In the darkness, a voice quietly rang out.
"How many more times are you going to do this?" he asked calmly, but also with disappointment.
"I haven't had --"
My question is, how many more times?
After a long time, he received an answer.
"I have no idea."
"I thought so too." He smiled sarcastically, but it was something he had expected. "But then again, this divine power is so obedient to you, its heartless master, always at your beck and call. Have you ever thought about why? You've already abandoned that body."
"No."
"Why?"
"Vengeance is a matter of course," replied the deity born in a primitive era. "Therefore, it has always granted requests, no matter who they are."
"But there's a price," Konrad Curze Curze said quietly. "It has different arrangements for everyone who calls upon it, and it craves your return to dominance."
Thunder rumbled, but He did not answer. He simply walked deeper into the cave in the darkness, finally plunging the sharp blade in his hand into the body of a ferocious beast. It did not awaken, but instead fell into an even deeper slumber.
"Lorgar Aurelian."
There had been a grudge, but now the dead brother softly murmured its name, his voice heavy with sorrow. The deity sat down, stroking its deformed and tormented body, and remained silent.
Silence reigned in the darkness.
--
He's been here before.
He had been here long ago—but what exactly was this place?
Ruins stained with blood, a sky blackened by smoke and fire, trembling ground, and giants clad in scarlet armor.
Is this a battlefield, or some unknown hell?
He looked around in bewilderment, when suddenly an old face appeared before him as he turned his head.
This person had no hair, and seemed to have been born with such a pale and smooth appearance, resembling a worm. His eyes were deeply recessed in their sockets as if they had been punched, and his prominent brow bones made every gaze particularly sinister.
And those tattoos.
He looked at them with suspicion.
Strange, jet-black, character-like patterns spread down from his left forehead, covering half of his face. Upon closer inspection, they even appeared to be wriggling.
"Is the matter finished?" the man suddenly asked.
He was startled—was this person speaking to him? And for some reason, he felt uneasy upon hearing the voice, and a burning pain shot through his back.
The pain was so real that he immediately turned around, thinking someone was whipping him from behind, but there was nothing there.
"Very good," the tattooed man continued. "But I need you to do one more thing—I hope that when Roboute Guilliman tracks us down here, he'll be just in time to see them take their last breath."
Who? What?
Before he could think, a sudden fog enveloped him. The fog dissipated beneath his feet, chilling him to the bone. Something seemed to be hidden within it, but he no longer cared to look; he simply walked forward, wanting to find that person again.
Admittedly, he had an instinctive dislike for the other person, but he still wanted to know more about Roboute Guilliman.
He seemed to vaguely recall the name, but he happened to be someone who had nothing but fragments like "recollections."
Perhaps I can remember who I am. Thinking this, he hurried forward.
The cold mist was dispersed, but this did not make the things in front of him clearer; instead, it cast an eerie halo over everything. He walked and walked, not knowing how much time had passed, his forehead was drenched in sweat, and the chill seeped deep into his veins.
Then, something appeared.
No, that's not right, it shouldn't be simply called a "thing".
He stopped in shock and fear, a corner of his mind suddenly tensing as if struck by lightning.
What he saw, if described in detail, could be called a deep pit filled with people who were on the verge of death. Some were wearing armor, some were not; some had their hands and feet taken away, some had been skinned alive; countless tortures, born of pure torment, had been inflicted upon them.
And, somehow, they didn't die—but the horror this hell brought him wasn't over yet. The fog continued to dissipate, and more and more deep pits came into his view. Even a rough estimate puts the number at over a hundred.
He trembled uncontrollably, then knelt down, tears streaming down his face in an indescribable outpouring of grief.
He didn't know where this emotion came from, nor did he want to think about such pointless questions at this moment. Ultimately, these people shouldn't be treated this way.
No matter what, they are still human beings.
A low whistling sound came from the sky, but it didn't attract his attention. He was overwhelmed by instinctive grief and remorse that came from nowhere.
He only raised his head when a tall, blue-gold Shadow came to his side.
He saw someone just like him, trapped in sorrow and regret.
The man's short, gray hair was stained with dust and blood, and his armor was covered in marks from swords and spears. He stood straight, silently gazing at the scene before him in the wind that carried the stench of decay and blood.
"Who are you?" was the question he was about to ask, but then he remembered the words of the tattooed man— Roboute Guilliman.
Are you Roboute Guilliman? Why would he do this to you?
Seemingly hearing his question, the blue-gold giant spoke in a low voice. His voice was completely at odds with the pain on his face; it sounded remarkably calm, as if he were utterly detached, yet he could clearly hear the emotions hidden within it.
