Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Library
  • Read
    • Popular
    • Charts
    • Browse
    • Categories
    • Wikis
    • Glossary
  • Request
  • Activity
  • Leaderboard
  • Help
Our Apps
  • DaoSearch
  • Narratorr
Social
  • Discord
  • Patreon
Deconstructing Magic at Hogwarts
Chapter 115

The Price of Fairness

4,551 words 15 min read 4 views 1mo ago Source ​
Skip to the end of the chapter
Prev
Next

When Gavin knocked on Professor McGonagall's office door, he had already finished his meat bun.

He shoved the last bite into his mouth, then pushed open the door and went inside.

Four Seeker were standing in the office.

Harry, Cedric, Cho Chang, and Cordelia.

The four people stood in a row, each with a different expression.

Cedric was studying the floor pattern with his head down, Cordelia leaned against the window, and when she saw Gavin come in, the corners of her mouth curved slightly but she quickly suppressed it. Harry looked like he hadn't figured out why he was there, while Cho Chang's expression was the calmest.

"Professor." Gavin stopped at the door.

Professor McGonagall looked at him over her glasses. "Mr. Gu, you're later than I expected."

"I'm doing some magical practice, you know."

Professor McGonagall nodded.

She knew Gavin was learning Animagus, which required a lot of Transfiguration practice to get a feel for it.

This was perfectly reasonable, and she didn't press the matter.

"Mr. Gu," Professor McGonagall looked at Gavin, "I heard from three Seekers that you taught them how to chase the Golden Snitch?"

Gavin frowned. "Excuse me, Professor, I need to understand what happened first."

He turned to look at Cedric, curious:

"How did you lose? Did you throw the game?"

A hint of embarrassment appeared on Cedric's face:

"This is difficult for me to explain to you."

Gavin hadn't expected this answer.

Then he looked at Qiu and asked, "I heard you caught the Golden Snitch in ten minutes?"

Autumn nodded.

"Good luck?"

Qiu laughed, "Of course not."

"That's what Cedric taught you?"

"I didn't!" Cedric immediately denied.

Gavin turned to him. "How did she do that?"

Cedric took a deep breath and began to explain everything.

As he finished speaking, his voice involuntarily rose by half an octave:

"Then she said she was Chinese and very good at math. Don't you think that explanation is absurd?"

Gavin thought for a moment, "I think it makes a lot of sense."

Cedric was stunned. "How does this make sense?"

Gavin ignored him and looked at Qiu: "Your grandfather is a math professor?"

"Um."

"The best university?" Gavin thought for a moment, then considered a possibility, "Wudaokou Vocational Technical College?"

Cho Chang paused for a moment in response.

She was clearly unfamiliar with the name.

After finally figuring out which school the name referred to, she nodded.

Gavin suddenly realized:

"That makes even more sense."

Cedric looked at him and suddenly felt a strange sense of awe towards the mysterious the East.

"But she only heard that one sentence," Cedric, still somewhat unconvinced.

"You've provided the most important direction; for researchers, direction is often more important than the answer."

"But this is Quidditch."

"From a mathematical perspective, the difference is minimal; Golden Snitch won't refuse to obey probability just because he's a piece of sports equipment."

Qiu nodded slightly beside her.

Cedric fell completely silent.

He now deeply regrets having a mouth and just wants to slap himself twice.

Professor McGonagall gently pressed her temple with her finger.

She's done this action several times in this office today.

Now that things are clear, we can move on to the next step.

"Alright. Mr. Diggory, Miss Zhang, Miss Rowle, Mr. Potter, you may leave now."

Several people walked towards the door one after another.

Cordelia glanced at Gavin as she passed by and winked.

Cedric was still lost in thought about life when he nearly bumped into the doorframe.

Qiu quickly pulled him up.

Harry walked away quietly, seemingly still trying to comprehend what had just happened.

The door closed behind them.

There were only two people left in the office.

Professor McGonagall pushed the two competition records on the table in front of him.

One is five minutes and seven seconds, and the other is ten minutes and forty-two seconds.

"This is the duration of the last two Quidditch Match Hogwarts."

Gavin looked down at it and nodded. "Significant progress."

Professor McGonagall ignored the assessment. "Quidditch cannot continue like this."

"Why?"

