As soon as Allen finished speaking, applause broke out. The wizards in the Training Class were used to clapping for Allen after he spoke, even though they were somewhat reluctant. They could already learn those powerful Charms in the Training Class, and now Allen was going to share some of his knowledge with all the students of Hogwarts. They still felt like their cheese was being moved, but fortunately, it should only be a part that originally belonged to the Hogwarts library.
Besides the students in the Training Class, many other young wizards at Hogwarts clapped enthusiastically. Some of the more outgoing and extroverted wizards even whistled, cheered, and shouted. Allen's words struck a chord with them. Even George and Fred, who deliberately ignored the annoying Percy, felt that the talented Bill might be able to advance even further with these resources. After all, the Weasley family didn't have much of their family collection left for him to study. The twins exchanged a glance, knowing what the other was thinking. "Dumbledore isn't as bad as Allen thinks, but indeed, in this matter, he might be less responsible than we are."
If even Dumbledore's die-hard fans felt this way, one can only imagine how the other students, who didn't know Dumbledore well, felt. After seeing the recent news reports on Television and in the newspapers, Dumbledore's image among them was now tarnished beyond just being ambitious and hypocritical; he was also labeled as narrow-minded and selfish. It has to be said that Allen's words only worsened Dumbledore's reputation among the students.
At the same time, they were very excited about Allen's promise to teach them those powerful Charms. They were glad that, compared to their father and brothers, they might have a new way to improve their strength, and perhaps they would have more options for the future.
The Hufflepuff wizards who were initially opposed to the introduction of new subjects were more or less persuaded by Allen's words. They were no longer so resistant to the new courses that might involve Dark Magic. Perhaps it was their nature that prevented many of them from taking the course, but now that they knew the other party had a legitimate reason, they clearly showed their tolerant nature, and the Hufflepuff no longer felt they should oppose others taking the course.
Those DAs who witnessed Dumbledore resisting arrest to take the blame for them in the Seventh Floor corridor didn't entirely believe Allen's story. They were skeptical and very resistant to Allen's account. They refused to believe that Dumbledore was the person Allen described, and they glared at Allen angrily because they couldn't accept it.
Sitting in the Headmaster's chair, Umbridge felt that today's events were even more exciting than her first Flying Class at Hogwarts. In a short time, Allen had taken her to heaven—to the seat she had always dreamed of—and then he had dragged her down to Hell, taking away her chance to seize Dumbledore's personal belongings.
But now, Dolores Umbridge, invigorated, felt as if he had been pulled back to heaven. Although he had lost the opportunity to obtain those personal items of Dumbledore, his original purpose in wanting to obtain them was to find further evidence to attack Dumbledore. But now, after hearing Allen's analysis, if he could get Allen to agree to publish his remarks... as long as he avoided Alan's final, suggestive statement about the possible return of the You-Know-Who, he was sure he could regain Fudge's approval.
Umbridge glanced at Professor McGonagall, whose eyes were filled with tears, and couldn't help but think that her experience was similar to his own. However, as a staunch supporter of Dumbledore, McGonagall had obviously been pushed into Hell in the end as well. Allen, on the other hand, had reversed his reputation in the eyes of most students through these conversations, making his actions at least outwardly righteous. He didn't try to find or fabricate a situation where Dumbledore had committed a crime, like Fudge and himself. Instead, he directly addressed the most essential and important aspect of Dumbledore's profession.
Thinking this, Umbridge glanced fearfully at Allen, then sat down and waited for McGonagall to slink away with Dumbledore's belongings before closing the Headmaster's Office door. In a fawning tone, she cautiously approached Allen, who was still collecting books, and tentatively asked, "Professor Harris, we are very grateful for your help today in reclaiming the Hogwarts Headmaster's office. I think what you said is very correct and reasonable. Would you allow me to publish it in the Daily Prophet so that more people will know Dumbledore's true nature?"
Allen continued organizing the books without turning around. "Dolores, why should I say it in front of everyone if I don't want to?"
Umbridge hadn't realized that she had unconsciously become accustomed to obeying others' opinions. Grateful for having received permission, she even began to worry for Allen. "Professor Harris, you just warned me to be careful of the world's most powerful White Wizard, but aren't you worried about yourself doing this?"
"Because I'm no longer as afraid of them as I used to be," Allen said calmly.
Umbridge thought that if someone else had said this answer, she would have thought they were arrogant and a madman, but hearing it from Allen made her feel that it was the truth. "Then why did you help McGonagall take those things away?"
"I'm not afraid of them, but that doesn't mean I have to cross the line and completely enrage him. I'm just trying to reason with him." Allen stood up after putting the last few books into his suitcase. "Besides, it's the most basic respect you can show a good person."
There was still a crowd gathered Headmaster's Office.
"It's disgusting! He's manipulating people, Harry. He's enjoying the feeling of being able to control others at will, enjoying the process of making their emotions change according to his wishes." Ron's eyes almost blazed with fire; he was convinced that Allen was just using smooth talk and manipulating people. "I swear he was there with that sinister smile during every plot twist!"
Harry nodded, looking dejected. He did agree with some of Allen's points; many of the older wizards participating in the Defense Against the Dark Arts (DA) couldn't even properly cast Expelliarmus; the frequency and quality of Defence Against the Dark Arts instructors were indeed a major flaw; and this summer before his fifth year, Dumbledore restricted communication with others...
Harry then shook his head. Dumbledore just lost his position as Headmaster to take the blame for him. Allen must have misunderstood Dumbledore. Dumbledore was the greatest White Wizard, so it was normal for him to be so resistant to Dark Magic. Moreover, he was so loving towards his students. Perhaps his methods in handling some matters were not very sophisticated, but Allen couldn't expect everyone to consider everything as meticulously as Ravenclaw. Dumbledore had fought bravely against Voldemort in the Triwizard Cup, and he almost died because he didn't have time to defend himself against Voldemort's magic. How could such Dumbledore be a selfish person?
"Look at those short-sighted people! They're so happy that Allen is going to promote Dark Magic at Hogwarts. Is he going to openly become the Dark Lord to gain their faith? You-Know-Who, Barty Crouch Jr.... Just think about all those people who study Dark Magic, what kind of people are they!"
Harry, following Ron's words, recalled his accidental stumble into Knockturn Alley —the filthy, eerie, and terrifying shop, the chilling old Witch, and the book of Potent Potions that Allen had just mentioned. He had even managed to obtain the Polyjuice Potion recipe from it, but the pained expressions and screams of the figures in the illustrations were unforgettable. And Allen actually thought that such a book wasn't enough... Harry nodded in agreement. He glanced at the indifferent Slytherin standing behind Draco. If those ambitious schemers were to openly learn Dark Magic, they would surely use it for evil.
Just then, Allen, who had just come out of the Headmaster's Office, casually glanced in the direction where Ron and Harry were. Legilimency, now at its peak, allowed him to clearly perceive the thoughts of these wizards who hadn't yet Occlumency. A thought flashed through his mind, and he suggested, "Why don't we prove it? Anyone willing can spar with this group of exchange students who went to Durmstrang. The facts will show how negligent Dumbledore has been in improving your abilities."
"But if they use powerful Charms, there's absolutely no need for a sparring match! They've already learned a lot in the Training Class!" someone questioned, drawing a chorus of agreement.
"Of course, during the battle, everyone can only use the Charms they can learn at Hogwarts." Allen quickly responded, quelling the objections. "The time is set for Saturday, and the location is the Quidditch Pitch. Any student who wants to challenge us is welcome to come and give it a try. Consider it my first lesson."