.
Furthermore, unintentional goodness is the highest form of goodness.
Therefore, I often advise people: Just do good deeds and don't worry about the future.
However, unintentional evil is a minor evil, but intentional evil is bound to be the greatest evil. Do you understand now?
"The abbot is saying that Crimson Mist killed someone with a kind heart, with the aim of eliminating evil."
And since it was not out of malice, it not only did not cause any harm but actually brought merit.
I killed out of disgust, solely for my own selfish desires; it was all driven by evil lust, and therefore I have neither merit nor demerit.
Therefore, although both involve murder, there is a difference between good and evil.
Mu Jingrou thought for a moment and said that she had a slight understanding of what Ling Qing meant.
"The abbot's actions were actually no different from Master Yan's; he just didn't actually kill us, but prevented us from committing evil."
"Indeed, the reason I say that I have no great compassion lies in this very word, 'heart'."
Ling Qing nodded, flicked the whisk in his hand, and continued speaking.
"I have learned and understand this principle of saving countless people."
However, while the principle is clear, it doesn't mean that it can be put into practice.
I love myself more than I love others, and my concern for my own well-being surpasses my concern for the well-being of others.
One's thoughts and actions will not violate the Master's teachings, but within the bounds of the Master's instructions, one's thoughts and actions should always prioritize oneself.
I am a Daoist who cultivates myself; all my good and evil deeds are simply in accordance with the principles of Heaven in my heart.
My actions align with the principles of Heaven, and therefore constitute good deeds.
If one acts out of anger or resentment, it will harm one's spiritual practice and is therefore an evil deed.
As long as it benefits my spiritual practice, I don't really mind.
I, a humble Daoist priest, have taken in Xiao Qian and the others, suppressed you, and now I wish to convert you. This can be considered an act of kindness.
But my original purpose was not for you, nor for those you have harmed, but for myself.
However, since it was done intentionally, it naturally ended up being a failure.
Therefore, there is only small acts of kindness, but no great compassion.
Moreover, as I told you before, although I have a kind heart, I only extend it to those who have kind intentions.
Many fierce ghosts are trapped on that Earth Sha Tree. Since I, this humble Daoist, seek this act of kindness and merit, why don't I go and help them be saved?
Because he lacks compassion, I cannot save him, so I will not provoke this trouble.
Only those with kind hearts can guide others to abandon evil and embrace good; how can those without kindness in their hearts be guided?
Just like you were back then, if you insist on going your own way, I will never change my ways.
Although you have helped me, I can only send you ashes, and send my last bit of true spirit to a clean and pure cycle of reincarnation.
"And will not attempt to convert others with deluded thoughts."
Between heaven and earth, humans, gods, ghosts, and demons each have their own laws of survival, and each has its own manifest natural law.
As a demon, you can eat the dead without consequence, but that doesn't violate the laws of nature.
Eating living people is fine with me; it doesn't violate the natural order.
This is simply because the laws governing demons are so.
Therefore, some things, such as forced mating, are prohibited.
When humans do it, it's considered karma; but for demons, it's simply natural.
But once a demon gains human nature, it needs to be judged according to human laws.
When it returns to its usual state, there was originally no sin.
But because his heart changed, he committed sins.
Mu Jingrou was a demon; she was born a demon.
There's nothing wrong with killing someone, as long as she believes it's the way of heaven in her heart.
But she learned a great deal about benevolence and morality from the monks in the temple, and learned many principles of being a good person, thus cultivating a kind heart.
But this also became a limitation that bound her.
When she acted with the mindset of a demon but the methods of a human, she naturally incurred sin.
Like the Yin Mountain Ghost King, he broke through the underworld, opened up the realms of Yin and Yang, and sought to Inverting Yin and Yang.
His actions were neither good nor evil in the eyes of Heaven and Earth.
For him, it was in accordance with his own natural principles, and he was doing good, not evil.
But gods, humans, ghosts, and demons are different; for him, this was an act of good in relation to heaven and earth.
But for humans, that is evil.
This is a dispute over racial distinctions, not a matter of good or evil.
As for the realm where gods, humans, ghosts, and demons distinguish between good and evil, treat everyone equally, and universally save countless beings.
Ling Qing might be able to comprehend it in the future, but for now, he only seeks to enlighten himself.
If it is within your ability and others are willing to believe in you, you might be able to help them.
But to say that he should be compassionate is premature.
The word "Human Immortal" implies a degree of closeness or distance in the relationship between people.
Note: I originally wanted to include this in the main text, but it's all preachy stuff and too long, so I gave up.
There are still many things I wanted to express that I haven't finished writing, such as the analysis of gods, humans, ghosts, and demons.
I'll just release it as a side story and add more later when I have time.
In short, Ling Qing is not a saint, nor even a moral exemplar.
He was just someone seeking immortality.
The reason for punishing evil and promoting good, and for converting others, is because doing so is beneficial to them, and the sect's teachings forbid them from doing evil.
Saving all living beings? Let's talk about that when he becomes a saint.
Of course, this saint is not the kind who verbally defends someone or thinks someone is innocent.
Rather, they are saints who can truly resolve issues and quell resentment.
To become a saint, one must take concrete actions.
Making a vow is meritorious, and putting it into practice is virtuous; true merit lies in both saying it and doing it.
Otherwise, no matter how much you say, it's all just empty talk.