"Because the game is losing its meaning, the Chaser has just scored a ball and the Seeker has already ended the game, the Beaters don't even have time to figure out which Bludger they're chasing. The time it takes for the spectators to walk from the castle to the course is longer than the game itself."

"This is a problem with the rules themselves."

"And you've made this problem visible to everyone."

"The problem was there all along."

"The staircases at Hogwarts are always moving," Professor McGonagall explained calmly, "But I still don't want students to dismantle them to prove they're illogical."

Gavin thought about it and found the analogy quite vivid.

"Then what do you want me to do?"

"Find a way to change the rules."

"I refuse," Gavin said immediately.

Professor McGonagall clearly hadn't expected him to refuse so quickly.

"You didn't even consider it."

"After consideration, revising a sport rule that has been in place for hundreds of years is a typical thankless task."

"Because some people will object?"

"Everyone will object," Gavin nodded. "Even those who support the changes will object—they'll object that the changes aren't enough, or that the direction of the changes is different from what they wanted. The losers will say the rules are unfair, and the winners will say the rules have lost their tradition. Houses with good Broomstick don't want to restrict equipment, while houses with bad Broomstick want to confiscate Nimbus 2001s outright. Seekers don't want to weaken the Golden Snitch, Chaser wish the Golden Snitch had never existed."

Professor McGonagall remained silent for a moment.

She had to admit that these things were indeed very likely to happen.

Moreover, given the fervor Hogwarts students have for Quidditch, any change to the rules will be debated back and forth for at least an entire semester.

Your judgment is not without merit.

"So I don't want to get involved."

"But if things don't change," Professor McGonagall said worriedly, "The next game might still only last a few minutes."

"Everyone can go later."

"Then in the next game, maybe no one will even go."

"That would save a lot of time."

Professor McGonagall put her glasses back on, moving very slowly, and the oppressive atmosphere immediately rose.

Gavin immediately straightened his attitude.

"Mr. Gu, I'm not asking you to agree now. I advise you to reconsider. Quidditch is very important to many students. It's not just a game, it's part of college life. If all games end in ten minutes, the sport will slowly lose its audience and its participants. You've identified the flaws, so at least you know better than others how to fix them."

"The person who discovers a vulnerability is not necessarily obligated to maintain the system."

"No, not really." Professor McGonagall looked at him, "But things get a little better when capable people are willing to do a little more every now and then."

"As for the objections you mentioned—I can help you resolve some of them."

Having said that, Professor McGonagall didn't try to persuade her further; she knew this might take some time.

"You can go back now."

When Gavin left the office, Cordelia was waiting for him by the window in the hallway.

Upon seeing Gavin emerge, she immediately stood up straight.

What did Professor McGonagall say to you?

"Let me help solve the problem of Quidditch Matches being too short."

"As expected." Cordelia nodded; she had probably guessed it too.

The two people walked forward along the corridor.

The torches on the wall swayed slightly in the night wind, casting their shadows long and short in alternating patterns.

Did you agree?

"No."

Cordelia turned to look at him, asking curiously, "Why?"

"That's too much trouble."

"But you've solved far more complicated problems than this."

"Those things usually don't offend all four colleges at the same time."

Cordelia could not refute this example.

In the Chamber of Secrets incident, she only offended Tom Riddle, but from her perspective, Tom was already dead, and the dead have no right to vote.

They walked up a flight of stairs.

The portraits on the wall are also gathered together, discussing today's match.

An old wizard wearing a feathered hat insisted that ten minutes was enough for a spectacular Dueling, while another knight argued that a duel couldn't be spectacular without casualties.

As they reached the next floor, Cordelia suddenly asked, "What if I also want you to solve this for me?"

Gavin stopped in his tracks.

"You?"

"Um."

Gavin was surprised by her response and asked curiously, "You're probably the last person who wants the rules changed."

Cordelia just won her first match using the current rules.

Moreover, she is very good at math, and as long as the Golden Snitch model is still effective, she has almost no rivals at Hogwarts.

"That's what I thought at first too. I was really happy when I caught the Golden Snitch."

"Then what?"

"Harry came over and said he'd be faster next time. I have to admit he really gave it his all in that race; it was kind of inspiring."

Gavin waited for her to continue.

"Then I realized I wanted to race him again, to see who could fly faster, who dared to chase, who had the quickest reaction, and who could catch the Golden Snitch first."

