Ch. 41Fifty Lashes for Each Side
Key events
- Gu Mingyuan gives his account of the fight: Tang Ya, Bei Bei, Huo Yuhao, and Wang Dong entered his South City courtyard without permission and challenged him over his Tang Sect. Bei Bei attacked first; Gu Mingyuan defeated all four, then stopped once they could no longer fight.
- Xu Sanshi provides a city log and Soul Tool footage that largely confirm Gu Mingyuan’s version. Bei Bei also admits he attacked first and lost.
- Yan Shaozhe weighs the incident against the academy’s interest in keeping peace among powerful students and factions. He rules that both sides were at fault: Tang Ya’s group trespassed and initiated the fight, while Gu Mingyuan escalated the confrontation in a residential area, causing serious injuries and property damage.
- The academy agrees to pay medical and repair costs and gives both sides auction allowances. Huo Yuhao additionally receives high-grade Whale Rubber.
- Despite the seemingly even-handed compensation, Gu Mingyuan is forbidden from using the Tang Sect name to recruit, teach, or organize expelled students, and may not expand his organization. He accepts the ruling without protest.
Character developments and interactions
- Gu Mingyuan remains composed and factual, acknowledging his role while emphasizing that he held back. He quietly stops Zhou Sichen from objecting to the restriction.
- Huo Yuhao is physically injured and deeply humiliated by the defeat. He resolves to grow stronger, while Yu Xiaogang reassures him that mastering his Ultimate Ice and Twin Martial Souls may eventually change the balance.
- Bei Bei admits the account is true and focuses more on Tang Ya’s condition than on his defeat.
- Tang Ya cannot dispute Gu Mingyuan’s account and is visibly shaken by how completely her group was beaten.
- Zhang Lexuan initially challenges Gu Mingyuan for injuring Bei Bei, then learns how powerful his abilities have become.
- Yan Shaozhe recognizes the exceptional potential of Gu Mingyuan’s Twin Ultimates and Huo Yuhao’s Ultimate Ice. Concerned that favoritism could destabilize the academy, he chooses a compromise that formally shares costs and rewards but limits Gu Mingyuan.
- Xu Sanshi privately feels apologetic, recognizing that the academy’s restriction falls on Gu Mingyuan even though Tang Ya started the conflict.
Significant themes
- Institutional fairness versus political balance: The academy’s ruling acknowledges fault on both sides but is shaped by the need to protect relationships and maintain order.
- Power and potential: Gu Mingyuan’s Twin Ultimates and Huo Yuhao’s Ultimate Ice mark both as exceptional talents, making their rivalry a matter of institutional concern.
- Restraint and responsibility: Gu Mingyuan claims he stopped once the fight was over, yet the academy holds him accountable for the scale and consequences of the violence.
- Unequal consequences: Although compensation is presented as equal, the restriction on Gu Mingyuan reveals how “balance” can place the greater burden on the less politically connected side.