"Ron, I can never play Quidditch again." Harry said hollowly as the exhausted Gryffindor little lion walked into the common room from Umbridge's office.
"But we were very restrained!" Ron's expression was no less desperate than Harry's. He said painfully, "We did everything she asked, but she still gave you a suspension, saying with a mocking look that King Weasley could continue playing Quidditch."
Harry, upon hearing this, was at a loss for words to comfort Ron was likely even more deeply hurt.
"Why?!" Frustrated, Ron received no response. He angrily clenched his fist. "Hermione Granger, those Harris Training Class she led, and those Slytherin did the same thing as us! Umbridge even forced the punishments they deserved onto us, and Umbridge's reason was that they were misled by us!"
"This isn't Hermione's fault, Ron! Don't fall for Umbridge's tricks. She's doing this on purpose to sow discord among us. Remember the Sorting Hat's song at the start of the school year: Our Hogwarts is in danger, enemies are lurking outside. We must unite, or we will fall apart from within." Although Harry himself was full of resentment, seeing Ron's desperate and agitated face, he restrained his temper and patiently persuaded him.
"Why is it that our Defense Against the Dark Arts class can only read those boring textbooks, while the trainees in the Training Class can train openly and use Charms that are clearly not something students should know? I bet that even the exchange program was a conspiracy by Pureblood like Allen Harris, who are evil to the core, and Fudge and his ilk. Look at those Durmstrang who came here; they hang out with the Training Class every day." Ron became more and more furious as he thought about it, and kicked an Iron Knight in the corridor. The Iron Knight crashed to the ground, his helmet and weapons scattered all over the floor.
Harry quickly tried to stop his friend's agitation, pulling him away down the corridor to avoid Filch's punishment. "Calm down, Ron Umbridge is afraid of Allen. Allen protected us at school, don't forget Hagrid told us personally that Allen stopped Umbridge from doing anything to him. I think that's why Umbridge, afraid to confront Allen directly, had to use Durmstrang's exchange program to get Allen to leave. You see, all her actions started after Allen left."
Harry and Ron weren't the only ones in despair. The next day at Hogwarts, the young wizards having lunch in the Great Hall heard a commotion coming from the Entrance Hall. Students who had finished eating poured out of the Great Hall to see what was happening, and many more crowded onto the Marble Staircase. Bystanders formed a large circle; some looked shocked, while others even appeared terrified.
Professor Trelawney sat atop a suitcase in the middle of the Entrance Hall, wand in one hand and an empty bottle in the other, looking utterly insane. Her hair was disheveled, her glasses were askew, making one eye appear significantly larger than the other, and countless scarves and shawls hung haphazardly, giving the impression of her being dressed in rags. Besides the suitcase she was sitting on, another suitcase lay upside down, as if it had been thrown down the stairs.
Professor McGonagall, who almost never commented on other professors except for Professor Trelawney, often expressed dissatisfaction with her, showed no signs of her usual aversion to her. Instead, she hurriedly jogged over to Professor Trelawney, embraced her, and softly called her name— Sybill —in an attempt to comfort her, letting her cry in her arms. Professor McGonagall's face was filled with pity.
Professor Dumbledore approached slowly, looking down at Professor Trelawney, whose face was streaked with tears and who was trembling on the chest. Harry heard him say, "Madam Umbridge, as the Chief Investigator, you have every right to dismiss my teachers. However, you probably don't have the authority to expel them from the castle; that authority, I suppose—" He bowed politely and said, "Remains with the Headmaster. I wish Professor Trelawney to continue residing at Hogwarts."
Trelawney laughed excitedly, with a slight sob in between.
"Excuse me, Headmaster Dumbledore, while I have no authority to forbid you from allowing her to stay at the school, as the new Vice- Headmaster, I believe I possess similar authority. I can, as Vice- Headmaster, order her to leave Hogwarts again each time you allow her to stay. It seems we need to have a contest to see who has more patience," said Professor Umbridge, a smug smile spreading across her toad-like face that sent shivers down one's spine.
"You—you can't!" Professor Trelawney cried, tears streaming from behind his large glasses. "You—you can't send me away! I've been here for sixteen years! Hogwarts is my—my home!"
"This used to be your home," Umbridge said viciously. "The Minister for Magic has signed your dismissal order. Now, please leave the hall. You've embarrassed us."