Gavin disagreed, stating, "Computation is also part of the competition."

"If you were the one riding Broomstick onto the field, of course it would be fair, because you came up with the method yourself. If someone else loses, they lose to your brain." Cordelia paused. "But I'm the one who was told the answers by you. I always feel like I've seen the exam questions beforehand."

Gavin looked at her.

Cordelia's expression was serious; it didn't seem like she was just saying it casually.

His thoughts involuntarily drifted back to the past.

Even during his school years, he believed in fair competition.

The same exam paper, the same time, everyone gets the results based on their ability.

Only after entering society did he realize that the resources, opportunities, backgrounds, and luck that people have from birth are never the same.

So-called fairness often simply means drawing a line that is originally slanted as inconspicuously as possible.

Of course, there was no need to say these things to Cordelia.

He had lost all illusions, but he decided to protect the spirit of the girl before him.

"Okay." Gavin nodded.

Cordelia's eyes lit up. "You agreed?"

"I can help you if you need it." Gavin looked at her, a mischievous glint in his eye. "But you'll have to beg me."

Cordelia stopped in her tracks, frowned, and asked, "How can I ask you for help?"

"At least call me 'brother'."

She stared at him for two seconds, then frowned and said, "You're clearly younger than me."

Age is not the point.

"So what's the key point?"

"Manner."

But you're younger than me.

Is this how you beg for help?

Cordelia pursed her lips. "Choose another one."

"No trade."

"I can give you Galleon."

"I don't need it."

"One hundred."

"This is a matter of principle."

"Five hundred."

Gavin paused for a second.

Cordelia immediately seized on it. "You're interested!"

"No."

You were clearly attracted to him.

Gavin shrugged. "I just didn't expect you'd rather spend five hundred Galleons than call me 'brother'."

Cordelia looked at him, her expression gradually changing from serious to annoyed.

Gavin stood there patiently waiting.

There was no one else in the corridor.

After a long while, she turned her head slightly and spoke in a very soft voice, "Brother."

The sound was so faint that it was almost drowned out by the wind outside the window.

Gavin deliberately asked, "What?"

Cordelia turned her head sharply.

"You clearly heard it!"

"That... the echo in the hallway is too loud."

Her face slowly turned red, the redness spreading from the tips of her ears all the way to her cheeks.

Gavin felt he couldn't pressure her any further.

If pushed any further, a casual stroll and chat might turn into a close-quarters fight, the kind where it's one-sided.

"Okay, okay, I heard you. I'll give Professor McGonagall the plan tonight."

Cordelia glared at him. "You can be really annoying sometimes!"

"Thanks."

This is not a compliment.

I've decided to take it as a compliment.

Cordelia turned and left, her steps noticeably faster than before.

Gavin followed behind, and he suddenly realized that this job might not be as thankless and exhausting as he had imagined.

They've already received at least a portion of the payment in advance, a large portion at that.

The next morning, the Hogwarts bulletin board was packed with people.

At the top of the Parchment was written "Provisional Amendments to the Quidditch Match Hogwarts," followed by the signatures of Professor McGonagall and Madam Hooch.

The main rules remain unchanged; only three items have been added.

[First rule: The latest end time for Quidditch Match within the school is when the Great Hall dinner bell rings. At that time, regardless of the score, the match immediately ends, and the winner is determined by the current score.]

Justin finished reading the first point and nodded:

That makes perfect sense.

Ron looked at him. "Why are mealtimes the rule in Quidditch?"

"Because dinner won't wait for anyone." Justin thought it made sense.

"The competition shouldn't disrupt your normal routine," Ernie added seriously from the side. "This Splinching time management and basic living security."

People around the bulletin board turned to look at the two Hufflepuffs.

It's quite obvious who wrote this.

[Second item: Release gold, silver, and bronze Golden Snitch simultaneously in each match.]

The Golden Snitch is worth 150 points; the match ends upon its capture. The Silver Snitch is worth 50 points, and the Bronze Snitch is worth 20 points; the match continues upon their capture.

The three Golden Snitch could not be distinguished by color, magical fluctuations, or flight characteristics before they were captured.

Note: All three Golden Snitch were subjected to subtle perturbations, making their short-range trajectories even more unpredictable.

