Execute? Seal Away? Atone Through Meritorious Service? A World at Peace?
Through the Special Affairs Department and various lineages of Daoism and Buddhism, this study explores the concepts of cause and effect, and the concept of karmic retribution.
People have discovered that, except when a calamity befalls living beings, any act of killing is accompanied by the birth of the original sin.
No matter how justifiable the reasons humanity may find—murderers should pay with their lives, debtors should repay their debts, and the wicked should be sentenced to death, etc.—these are all valid principles.
But those are just subjective human thoughts and do not represent the laws of heaven and earth.
It is not that killing someone is a sin that would result from their impending doom or when they are destined to die.
Just like Xiao Mo, it wouldn't be impossible to kill him now, but since he is not currently in a predicament, killing him would definitely have dire consequences.
Moreover, the sins he committed did not completely disappear, but were scattered throughout the world, to be borne by other people or living beings.
In this way, not only was Xiao Mo's sin not absolved, but another "sin of killing Xiao Mo" was added to the world, and someone had to bear this "evil".
An eye for an eye. If the Special Affairs Department kills him today, someone else may be killed tomorrow for the evil consequences of his death, to atone for this sin.
This person may not be a bad person; they might even be a very kind person.
Therefore, some people feel that killing is insufficient to warn the world, while others do not advocate killing.
Unless the executioner is a practitioner of a special killing technique, capable of killing without incurring karmic consequences.
In this way, no bad consequences will occur, and innocent people will not be affected.
But even if such a method were found, it wouldn't be easy to let people practice it.
The appearance of this type of cultivation technique in the world is almost always accompanied by endless bloodshed.
Whether it's starting a massacre to kill criminals or not, everyone can tell the difference between what's more important and what's less important.
The debate over whether to kill or not was not solely caused by Xiao Mo.
Rather, it concerns other criminals across the country, as well as the guidelines for dealing with such heinous acts in the future.
Xiao Mo was simply caught up in a special period and was used as a typical example.
The biggest disagreement on this matter comes from a group of people within the Religious Alliance and the National Arts Alliance.
Those ruthless killers like the military strategists and legalists in the National Arts Alliance don't care about karma or cause and effect.
So what if the sins have been transferred? Anyone who commits a capital offense should be executed as a warning to others.
This country certainly has no shortage of virtuous individuals who uphold the philosophy of "If I don't go to hell, who will?"
Just like Wu Tiantong, if he were to be condemned to all evil and condemned to eternal damnation in exchange for the world's peace and order, he would absolutely agree without hesitation.
They are not afraid of bearing the sin of killing, and some of them don't even care that the transferred sins might affect innocent people.
They only knew that eliminating evil could both promote good and warn against evil.
Compared to the sins of killing, the sins scattered by wicked people.
In their view, truly eradicating evil means making others aware of it and reducing crime.
This statement is not wrong in itself, but the Religious Alliance's statement that not killing does not necessarily mean abolishing death, but rather valuing life.
Their main concern is that simply resorting to killing will not effectively solve the problem of accumulated sins in the world.
Even if the rate of increase in sin is reduced, sin will only increase if it is not eradicated.
Until a certain limit is reached, it will trigger a massacre to cleanse the world of its sins.
At that time, regardless of good or evil, innocent or not, everyone will be drawn into this catastrophe and will be forced to pay for their sins with even more lives.
At that time, the killing spree will not care whether you are good or evil.
If you carry the burden of karma and sins, you must cleanse yourself with your own life or the life of someone else.
Therefore, the Religious Alliance believes that by not killing, no new sins of killing will be created, and those sins will remain with the criminals and will not affect innocent people.
However, this doesn't mean that no punishment will be imposed.
If someone makes a mistake and is treated well, then no one will have any respect for wrongdoing in the future.
The Religious Alliance then proposed two methods.
One is the punishment of sealing off and suppressing enemies, proposed by the Mount Mao sect.
According to the ancient teachings of Mount Mao, apart from zombies, there is no reason to exterminate any demons; their evil deeds will be punished by Heaven.
In other words, no matter how heinous the sins of demons, they will be punished and condemned by the Heavenly Court.
It is unacceptable for others to use the guise of "acting on behalf of Heaven" to commit heinous acts of killing and implicate innocent people.