"Why?" Roboute Guilliman asked, as if addressing him directly.
Another person walked up behind him. This person was wearing the same blue, gold, and white armor as him, but was slightly smaller.
He walked to Roboute Guilliman's side, stood shoulder to shoulder with him gazing into the horror of the pit, sighed deeply, and then answered his question.
"They hate us, sir, so they want to make us suffer terribly."
"I know, Gage," Roboute Guilliman replied softly. "Of course I understand what the Word Bearers want—to vent their hatred, to offer sacrifices, or simply to have their fun—we've seen far too much of that these days. I just don't understand why they would brand my brother's name in the face of all this depraved atrocity."
He pointed to a spot in the deep pit, where someone had meticulously arranged fragments of corpses into a line of words.
[In the name of Lorgar Aurelian, we offer this miracle to you, esteemed Lord of the Five Hundred Worlds, may your people enjoy eternal happiness and peace.]
The man called Gage paused for a moment, "Perhaps, this was precisely his intention?"
"No," Roboute Guilliman denied again. "He wouldn't do such a thing. After the Perfect City, he hated me to the extreme, but this is still not something he would do. Lorgar might attack me, might charge at me with the determination to kill me, but he would never take his anger out on anyone else. He's not that kind of person."
But he's already dead.
"Not yet."
"My lord!" Gage emphasized. "He's dead!"
Roboute Guilliman slowly lowered his head and stared at him.
"Not yet." He repeated very seriously. "He's still there, Gage. Right beneath that skin, Lorgar is still there. I've seen him."
"Your words sound like the ramblings of a madman."
Roboute Guilliman remained silent, seemingly deep in thought, his teeth clenching repeatedly. Finally, he shook his head. A bloody wind swept up from the bottom of the pit, carrying away the last sobs of those inside.
"Perhaps," he said. "Handle it properly. We need to leave as soon as possible."
"We are short-handed, sir."
"The Word Bearers are the same," Roboute Guilliman said calmly. "Since Calth, they've attacked every world along their escape route, without regard for cost. They've gained an advantage over us, just a tiny one, a mere sliver of a lead. Any commander with a brain would have used it for a better purpose, but they haven't. They are now suffering heavy casualties as well, Gage, our comrades are no cowards. We cannot let them down; we must catch up and wipe them out, leave no one alive."
He raised his hand, making a resolute gesture.
"Burn it," Roboute Guilliman said.
And so, he turned and left.
The cold fog swept in again, engulfing everything, but he still did not stand up.
The images from earlier still swirled and echoed in his mind, shattering everything. The agony of thinking destroyed every inch of his remaining rationality, and he howled again, his eyes bloodshot, shoveling his head into the ground.
He didn't know how much time had passed when he groggily stood up and, unsurprised, found himself back under that blood-soaked sky.
He rushed breathlessly to the mirror.
"Why?" Blood trickled from his mouth and nose, his face deathly pale as he gripped the edge of the mirror. "Why...?"
The creature inside did not answer; its wounded body remained bound by the instruments of torture. Whoever imprisoned it here must have been filled with malice, otherwise there would be no way they could have devised such a punishment to torment it.
Realizing this, amidst the agony of contemplation, he burst into laughter. The laughter was sharp and piercing; he fell backward, collapsing to the ground, screaming and rolling around—he was still thinking, though the agony wouldn't allow him to.
But this time, he was determined to rebel.
He's been obeying for too long, why not rebel this once?
So be it, he's dead!
The pain forced him to groan and pound his head, trying to drown out the unbearable, excruciating torture with even greater agony. The immense force shattered his bones time and again, his brains splattering and seeping from his mouth, nose, and ears. The howling wind felt like a million blades piercing through his body.
Even the punishment of slow slicing wouldn't be more severe than this, would it?
He gritted his teeth and continued his stubborn rebellion, disregarding everything. An even more intense pain and rage struck, instantly turning him into a bloody mess and completely shattering the thoughts he had painstakingly acquired in his mind.
However, whether it was a miracle or the prelude to an even greater despair, one question lingered in his mind, never dissipating no matter how much pain he suffered.
Who I am?
It was that simple, but after it echoed in his mind tens of millions of times, it became a new instinct, deeply engraved in his bones and blood.
Even though the pain had spread throughout his body, rendering him unrecognizable and plunging him into a deep coma, the question still echoed.
Over time, it ceased to be just a problem.
"Who am I?" he murmured unconsciously amidst endless nightmares.
The object in the mirror suddenly raised its head, and the iron chains rattled as they tightened to their limit.
It pounced on the edge of the mirror, its posture humble and cautious to the extreme, like a person dying of thirst walking into an oasis in disbelief—it simply couldn't believe it was real.
