"What about the other families in the experiment? Did any of them have children?"
"No, but there are two families where the pregnancies are confirmed. One is less than a year along, so it's probably the couple's child; the other is two years along, and like the previous couple, it's the offspring of another male."
"I see." Blade Tusk pondered for a moment, then lightly tapped his fingers on the table, causing a 'clinking' sound to echo in the now quiet council chamber.
"Let's hear everyone's thoughts. Regarding this case and this series of experiments with the Sharp Tusk witch doctor, you're the initiator, so why don't you go first?"
"Yes, Your Excellency Speaker, I believe this incident was merely an accident caused by inadequate supervision, and it does not mean that the experiment itself was wrong. The relevant authorities should be punished. Of course, our committee members also had oversights, and I am willing to take the lead in assuming responsibility."
When Sharp Tusk made this statement, the Troll below reacted in various ways.
Those who agree with this include, for example, those who identify with, such as, "Earth Tusk" and "House Tusk";
Some disagree, such as those with Rough Tusk or Boat Tusk;
In addition, the three newly joined witch doctors, Nomen and Finae, were clearly still somewhat bewildered, seemingly not having grasped the full situation immediately.
"Rough Tusk witch doctor, and you?"
"I remain opposed. The lack of effective oversight is not due to negligence on the part of the authorities; rather, it is because the tribes simply lack the environment to implement such changes."
"Neither we nor the public are truly ready for change."
"Your Excellency Speaker, I am not blaming anyone. I simply wish to ask a question to the original proponents, such as the Sharp Tusk Doctor and the House Tusk Doctor, and I humbly request your permission."
"Ask away."
"Alright, then I ask you, Sharp Tusk Witch Doctor and House Tusk Witch Doctor, as promoters of 'family,' 'private property,' and 'sole parenting,' why haven't you established families, owned private property, or raised your own children in the year or so since the bill was proposed?"
"I... I'm just not used to it!" Sharp Tusk, who always had a short temper, replied.
"So, what makes you think that other people will get used to it? Children? Parents? Families? Let alone ordinary people, even among ourselves, who truly agrees with these things? Apart from the Speaker Meiya, who among you here has personally tried it? No one, right? Maybe some have, but they couldn't stick with it, right?"
As he spoke his last words, his gaze fell upon several of the apprentices.
They were all Troll had previously been inseparable, but ultimately broke up because they couldn't control their lust. Yes, neither male nor female could control their lust.
"Night Tusk, as an executive officer of the authorities, I ask you, among those so-called 'experimental families,' how many have truly kept their promise of 'mutual fidelity'?"
"I only have two sets."
"The other seven groups all broke their promises, right?"
"Yes."
"Why didn't you report such an obvious violation? Or did you report it, but you didn't take it seriously, and the committee members who received your report didn't take it seriously either, so it was left unresolved?"
Night Tusk glanced in the direction of Sharp Tusk and opened his mouth as if to speak, but ultimately clenched his fist and lowered his head.
The Sharp Tusk witch doctor was right; he did report it, but deep down he didn't really care.
The Sharp Tusk witch doctor seemed to share the same idea, so the clay tablet he submitted ultimately disappeared without a trace.
"It seems Night Tusk Executor has reported it. Sharp Tusk Witch Doctor, is that right?" Rough Tusk continued to question.
"Yes, it's my fault for not giving it enough attention."
"Your Excellency Speaker, I believe that in the 'family' relationship you Meiya have formed, 'fidelity' has played the most fundamental role as a bond."
"But you heard it, even we self-proclaimed wise, even somewhat arrogant, witch doctors cannot truly take 'loyalty' to heart."
"If that's the case, then what's the point of these so-called 'families'? What's the difference between this new work unit and our traditional relationships, which are maintained by what we would call 'comradeship in arms' today?"
"Is it simply a matter of fixing the varying number of small, intersecting circles that might be composed of 'male-male,' 'male-female,' or 'female-female' into new 'circles' that are like loose sand, fixedly formed by 'two male and female Troll '?"
"Just so they could raise their children, only to let them die like this today?"
From the almost roaring sound of Blade Tusk Rough Tusk, one could hear intense anger, confusion, and resentment.
This Troll, nearing old age, has maintained a gentle demeanor for many years;
Even when he frequently argued with the Sharp Tusk witch doctor, he was almost never seen to lose his temper;
Even if they can't win an argument, they can only sigh helplessly at most.
But today, he was clearly different.
"Sorry. I seem to have gotten a little excited." Seemingly noticing Blade Tusk's observation, Rough Tusk stopped speaking, took a few deep breaths, and said this.
"Yeah, I understand. I even attacked the Troll before, didn't I?"
"Please continue, finish explaining your thoughts."
"Thank you, Your Excellency Speaker."
Blade Tusk, indicating that it was alright.
"Hmph. In short, I believe that such fundamental institutional changes should be left to time to naturally emerge and evolve."
"Instead of forcibly pushing things forward based on our own arrogance; this time an innocent baby died, what about next time? Are we prepared to pay an even higher price?"
"Your Excellency Speaker, I have finished speaking."
"Your Excellency Speaker, I have an objection!"
Having been waiting impatiently for some time, Sharp Tusk raised his hand and, with Blade Tusk's permission, began to refute Rough Tusk's opinion.