For the first thirty minutes of the match, all three Golden Snitches are uncatchable and cannot be caught, bound, stored, or magically restricted. During this period, both Seekers become Free Player, able to perform the duties of Chaser, Beater, and Goalkeeper.

The crowd fell silent for a few seconds.

Lee Jordan was the first to spot the problem. "In other words, the Seeker doesn't know which ball they're chasing until they rush over?"

"Yes." Fred nodded.

"After desperately grabbing it, they discovered they only had twenty points?"

"Right."

Lee Jordan's eyes slowly brightened.

"This is very helpful for the commentators."

"Why?"

"Because I can keep calling it wrong."

George was also very satisfied.

"Until the Golden Snitch is caught, nobody knows if the competition will end."

"Including the Seeker."

"Especially the Seekers."

Cedric, however, discovered another problem. "What does 'subtle perturbation' mean?"

He looked at Cho Chang pleadingly.

Qiu thought for a moment and replied, "It should be about increasing randomness, making it less predictable for the Golden Snitch to follow our route when we're chasing him."

Cedric was quite pleased. "Now I can finally show off my reflexes."

He still felt lingering fear about that bend in the road at Cho Chang.

Cho Chang nodded. "Actually, it can still be calculated--"

"Huh?" Cedric was frightened.

"But now there are three Golden Snitch, the calculation is too much, and I haven't figured out how to solve it yet." Cho Chang was a little troubled.

"Can you stop talking so fast?" Cedric felt for the second time that dating Ravenclaw was a dangerous thing.

"Perhaps—" Qiu's eyes lit up, "I can write to my grandfather again and ask him?"

Cedric was really tired; he suddenly felt that the day had been quite long.

[Item 3: A unified Broom Budget will be adopted for all four college teams. The total estimated value of the seven Broomstick used by each team must not exceed the average total estimated value of the Broomstick currently used by the four active teams. The estimated value will be based on the seasonal guidance price from the Broom Quality Supervision Office.]

This time, the crowd truly erupted.

The Gryffindor the first to cheer.

"Finally!" "Slytherin can't use all seven Nimbus 2001s!" "That's fair!"

Ravenclaw students have already begun discussing Broomstick depreciation rates.

"Should the repaired Broomstick be priced the original price or the repaired price?" "Is replacing the tail branch considered a core component?" "If we deliberately create scratches on the Broomstick handle, can we lower the valuation?"

Several fifth-graders from Ravenclaw have already huddled together to devise a strategy.

Hufflepuff was more concerned with something else.

"Aren't the secondhand prices for those Cleansweep Series in our college too low?"

"Lower prices have their advantages too."

"What are the benefits?"

"That will save the budget for Cedric to buy a new one."

There was no discussion about Slytherin.

Their main motivation was anger.

Marcus Flint pushed through the crowd, stood in front of the bulletin board, and read the third item three times from beginning to end.

With each reading, his expression grew increasingly grim; after three readings, his complexion was nearly the dark green of his robe.

Under the new rules, Slytherin cannot field seven Nimbus 2001s at the same time; at least half of them must be replaced.

He turned around abruptly, scanned the crowd with his eyes, and then strode toward Gavin.

The crowd naturally parted to make way.

"Gu! I heard you made these rules?"

Gavin nodded. "It was my suggestion."

"Remove it."

Gavin shrugged. "You can talk to Professor McGonagall."

Marcus stared at him.

"You'd better think about it again. Do you know what the consequences are of offending the Slytherin Quidditch Team?"

He took another step forward.

He was more than half a head taller than Gavin, and his shoulders were much broader; standing there, he looked like a wall in a robe.

"Flint! What are you doing?!" Cordelia rushed out of the crowd, trying to stand in front of Gavin.

Gavin glanced at Cordelia, smiled slightly, and gave her a reassuring look.

Then he looked at Marcus again, his tone calm, as if asking him what he had for breakfast.

How are you feeling?

Marcus was stunned for a moment, his mind not quite grasping the situation.

"What?"

"I mean, resilience," Gavin added. "Stronger than Troll?"

"What do you mean?"

A third-year Slytherin student standing nearby changed his expression.

He tugged at Marcus's sleeve and lowered his voice, "He killed a Troll last year."

Marcus frowned. "I know that. Didn't the Troll die from slipping on the ground?"