To confirm, it examined him closely, again and again, until his life was nearing its end, and the process had to be repeated once more, before the withered body in the mirror finally made its decision.
It slowly stood up.
A dry, cracking sound came from its ankles; the instruments of torture demanded it kneel, but it refused. Then, the collar around its neck came into play, and a tremendous force pulled it down, causing it to fall heavily to the ground.
The chains attached to the handcuffs let out a terrible shriek, tightened instantly, and tore his hands apart, forcing him to kneel on the ground with his back completely hunched.
A heavy pressure followed, pressing its forehead firmly to the ground, making it appear as if it were a slave bowing to its master.
A lowly slave.
It slowly clenched its fists, then stood up again—the physiological structure of an ordinary person at this point would probably have been completely destroyed by the instruments of torture piercing their body, and they would have long lost the ability to move.
But it is different; it was once something far beyond ordinary humans. Even though it has been devoured of its flesh and blood, some of its essence has remained.
The person who took everything from it disliked this essential aspect of itself, considering it cowardly and incompetent, but he didn't erase it either. Instead, he bound it within the physical body in some way. It could be said that he turned the last remaining part of the body into slaves and well-trained dogs.
In his spare time, he would loosen his control a little and deliberately listen to the silent wails and curses of his physical body, finding great pleasure in it.
The skin slowly walked to the edge of the mirror, and then stepped out.
In an instant, its form began to disintegrate due to its disobedience, but it ignored it and simply went to the man's side, then lowered its body and approached his ear.
Its voice was taken away long ago to Deceit or incite murder. However, what it does now requires no voice.
Ultimately, it's nothing more than a whisper to itself deep inside.
"Lorgar Aurelian," the skin uttered the answer.
As soon as he finished speaking, it vanished into thin air. A few seconds later, he opened his eyes, trembling.
A mist descended, obscuring the blood-red sky. And so he remembered everything.
--
At first, Lorgar saw a boy.
He had a pair of violet eyes, wide open, as if they were gleaming.
He was perfectly proportioned and handsome, far surpassing the boundaries of beauty, even shrouded in an aura of light—yet he was weeping.
To be precise, it was sobbing.
He knelt on the ground, enduring the whipping. The black, barbed whip lashed his back again and again, but the pain was secondary, for it could not actually injure him. This boy was something extraordinary; a single lash from the whip that would tear an ordinary person's skin would only leave a few marks.
But he will still cry—ultimately, he will still feel pain. However, the greatest pain will not be physical, but emotional.
He didn't understand why he was being treated this way.
"Remember, there will be no next time!" Cole Fallon said sternly. "Never test my patience! Know your place!"
There won't be a next time, Lorgar thought. Because this boy has learned his lesson; he understands that you're just bluffing, and you're terrified by his intelligence and photographic memory. You're jealous of him, but you must establish and solidify your own authority.
Therefore, when the boy recites those so-called truths from the classics as you instructed, he receives punishment.
The whip continued to fall, Lorgar silently counted. Twenty, thirty, forty.
The boy's cries of pain gradually turned into muffled groans, then into long, heavy breaths. Cole Fallon's arms grew increasingly sore, and he gasped for breath, sweating profusely, as if he were the one being whipped.
On the forty-fifth strike, he could no longer bear it and threw down the whip.
"Confinement!" he roared. "You'll stay here until I call you!"
The door slammed shut, and the footsteps faded into the distance.
The boy raised his hand to wipe away the tears on his face, sobbed as he got up, then knelt down again and began to pray in the language of Colchis.
Four powerful beings, four deities seated above the stars.
He recited their names one by one in Colchis, and then innocently asked—why is my Lord unhappy? Why is he angry because I did what He asked?
There was no answer in the darkness.
Lorgar approached the boy and then squatted down.
"Because he's afraid," he told the boy. "He's afraid of you, but he has to control you; he sees you as an opportunity."
The boy, of course, couldn't hear it, and his prayers didn't end until more than ten minutes later. Just then, footsteps sounded outside the door again.
Half a minute later, the door was carefully pushed open, but the person who walked in was not Cole Fallon, but an ugly, old slave.
He was dressed in tattered clothes, and his hands and feet were covered in wounds. He tiptoed to the boy's side, closed the door, and approached him.
"Naero?" the boy called out his name in confusion. "How did you get here? You shouldn't be here! If my Lord sees—"
"--Shh, shh."
The slave quickly stopped him and pulled out a cloth bag, no bigger than half of his palm, from under his tattered clothes.
