Ch. 41Christmas (Thanks to Starwish and Dust for the Flowers, Thank You)
Chapter Summary: “Christmas”
1. Key Plot Points and Events
- A powerful blizzard hits Hogwarts, causing the final Herbology lesson of the term to be canceled.
- Daphne brings Su Yu to the library to encourage him to study, but he spends most of the time playing with her hair while listening to Hufflepuff students discuss the attacks.
- The Hufflepuffs, led by Ernie Macmillan, conclude that Harry is the heir of Slytherin and responsible for the attacks. They cite his ability to speak Parseltongue, his conflicts with Filch and Colin, and his mysterious survival as evidence that he may be a Dark wizard.
- Harry overhears the rumors and confronts Ernie, insisting that he never commanded the snake to attack Justin. The argument becomes heated, especially when Ernie accuses Harry of hating Muggles.
- Shortly after Harry leaves, Justin Finch-Fletchley and Nearly Headless Nick are found petrified. The incident immediately intensifies suspicion of Harry, who is discovered nearby.
- Professor McGonagall clears the corridor and begins organizing the response. Justin is taken to the hospital wing, while Ernie is ordered to carry and fan the suspended Nearly Headless Nick upstairs.
- Su Yu searches for clues but finds nothing useful.
- Christmas arrives with most students gone because of the attacks. Su Yu remains at Hogwarts with Sister Ka, while Malfoy, Crabbe, and Goyle also stay behind.
- Su Yu and Sister Ka spend Christmas morning together in private. Su Yu opens several gifts, including a sweater from Mrs. Weasley, presents from Ginny, Daphne, Luna, and others.
- The Christmas feast takes place in the decorated Great Hall, but Su Yu and Sister Ka remain in the Slytherin common room because Sister Ka is exhausted and unwell.
- Malfoy returns with Harry and Ron disguised as Crabbe and Goyle. Believing them to be his usual followers, he formally greets Su Yu as “Chief,” prompting Harry and Ron to imitate the gesture. Su Yu and Sister Ka struggle not to laugh at their awkward performance.
2. Character Developments
- Harry becomes increasingly frustrated and isolated as suspicion spreads around him. He tries to defend himself but loses control emotionally when accused of attacking Muggle-born students.
- Ernie Macmillan grows more convinced that Harry is dangerous, relying on prejudice, rumor, and fear rather than direct evidence. His insistence on his pure-blood ancestry highlights his insecurity and bias.
- Su Yu remains observant and amused by the confusion surrounding Harry, though he also makes a serious attempt to investigate the latest attack. He continues to act protectively toward those close to him.
- Daphne shows affection and patience toward Su Yu, allowing him to play with her hair while she studies. Her Christmas gift reflects her concern for his safety.
- Sister Ka becomes more emotionally and physically close to Su Yu. Their relationship is portrayed as intimate and trusting, and Su Yu takes care of her after she becomes exhausted and ill.
- Malfoy continues to treat Su Yu with exaggerated respect and remains unaware that Harry and Ron have replaced Crabbe and Goyle.
- Harry and Ron demonstrate both courage and comic awkwardness while disguised as Slytherins, struggling to imitate the formal behavior expected of Malfoy’s followers.
3. Significant Themes
- Fear and prejudice: The students’ belief that Harry is guilty is based largely on rumor, blood-status prejudice, and fear of Parseltongue rather than proof.
- Scapegoating and hysteria: Each new attack increases the pressure to identify a culprit, making Harry an easy target because of his unusual abilities and reputation.
- Friendship and emotional support: Despite the dark events, Su Yu’s relationships with Daphne and Sister Ka provide warmth, loyalty, and comfort.
- Appearance versus reality: Harry’s disguise as Goyle, the false assumptions about his guilt, and the exaggerated Christmas atmosphere all emphasize how misleading appearances can be.
- Humor amid danger: The chapter balances the sinister petrification attacks with comic moments, especially Ernie carrying Nick like a “helicopter” and Harry and Ron awkwardly bowing to Su Yu.
- Christmas as refuge: The holiday creates a temporary sense of peace and intimacy, even though fear continues to dominate Hogwarts.
4. Character Interactions
- Su Yu and Daphne: Daphne studies while Su Yu idly plays with her hair, showing their comfortable intimacy. She later gives him a protective brooch engraved “Safe and Sound.”
- Harry and Ernie: Their confrontation exposes the depth of the rumors surrounding Harry and Ernie’s reliance on blood-status ideology.
- Teachers and students: McGonagall takes control of the attack scene, ordering the crowd away and arranging for Justin and Nick to receive care.
- Su Yu and Sister Ka: They spend Christmas together in private, with Su Yu caring for her after their intimate night and ensuring she has food, warmth, and blankets.
- Malfoy, Harry, and Ron: Malfoy unknowingly treats Harry and Ron as Crabbe and Goyle. When he salutes Su Yu as “Chief,” they imitate him, creating an absurd and revealing interaction.
- Su Yu and Malfoy’s disguised followers: Su Yu recognizes Harry and Ron immediately but pretends not to, enjoying the comedy of their stiff, unnatural behavior.