Professor McGonagall then pulled Trelawney close behind her and shouted at Umbridge, "For Merlin's sake, you fired her for your power; at least be fair and let her stay!"
Umbridge shifted her gaze from Dumbledore, turning with a smile to Professor McGonagall, "I had assumed that as a senior professor at Hogwarts, you would have some profound insights to offer in the middle of this Entrance Hall, before the entire school. I never expected you to utter such vulgar words!"
McGonagall glanced at the teachers and students watching, then glared angrily at Umbridge.
Umbridge lifted the hems of her skirt and bowed slightly to the surrounding crowd. "I have something to say, please listen carefully. Professor McGonagall, since you have mentioned fairness to me, then let me explain fairness to you step by step."
First-year students are not allowed to join the Quidditch team. This is a rule established by Hogwarts School. When Madam Hooch took the poor Neville Longbottom to the infirmary after his accident, she also made it a rule that anyone who touched a broom after she left would be expelled from Hogwarts.
Professor McGonagall, known for her fairness, not only failed to punish Harry Potter after he clearly violated Madam Hooch's rules, but also, under the pretext of helping Gryffindor win the House Cup, used her status as a Quidditch fan and Headmistress of Gryffindor to take Harry to Hogwarts Headmaster Dumbledore, requesting that he make an exception and allow Harry Potter, a first-year student who had only taken one flying lesson, to join the Gryffindor Quidditch team. She did not consider at all whether young Harry Potter could ensure his safety while playing against other older students on the field.
Instead of upholding the school's own rules, Headmaster Dumbledore agreed to Professor McGonagall's unreasonable suggestion. Even worse, after obtaining her consent, Professor McGonagall bought Harry Potter Nimbus 2000, the only and most advanced broomstick among the four house teams at the time, because of the school's rule that first-year students were not allowed to bring their own Flying Broomstick. Did Professor McGonagall completely disregard fairness at this point? Did she also fail to consider that her actions were unfair to other first-year and previous students?
Our Mr. Harry Potter, under the negative influence of Professor McGonagall, was quite dissatisfied with the new equipment that the Slytherin House team had to acquire to counter his Nimbus 2000, which gave him an edge over other teams. He even tried to look up the relevant regulations to stop Slytherin House's self-protective actions.
This shows how terrible the negative impact of incorrect guidance can be on a student's character. Harry Potter, now, is even lying—claiming that the You-Know-Who has returned—just to get attention!
Professor McGonagall was furious. She pulled Professor Trelawney even tighter with one arm, almost suffocating her, and pointed at Umbridge with the other. "You... Umbridge... Didn't we have Allen Harris back then? As long as the student's flying talent met the requirements, we would all..."
Umbridge, enraged, took a step forward and slapped McGonagall's finger away. "Shut up! You shameless old scoundrel! Don't you know the students from the other houses are all angry but dare not speak out behind your back, yet you dare mention Mr. Harris. Allen Harris here! Compared to Harry Potter, how does Allen Harris's Quidditch talent compare? Ravenclaw took Flying Class before Gryffindor, and he displayed superior flying talent in his very first Flying Class. I checked the school logs; Madam Hooch also reported on Mr. Harris. Allen Harris's performance. Did you show him any appreciation then? Did Headmaster Dumbledore show him any appreciation? If you hadn't broken the rules first, Professor Flitwick wouldn't have had the chance to fight for the opportunity that rightfully belonged to this more talented student!"
Seeing McGonagall speechless after being insulted, Dumbledore tried to help her out. "Madam Umbridge, what you said is indeed a mistake caused by our lack of consideration. Minerva only made a wrong judgment in her excitement upon seeing Harry's talent, but this matter has little impact. After all, students with flying talent can still participate in the Quidditch team in their second year, and we haven't hindered Allen's development in Quidditch because of this. Allen Harris also solved the problem for us regarding Quidditch Match equipment, didn't he?"
Umbridge calmed down and gave Dumbledore sweet smile, "Oh, please forgive my excitement, Headmaster Dumbledore, the Quidditch incident really hasn't had a big impact on the students, so please allow me to continue."
