The office remained quiet for a long time.
The ticking of thousands of clocks in the Time Hall outside seeped through the thick Oak doors, making the atmosphere inside even more eerie.
Saul Croaker's hand, holding the white porcelain teapot, froze in mid-air.
He glanced at the black-haired boy across from him through the rising steam of the Black Tea.
Then, the old man slowly filled Gavin's teacup, then took back the teapot and poured himself a cup, before speaking slowly and deliberately:
The last person to sit in this chair and say that to me was sent to the Permanent Spell Damage Department on the fourth floor of St. Mungo's's three days later.
Gavin, without changing his expression, picked up the teacup and blew away the tea leaves floating on the surface:
"Because he went mad from his research on time?"
"No."
Croaker placed the teapot back on the tray and said expressionlessly:
"Because he owed the Time Hall over three hundred hours of night shift pay, he tried to evade his debt by denying the existence of Time. After leaving the building, he was attacked and brought back in by the other six Unspeakable."
Gavin paused for a moment, his hand holding the teacup still.
It seems that, in any world, withholding wages from migrant workers is a high-risk behavior.
Research workers are no exception.
"Don't worry, Professor, you haven't paid me yet."
Gavin took a sip of hot tea, placed the cup back on the saucer, and looked up at the old man behind the table:
"I'm not talking about the kind of thing where they renege on their debts; that doesn't exist."
Croaker's aged eyebrows twitched slightly.
He leaned back in his large chair, tapped his thin index finger lightly on the table, and pointed towards the door:
"Then tell me, Mr. Gu."
"From the moment you pushed open this door and sat down until now, the tea in the pot has slowly cooled, and the grandfather clock outside has struck two hundred and eighty-three. Since you say time might not exist, what does this period of time even matter?"
"If, as you say, time doesn't exist at all, then what about the past we've traveled back to?"
Croaker chuckled softly, "Some kind of hallucination?"
Gavin shrugged:
"Perhaps it really is some kind of hallucination?"
"Mr. Gu," Croaker's expression turned serious, and he shook his head, "This isn't funny. If that's the case, then everything the Time Hall has done over the years has become a joke."
The Ministry of Magic was a joke to begin with.
However, Gavin didn't say this to Croaker's face; so far, he still thought the professor was a pretty good person.
Gavin glanced at the still steaming Black Tea in his cup and nodded:
"Of course it's not just a simple physiological hallucination."
The tea does feel very hot to the touch, but when you really look down to the microscopic level, from the perspective of each individual molecule, there is no such thing as a separate entity called "temperature".
The so-called hot and cold are merely the macroscopic results of massive particle collisions;
Therefore, some physicists have deduced that the "passage of time" perceived by humans may also be a similar manifestation of some kind of motion of matter.
"What are you trying to say?" Croaker frowned.
"Those pasts you returned to might actually exist."
Gavin stretched out his right hand and moved the silver sugar cube jar on the table to the center, then placed his own teacup and Croaker's teacup on either side of the sugar cube jar.
"But what I question is the 'River of Time' that wizards have always believed to exist."
Gavin pointed to the desktop:
"Whether it's 'The Calamity of Quicksand' or the intuition of most people, it's assumed that the entire universe is immersed in the same evenly flowing river."
"Everyone shares the same 'present'—the past is gone forever, and the future is still a void yet to be born."
Isn't that so?
Croaker countered with a question.
"If we don't use magic, isn't Hogwarts now and London now the same 'now'?"
"If the distance is very close and the speed is very slow, they do look about the same."
Gavin's finger landed on the sugar jar in the middle:
"But we can conduct a thought experiment, a simple hypothesis, Professor Croaker."
"Imagine there's a modified flying Broomstick outside, flying extremely fast—almost at the speed of light."
Croaker narrowed his eyes slightly, following his finger to the sugar jar.
"A rider sat in the very middle of the Broomstick, the distance from the Broomstick head and the Broomstick tail to him being exactly the same."
Gavin lightly tapped the top of the sugar jar with his fingertip:
"The moment it flew past you, the rider raised his Wand, Lumos right in the center of the Broomstick."
"Will the light illuminate the head of the Broomstick first, or the Broomstick?"
Croaker hardly hesitated:
"Naturally, the lights illuminate simultaneously. He sits right in the middle, with equal distance between him and the other side."
"From the rider's own perspective, it was indeed illuminated simultaneously."
Gavin nodded, then moved his finger toward Croaker across the table:
But how do you see him from the ground up?
"The light needs a slight interval to travel from the middle outwards. During this interval, the Broomstick is flying forward— the Broomstick tail is approaching the light, while the Broomstick head is moving away from it."