"No, you don't know the details," the student continued. "I heard that blood splattered all over the toilet, all over the walls, and the Troll's head was later scraped out of the rocks with a shovel."

Gavin turned and glanced at him; this was the first time he'd heard of this version either.

Rumors about Hogwarts obviously take the initiative to add details as they spread.

Moreover, the additional footage is more visually impactful than his own account.

Marcus's momentum instantly diminished.

"I never said I wanted to fight you."

"That's good." Gavin nodded. "I don't like violence either."

A brief silence fell over the area.

Anyone who knows what Gavin did last year finds this statement unconvincing.

Just as Marcus was about to continue speaking, the sound of a Black Robes sweeping across the ground came from outside the crowd.

Snape walked over.

The students fell silent, some even holding their breath; the scene was like a sudden gust of extremely cold wind blowing into the room.

His gaze first fell on Marcus, then shifted to Gavin.

"I've heard that the Quidditch rules that Hogwarts has used for centuries were modified by a second-year Hufflepuff."

"A temporary modification," Gavin corrected.

"This doesn't make things sound any more reasonable."

"Which point does the professor object to?"

"Broom Budget."

The answer was unsurprising.

"Slytherin gains an advantage by acquiring equipment legally," Snape said sternly. "I don't believe that this advantage should be restricted just to appease the incompetence of other houses."

The Gryffindor students immediately showed expressions of anger. Ron opened his mouth to say something, but Hermione stopped him.

Gavin nodded.

That makes sense.

Snape narrowed his eyes slightly; he clearly didn't believe Gavin would agree so quickly.

"Of course the rules don't have to be changed." Gavin didn't directly confront Snape.

Marcus's face immediately lit up with joy.

"But that means I have to resort to another solution."

"What plan?"

"Teach Harry how to chase the Golden Snitch."

Snape didn't speak; he didn't understand Gavin's meaning.

"Mr. Potter is very talented. Last time, he didn't know this method and ended up in a draw with Cordelia," Gavin continued. "If he learns this method, he should have a hard time losing in school competitions."

The Gryffindor students around them lit up when they heard this.

Fred and George had begun exchanging glances, their eyes revealing a shared thought:

If Harry learns Gavin's method of catching the Golden Snitch, Gryffindor will never have to worry about the Slytherin match again.

Gavin leaned closer to Snape and lowered his voice—

A volume that only the two of them could hear.

"I've heard his dream is to become a world-class Seeker, and with his age and talent, it's certainly possible after a few years of training." Gavin's voice was full of allure. "And this method is my own creation; it doesn't exist in the wizarding world. If he learns it, he could become a true star."

Snape remained silent, but images were already flashing through his mind.

The Daily Prophet's front page.

Potter is holding up the Quidditch World Cup.

Potter was wearing England Team.

Potter flashed a bright smile at the camera that bore a striking resemblance to James Potter.

There might even be a book--

Harry Potter: From the Boy Who Lived to the King of Quidditch.

Just looking at the title is enough to make one feel nauseous.

Gavin added, "If he represents England at the Quidditch World Cup, he should be a source of pride for many people."

Snape's expression completely calmed down.

He took a step back, spoke again, and said clearly, "I've reconsidered."

Marcus immediately turned to look at him. "Professor?"

"Temporary rules are not entirely without value."

"But our Broomstick— " Marcus exclaimed in disbelief; the Dean had actually betrayed the revolution.

Snape looked at him coldly:

"Slytherin relied on ability, not seven Broomstick of the same price."

Marcus opened his mouth.

This statement would be perfectly normal to come from any professor.

But coming from Snape, it gives the impression that history has been distorted.

"Adapt to the rules," Snape said firmly, "And stop harassing Mr. Gu."

After saying that, he turned and left.

The Black Robes billowed behind him, leaving Marcus standing there, watching his dean's retreating figure, momentarily unable to keep up with the pace of events.

Gavin could see it very clearly.

Snape's fondness for the Slytherin Quidditch Team ultimately couldn't overcome his aversion to "Harry Potter becoming a world-class Quidditch player."

This was a fair contest of wills, and Potter won decisively.

Harry doesn't even need to step in; his very presence is the most effective deterrent.

After the crowd dispersed, Cordelia walked over to Gavin.

"I'm sorry, I didn't expect so many people to be looking for you."