But there's no reason to turn a blind eye to evil deeds committed by demons.
Therefore, to prevent him from continuing his evil deeds, the disciples of Mount Mao had to seal him away and wait for his calamity to come, when Heaven would surely punish him.
At that time, those who participate will not incur new sins by killing.
When they are punished by Heaven, they will receive merit for atoning for their sins.
This concept is not unique to Mount Mao; most Daoist sects share it.
Needless to say, Buddhists also believe in the boundless ocean of knowledge, and that turning back is the shore.
The other was the suggestion from Daoist Lingguan to atone for one's sins with meritorious deeds.
When people make mistakes, they should correct them and make amends.
If you have killed someone and feel remorse, then you must take responsibility for the sins you committed and not let them affect others.
Then, by atoning for the sin and turning evil into good, one can atone for the crime with good deeds.
In this way, not only are the original sins absolved, but more good deeds can also be shared with others in the world.
There are two methods: one is suitable for the stubborn and unrepentant, and the other is suitable for the repentant and repentant.
They all embody the Daoist principle of valuing life and abhorring death.
However, Daoism also has its moments of using thunderbolts to subdue demons, and Buddhism also has its wrathful King Kong.
Valuing life and abhorring death does not mean that one should never kill under any circumstances.
Whether it's execution, sealing off the area, or atonement for one's crimes, none of these three interpretations are unreasonable.
After much negotiation, the Special Affairs Department finally established a set of guidelines.
That is a crime that has caused extremely serious consequences, so it must be punished by death as a warning to others.
If the impact is not widespread and the person is stubborn and unyielding, then they should be imprisoned and sent to their doom by Heaven when their time comes.
Those who feel remorse can atone for their sins under the supervision of the Special Affairs Department.
However, such people not only need to be strictly investigated, but if they commit the same offense again, they may even use it as an excuse to try to escape punishment.
They will be executed without hesitation, as a warning to others.
As for the criteria for judgment and how to make the judgment, that is a long and persistent process of refinement.
After investigation and verification by the Special Affairs Department, Xiao Mo concluded that the crimes he had committed were not considered to have extremely serious consequences.
This is mainly due to his method of stealing lifespan; without the demonic seed he gave, no one else could use it, and it wouldn't leave endless poison, so it didn't cause too much panic before.
Furthermore, even now people still consider him a kind and charitable person, and few people know about the evil deeds he committed in the past.
Furthermore, he genuinely showed remorse and was not entirely incorrigible.
He also possesses the merit of subduing demons brought from the dungeon, which allows him to atone for his sins.
However, in addition to atoning for his own sins, Xiao Mo also needs to accumulate three thousand acts of kindness and merit to give back to heaven and earth in order to achieve perfection and remove his sinful status.
After resolving these trivial matters, Daoist Lingguan finally felt relieved.
While some may have selfish motives, the majority of people's thoughts and ideas are ultimately for the betterment of the world.
Perhaps this sounds a bit grandiose and unrealistic.
But someone like Daoist Lingguan, who can live a long and immortal life, would never utter such empty and pretentious words.
For them, temporary gains or losses mean absolutely nothing.
If nothing unexpected happens, they will be able to live as long as heaven and earth and shine as brightly as the sun and moon.
And they will inevitably have to live in this world.
A peaceful and tranquil world is surely much more comfortable to live in than a filthy, sinful swamp, isn't it?
Moreover, these filthy sins can fall upon you at any time, as long as you cannot transcend the Three Realms and escape the Five Elements.
If you are at a critical juncture in your spiritual practice, suddenly a sin will befall you.
Not only did you interrupt your original breakthrough, but you're also prevented from making any progress until you resolve this issue. Isn't that disgusting?
Even setting aside the Earth Immortal, some other Human Immortal who themselves have the potential to become Earth Immortal will also offer their support.
Some ordinary people with good intentions will not blindly oppose it.
Aside from those who need to be defiled for their own spiritual practice, or those who have no hope for their future and want revenge, or those who are ambitious and regard all things as straw dogs, sacrificing all living beings for their own sake.
But these kinds of people really can't make any waves in today's world.
Otherwise, this country would have been in chaos long ago.