"How can you negate all the changes just because one part failed?"
"Yes, I admit there's some truth to what you said—about fidelity, family, and raising children; perhaps we really weren't prepared."
"But what about the others? In the past year or so, nine experimental families, a total of eighteen Troll, do you know what their output has been?"
Do you know how much their productivity has increased?
"Rough Tusk, let me tell you! They produce almost all the resources that would normally take 25 Troll to produce! More food, better clothing, and even charcoal that ordinary able-bodied men disdain to make, and pottery skills that they are unwilling to learn—they actively learn and manufacture them."
"Why is that? It's because of the 'private property system' that you so vehemently disapprove of, because we are actively promoting it!"
"Now you're thinking of erasing all of this with a simple 'we're not ready yet'? Let me tell you! Impossible!"
"Natural evolution? If we relied on natural evolution, where would we get our current lives! Nomen Tribe and Finae Tribe, are you planning to send them away again?"
"Ding ding ding"
"Sharp Tusk Witch Doctor! Watch your mouth!"
"I'm sorry... huff... huff"
"Stop saying things that hurt the feelings of our compatriots."
"Yes, I understand."
"Okay, continue."
"Yes... Your Excellency Rough Tusk Witch Doctor, if we don't actively seek change, will the tribe be what it is now?"
"The hunter system, the full-time Battle Soldier system, and even the new witch doctor system—a crucial factor in our rise—aren't all of these products of proactive change?"
"You deny all change just because one child has died? Then I ask you, how many babies died before these changes, in those days when the tribe was starving?"
"Without the discovery during the three-year pregnancy, and without the policy decisions to protect pregnant women, how many more children would have been lost silently without our knowledge?"
"I'm asking you! Do you want to go back to that era? Back to that time when people lived hand to mouth, ate raw meat, and couldn't even speak properly?"
"But that's no reason for us to ignore the current situation and forcibly change the system! Just because more babies died in the past doesn't mean we can take it for granted that 'one' is acceptable now! This is clearly a situation that could have been avoided!"
'Ding ding ding'
Seeing that the two were once again ignoring meeting discipline and entering into a confrontational 'argument', Blade Tusk's gavel rang out again, interrupting this trend.
"Alright, although both witch doctors acted with the best interests of the people, they still need to follow the meeting procedures."
"Yes, I'm sorry. I got a little excited."
"I'm sorry, but his proposal was really too much."
"Alright, alright, I understand both of your opinions, Night Tusk. Is the 'productivity' that the Sharp Tusk Witch Doctor mentioned truly true?"
"Yes, while the other members of the public are not lazy either, the experimental families are indeed more diligent."
During the 'argument' between the two witch doctors, Night Tusk, who had been cowering like a turtle, answered Blade Tusk's question in this way.
"Is that so? You two witch doctors, and everyone else, do you remember what the Old Witch Doctor said before?"
The attendees exchanged puzzled glances, unsure of what Blade Tusk was referring to.
"I remember it clearly; it must have been the last meeting Old Witch Doctor attended before. He said that Sharp Tusk were too radical and Rough Tusk were too conservative. I think your current debate is a kind of replay of that meeting."
"Let me share my thoughts. The previous experiments were indeed somewhat rushed, and I agree with the Rough Tusk witch doctor on that point."
"Your Excellency the Speaker!"
"Wait a minute, Sharp Tusk Doctor, let me finish."
The Middle Witch Doctor, who was about to argue, fell silent upon hearing this and waited for Blade Tusk to continue.
"However, I also share the view that the Sharp Tusk witch doctor said 'experiments in social change are beneficial to us'."
"Since there are benefits, we shouldn't dismiss them all at once. The point is to identify and correct problems. That's the significance of 'experimentation'."
"Well then, since it does indeed help increase productivity, the 'family experiment' and the 'private ownership experiment' can certainly continue."
"But the public is indeed not prepared for raising children."
"In that case, the concept of family will temporarily remain with 'husband and wife'. All protection policies for 'husband and wife' will be retained, but all additional benefits, such as the fact that married couples can get 'treehouses' first, will be eliminated."
"But their children will continue to be raised by the tribe according to the previous system."
"But what about the females who are already married?" asked Night Tusk, the executive in charge of specific matters.
"While they are temporarily housed in the nursery area to raise their children, it is considered that she is working for the tribe, and the tribe will cover the extra food consumption she incurs for breastfeeding."
"Your Excellency the Speaker"
The shaman with the Rough Tusk asked to speak again, and Blade Tusk glanced at him and readily nodded in agreement.
"Your Excellency Speaker, I believe that private ownership may indeed be beneficial to increasing productivity; but at the same time, isn't this unfair to other citizens?"
"They worked just as hard in hunting and gathering, yet they had to hand over all their harvest to the tribe; but these families who participated in the 'private ownership' experiment enjoyed the benefits of the policy without any risk."
"If this continues, will the public develop hostility towards these 'special individuals'?"
"Yes, I've noticed that too, and I was just about to bring it up."
Caught up
I went on a date today! Hahaha!
Sorry, only one chapter, because the night will be very long~~~~
The girl kept complaining that I ignored her after I came back, so I guess I should make it up to her now.
Hehehe (rubbing hands like a fly) Give me some votes!