Back in the day, before the Ministry of Magic implemented educational reforms that enforced strict adherence to school rules by students and administrators, do you remember the year Harry Potter entered school? After the Sorting Ceremony, Headmaster Dumbledore personally announced in front of the entire school that students should not enter the right-hand corridor on the fourth floor. However, at the end of the semester, Harry Potter and a few Gryffindor violated the rules personally set by Headmaster Dumbledore, yet he still awarded them an unusually large number of House Points.
Doesn't this mean the other houses are being punished for following your rules? How is that fair to the law-abiding students in the other houses? Oh, Professor McGonagall, don't try to use Mr. Harris. Allen Harris as a shield again. I checked the data from back then. Although Mr. Harris also violated the rule, even though he was penalized, Ravenclaw would still have no problem winning the House Cup with the bonus points he usually earns.
But the Hufflepuff and Slytherin students were genuinely expelled from Gryffindor for following the rules. I would like to ask, Headmaster Albus Dumbledore Gryffindor, is there any fairness in this, as Professor McGonagall Minerva Gryffindor just emphasized? This encouragement of students to break Hogwarts rules is precisely why the Ministry of Magic sent me here—to inherit what should be inherited, to perfect what needs to be perfected, and to eradicate practices that should be prohibited."
Professor McGonagall, panting, said, "You... Umbridge, how dare you accuse Dumbledore like that... The situation was that we were..."
Umbridge, ever the assertive one, pressed on. "Professor McGonagall, you've lived sixty years in vain. Aside from your decent Transfiguration, you've made no significant contributions to education. All you do is boast about your strictness, fairness, and impartiality, acting superior, unable to distinguish right from wrong, and taking pleasure in arbitrarily accusing others. Even Sybill Trelawney in your arms—I've heard you criticize her in front of students on numerous occasions before, and for reasons essentially identical to my reasons for expelling her today. And now you're pretending to be a good person? Professor McGonagall, I know your life story well. Do you even remember your hometown...?" A local Muggle farmer named Doug McGregor? After dating him for a while, you explicitly accepted his marriage proposal. However, after calming down and weighing your options, you were unwilling to give up your job in the Department of Department of Magical Law Enforcement at the Ministry of Magic. Instead, you ran off and rejected him without even telling him the real reason. Three days later, you left without saying goodbye and even married your much older superior at the Ministry of Magic, Alfred Oquart. Clearly, you yourself disregarded fairness and justice for power. I have never seen such a shameless person!
Umbridge deliberately concealed some facts when making the accusations, making it sound like a different story. The reason McGonagall accepted Doug's marriage proposal and then rejected him was because her unhappy childhood marriage to her Muggle father and wizard mother made her hesitant. At the time, stricter International Statute of Secrecy prevented McGonagall from revealing the real reason for her broken engagement. When McGonagall agreed to marry her boss, Eifenstone, who had been pursuing her, Doug, whom she had always loved, had already married another Muggle and passed away. McGonagall herself had left the Ministry of Ministry of Magic to teach at Hogwarts, and Eifenstone had also retired long ago.
Professor McGonagall was so angry that she trembled. She wanted to retort to Umbridge, but in her anger, she could only utter "You, you! Ah..." before fainting. Sybill, who was caught by McGonagall and unable to move or speak because of her anger, was also pulled to the ground and pressed down on the sleeve of Professor McGonagall's black robe.
"Miss Umbridge, if you try again to use wordplay to frame Minerva ..." Seeing Professor McGonagall faint, Dumbledore's usual gentle demeanor vanished. The young wizards watching from the periphery realized they had never seen Headmaster Dumbledore with such an angry expression. He slowly approached Umbridge, and the previously smug and wicked Witch, now facing the world's greatest White Wizard, could only tremble and back away. She sat down on the ground, her voice trembling as she threatened Dumbledore with phrases like, "She is the highest investigator of the Ministry of Magic; you cannot touch me."
Just then, Trelawney, who had just regained her freedom and gotten up, spoke first, "No— Dumbledore —no, it's not worth it. Thank you for protecting me, but I'm leaving. I'm leaving Hogwarts to make a living elsewhere. You should take Minerva to the infirmary." With that, her trunk flew up and followed her, stumbling towards the castle gate.
Dumbledore sighed, his imposing manner vanishing. He strode past Umbridge, who was still slumped on the ground, without another glance at her. He scooped up McGonagall and began to help her toward the infirmary, shouting at the students blocking his way, "Don't you have any homework to do?"