"Changing the rules will inevitably lead to this."

"If I hadn't asked you for help—"

"Professor McGonagall will continue to try to persuade me; perhaps she'll eventually bring Dumbledore into the picture."

Cordelia still felt a little guilty.

Her lips were pressed into a thin line, and the tassels of her scarf were wrapped around her fingers several times.

Gavin thought for a moment, then spoke.

"If you really feel sorry, you can call me 'brother' a few more times."

Cordelia looked up at him.

Gavin was prepared to back down.

Based on past experience, she might step on his foot or simply use her elbow to solve the problem.

However, Cordelia did not.

She simply turned her head and looked around.

There are too many people here.

"Ah?"

After saying that, she walked past Gavin.

After taking a few steps, he stopped again and turned his face slightly to the side.

"Let's talk about it when there are fewer people."

She's gone.

Her ponytail swayed gently behind her shoulder, and her footsteps faded into the distance in the stone corridor.

Gavin stood there, motionless for a long time.

He hadn't expected such an unexpected gain.

During lunch, Professor McGonagall announced another piece of news.

"To test the provisional rules, Hogwarts will hold a friendly match this Saturday." The sound of spoons clattering in the Great Hall paused for a moment. "The two teams are Slytherin and Hufflepuff."

After a brief silence, discussions broke out simultaneously at the four Long Tables.

Gryffindor and Ravenclaw were very excited; they were eager to see how the three Golden Snitches would turn the match around.

Slytherins and Hufflepuffs, however, had it less easy, as they were the ones being watched.

An emergency meeting was held that afternoon in the Hufflepuff Common Room.

When Cedric found Gavin, he was sitting by the Fireplace reading a book.

The warm light of the flames shone on the pages of the book, turning the densely packed incantation formulas orange.

Which Golden Snitch do you think we should chase first?

Gavin turned the page without answering.

"The Golden Snitch is still the most important, but we can't completely ignore the other two. If we catch the Silver Snitch first, we can get fifty points, and then Seeker drag it out until dinner time. Our chances of winning should be very high."

Cedric sat down next to him, a tactical diagram he had drawn himself spread out on his lap, with several plans marked on it in different colors of Ink.

Gavin continued reading.

"But if Cordelia catches the Golden Snitch first, the match will end immediately. Should we assign a Chaser to cover the Golden Snitch as well? Or should we have Beater specifically distract Cordelia?"

"This isn't really Hufflepuff style," Ernie remarked from the side.

"Normal interference," Cedric explained, "Not an attack."

"Bludger is inherently an offensive move."

"That's an attack permitted by the rules."

The two exchanged a few words, then simultaneously looked at Gavin.

Gavin seemed not to hear him at all.

Cedric finally started to get anxious.

"Gavin, say something!"

"Say what?"

"Tactics."

"Then I'm sorry, I cannot provide that."

"Why? Aren't you Hufflepuff?" Cedric asked incredulously.

Gavin took a piece of Parchment from his Dragon Hide Bag and spread it on the table.

Below the Parchment were his and Professor McGonagall's signatures, the edges of the text gleaming faintly with gold.

This is a Magical Contract.

Cedric lowered his head and read aloud, "During the trial competition, referees shall not provide either side with tactical guidance, data analysis, equipment adjustments, training suggestions, or the release probabilities and flight parameters of the gold, silver, and bronze Golden Snitch in any form..."

He stopped reading at this point.

The Common Room also quieted down.

"Of course I am Hufflepuff," Gavin, putting the Parchment away, "But more importantly, I am the referee for the next match."

Cedric looked at Herbert.

Ernie looked at Justin.

All the Hufflepuffs around looked at each other in bewilderment.

The atmosphere in the Common Room gradually became heavy.

Cedric finally understood.

Fair rules come at a price.

The first cost was that their super brains were now standing in the center of the arena.

They are no longer usable.

Cedric suddenly felt that the seemingly fair rules of the game had become very unfair.

"We've suffered a huge loss."

End of Chapter
Prev
NovelSummaries
Next

Explore the wiki

Gavin
Cordelia
Justin
Hermione
Ron
Tom

Comments

No comments yet.
AboutStatsAPIChangelogStatusContactPrivacyTermsDMCA
© 2026 RandomTranslator·v3.26·RSS