Its shape had been altered by some fluid, making it look heavy, like an outdated tree branch. The slave handed the small bag to the boy and then smiled.
"I brought you some water. Drink it quickly, he'll definitely punish you again tomorrow. You haven't had any water for at least three days."
"Then what will you do?" the boy asked.
"What? What should I do?"
"This must be your water," the boy said, his tone matter-of-fact, as if he were entitled to know things he shouldn't.
"Slaves work for forty days and nights to receive a small sip of water, and this is at least four of those sips. This is the reward for at least one hundred and sixty days of your hard work. If I drink it, what will you do?"
"Drink up," the slave replied after a while, wiping his eyes. "I'm not thirsty at all."
You're lying.
"I don't."
"I could tell," the boy said, then paused. "Why did you lie to me?"
"I didn't lie to you." The slave sighed. "Since becoming a slave, I've gotten used to thirst. Remember? I told you last time that I used to be a teacher."
"I remember you also said that you became a slave because you taught the wrong things to the wrong people. But I don't understand, Naero, you're clearly right."
The slave was slightly taken aback. "You think I'm right?"
The boy laughed happily, as if the hurt he had suffered earlier had never happened.
With heartfelt sincerity and fervent devotion, he clasped his hands together and said to the slave, "Yes, all people are inherently equal."
"Hush!" the slave hissed again, this time with a warning. "Don't say this to anyone else, or you'll be in big trouble! My views are heresy, and the oath forbids them from being taught!"
The boy was startled, but quickly recovered and began asking more questions. The slave wanted to stop the conversation, but he couldn't, and he could only continue.
And so they talked until dawn, and he taught the boy something quite different from what the boy had learned from Cole Fallon, and then slipped away.
Lorgar stood up.
He knew what would happen next—twenty days, and in another twenty days, the boy would grow into a young man, a strong and intelligent one.
But his mind was still immature, and Cole Fallon cleverly exploited this, deeply imprinting his ideas and authority into the boy's mind for his own gain.
The moment he reaps this benefit will come soon; in twenty days, on the day the boy grows to look like a young man, Cole Fallon will be attacked.
He was taken hostage by some people who hated his violent ways, and the boy killed them all.
From this point on, things became truly irreversible; once the blood of innocent people was stained, it could never be erased.
The boy helped Cole Fallon eliminate his enemies and performed miracles in the eyes of ordinary people, becoming the holder of the oath.
From one city to another, his knowledge gradually increased, and his demeanor ascended to perfection. Anyone who saw him would involuntarily feel joy and happiness, and his followers gradually spread throughout Colchis.
Then he killed Naero.
What are the reasons? There are probably many. Cole Fallon's covert manipulation and instigation; the so-called evil of faith according to Colchis and the people's natural acceptance of killing and bloodshed; the boy's own self-indulgence, only thinking about obeying the will of his so-called adoptive father.
And most importantly, a group of unbelievers. Or rather, the last of the unbelievers.
Not everyone who sees the boy decides to believe in him and his vows. Some people find gods unbelievable, and some want to rely on themselves. They live in the mountains or deserts, struggling but still able to be self-sufficient, and even develop cities.
But this was intolerable to Cole Fallon, so he began to indoctrinate the boy with even more brutal ideas—and surprisingly, the boy accepted them. Thus, amidst the widespread conversion of faiths across the world, massacre after massacre began.
Many cities were ravaged by bloodshed, and those who did not believe in the oath were all beheaded.
Naero watched the whole process, but there was nothing he could do until the very last moment, until the last day before the Emperor's arrival, when the slaves' consciences could no longer bear it.
He overstepped his bounds, attempting to persuade the boy to stop obeying Cole Fallon.
The latter flew into a rage—or perhaps terrified—in any case, he punched the slave, intending to kill him.
Naero did not sit idly by and wait to die; he drew a dagger in self-defense.
It was at this moment that the boy made his move.
By the time he came to his senses, it was all over.
After so many years of preaching, war, and slaughter, protecting Cole Fallon had become almost instinctive for him. So when his master praised him for doing well, the boy simply nodded as before, as if nothing had happened, and left the body of the slave who had brought him water and talked with him all night.
Lorgar Aurelian slowly clenched his fists.
He stared at the boy in front of him, looking at this still ignorant child, and felt a tickle in his throat.
A strange emotion gradually spread through him, and he knew what it was—hatred. Nothing else could possibly incite such malice. He wanted to kill the child right now to prevent anything that might happen because of him.
All of that.
Tears of sorrow, accompanied by a long sigh, streamed down Lorgar's face.
He remembered everything—everything in the truest sense.
From Colchis to the Great Crusade, from the destruction of the Perfect City to the betrayal of Erebus, he was trapped in darkness. His legions were altered, and his body was wantonly possessed and twisted by the Unborn, who used his voice and his appearance to sow lies again and again, causing the Word Bearers to utterly fall.
The endless blood debts originated with him.
From Calth onward, for the next ten thousand years, every bloodshed, every pain, and every bit of despair that humanity has experienced will be attributed to him.
His offspring became lackeys of evil gods, his brothers suffered endless torment because of him, and his father died because of it.
The accusations weighed heavily on him, preventing him from ever recovering. This was just as he deserved; he deserved to be despised and cursed.
But there are always people who know the truth.
He slowly began to laugh, a weak, sorrowful, and manic laugh.
Why would anyone still be willing to fight for him?
Those who had never seen him, those outstanding people, those who could have had better destinies and futures, died in his name.
Starting with Angron Te, and continuing through one person after another.
Chosen, he learned the truth from the Anchorite, trembling with fear, yet he always remained steadfast and did not abandon him to hell.
For ten thousand years, that drop of blood has been passed down continuously.
Tears gradually turned into bloody tears. Lorgar trembled and fell to the ground, his back arched, his hands clasped tightly together, his head buried deep in his arms, roaring like a wild beast.
He hated it all—he hated himself for being a slave, passively submitting to Cole Fallon's control; he hated himself for killing innocent people; he hated himself for not seeing the truth of the so-called Colchis faith sooner.
Once hatred surges, it can never be stopped. It churns within him, bringing before him countless bloodshed and the mad laughter of the gods. The boundless hatred makes him see clearly how each of his children died, and how innocent people were sacrificed by his legions—he sees it all clearly.
All of these things ultimately come down to one name.
Erebus.
As the fog rolled in, it obscured him, and his form gradually changed within it.
The eternal flames of rage melted his eyes, burned his eye sockets, and blazed like torches. A grotesque spiral horn pierced his forehead, dripping with blood, pointing towards the sky. His teeth sharpened, his face contorted with overwhelming hatred and rage. He rose hunched over, black flames rising from his feet, swirling and threatening to engulf his head in the blink of an eye.
A hand pierced the mist and pressed down on his shoulder.
"I won't try to persuade you," the evil god said calmly. "I only want to tell you that your desire for Vengeance will lead you to a wasteland. That is the realm of the dead, and once you go there, you will never return."
Lorgar responded with a roar that was completely inhuman.
"I told you, I won't try to stop you." The evil god released his grip. "That's not why I came here, Lorgar Aurelian, and I won't stop others from seeking Vengeance. But I've been entrusted to bring this to you."
He reached into his robes and pulled out a golden stone.
Lorgar's gaze seemed to be fixed on it.
"Is there a limit to hatred?" the evil god murmured to himself, spreading his palms. "I don't know the answer, but you are the closest I've ever come to that concept of all the wrongfully deceased I've ever seen."
"Your hatred is enough to engulf the entire world, especially your hatred for yourself. You hate yourself, even more than Erebus. Therefore, you want to die, Lorgar. You want to end it all by sacrificing yourself to hatred—but think about it carefully, how is this any different from your past actions?"
"You once dedicated yourself to the distorted faith of Cole Fallon and Colchis, and you also threw yourself into the so-called truth of salvation. What about your own will? Have you ever thought about what you really want to do? But it doesn't matter."
The evil god threw down the stone and turned to leave. In the blink of an eye, he vanished, and his voice became very distant.
"Vengeance is always granted. Make your choice; it's your right."
--
Ten minutes passed in the blink of an eye.
The power of the evil god has faded, and humanity has regained its strength and gained the upper hand.
Karyl Lohars opened his eyes and waited inside the cave. His right hand still gripped the knife, which felt icy cold to the touch.
Konrad Curze Curze's voice rang in his ears, soft and thoughtful.
"The limit of hatred is more like its opposite; everything has its extremes and then reverses. Alright, Father, what is the opposite of hatred?"
"."
"Why aren't you saying anything? Okay." Curze chuckled. "What's next? What will happen? It doesn't seem to be over yet."
Karyl shook his head.
"It's love," he suddenly said.
". What?"
"Next, we'll wait and see which will prevail in his heart: hatred or love. If it's the latter, then he can come back."
The Night Haunter sighed in great annoyance.
"Can't you just say everything at once?!"
"I'm sorry," Karyl said sincerely. "I was just reminiscing. I was once like him, alone in the dark, do you remember?"
"."
No one answered him; Konrad Curze Curze seemed to have vanished. Much later, his voice rang out again.
"I remember," Night Haunter said. "And you were always the one who found me first."