"So in your eyes, that light will definitely illuminate the Broomstick tail first, and then catch up with the Broomstick head."
Croaker's graying eyebrows furrowed, and he immediately seized upon the loophole:
"That's just because the light enters my eyes at different speeds; it's a visual illusion."
It's not an optical illusion.
Gavin calmly shook his head:
Even if you cover the ground with the most sensitive observation Magic Runes, completely eliminating the delay of light returning to the eye, the calculated result will still not change.
"Because the speed at which light travels through space is constant, it doesn't increase just because the Broomstick flies faster."
"Wait!"
Croaker interrupted him without any politeness.
"The Chaser throws the Quaffle forward while riding on Broomstick, and the ball naturally flies faster due to the momentum. Why is there any exception?"
"Unfortunately—" Gavin gazed silently at the other person, "Light is the exception."
Over the next ten minutes, Gavin had to move the white porcelain teapot to represent the sun and the sugar cube jar to represent the earth, demonstrating from beginning to end how Muggle scholars measured "light traveling with the earth" and "light traveling against the earth," and how they shattered everyone's common sense.
By the time the steam from the spout had dissipated, Croaker's gray eyebrows were already knotted into a tight knot.
The old man stared at the sugar cube jar that served as the Earth for a long time, clearly still finding it unbelievable, but finally raised his chin:
"Even if I were to believe your superstitious premise—so what?"
"Once you accept this rule, things become simple."
Gavin pointed to the teacups on either side of the sugar cube jar:
For the rider on the Broomstick, being illuminated at both ends is a complete 'simultaneity'; but for you on the ground, when the Broomstick tail lights up, the Broomstick head is still in a dark 'future'.
The old scholar behind the desk fell completely silent.
He stared at the sugar cube jar and teacup on the table, his cloudy yet sharp eyes fixed on the spot, repeatedly replaying the high-speed Broomstick in his mind according to this set of rules.
A few seconds later, Croaker's hands, which were resting on his knees, slowly tightened.
It's as if they've already admitted to what Gavin said.
Gavin pushed the sugar jar back to its original position with a smooth and clear sound:
"So, since the same event may be seen as 'the present' by one person and as 'the future' by another—does that mean there isn't a single blade in the universe that can neatly slice through everyone's 'present'?"
"Others' 'present' can be a stepping stone into our 'future'."
"And if the future hasn't even existed yet, how can someone else's 'present' possibly overlap with it?"
Gavin looked up and met Croaker's shocked gaze:
"So perhaps the future isn't something that's created temporarily once we've arrived there."
"The cup of tea we're drinking today, and a snowfall hundreds of years from now, already exist simultaneously in this space-time, along with the past and the present."
The room was deathly silent.
Only a wisp of steam remained in the teacup, slowly rising upwards.
After a while, Professor Croaker, who had been lazily leaning back in his chair, gradually straightened his hunched back.
He didn't utter a word in rebuttal, but silently extended his right hand, pulled a blank piece of Parchment from the corner of the table, picked up Quill, and dipped it in the Ink Bottle:
"Reiterate your assumption about the Broomstick from the beginning. Slowly."
The Quill glided across the rough Parchment.
Croaker remembered quickly, yet his handwriting was very neat, and his wrist was so steady that it didn't seem like that of an elderly man in his seventies.
Gavin not only showed him again the sequence in which the Broomstick head and tail lit up, but also pointed to the sketch on the Parchment depicting "the Broomstick head moving forward while the light chases after it," and casually added:
"Furthermore, looking down from this diagram, not only is the sequence of events messed up—even the flow of time on the Broomstick actually slows down."
Croaker paused, then looked up. "The flow of time has slowed down?"
"Look at that ball of light that just started from the middle of the Broomstick and chased after the Broomstick head. If the Broomstick had stopped on the ground, the light would have hit the Broomstick head in the blink of an eye—let's call that 'ding' the impact one second."
Gavin's fingertips slid far along the sketch:
"But once the Broomstick flies at a speed only slightly slower than the light, the Broomstick head races ahead while the light struggles to keep up. From your perspective on the ground, it might seem like several hours have passed before the light finally catches up with the Broomstick head and makes that 'ding' sound."
Croaker frowned, immediately grasping the crux of the matter:
"That only means it slowed down when using light as a clock; what does it have to do with the rider's body or the Pocket Watch?"
"Because the human body and Pocket Watch, in the final analysis, are also clocks that rely on transmitting information to keep time."
Gavin looked at him calmly:
"The human brain makes the heart beat, ages the body, and even one Gears in a Gears Pocket Watch moves the next, all thanks to the extremely weak force transmitted between particles—and the highest speed at which these transmissions can occur is still no faster than the speed of light."
"As the Broomstick races at near-light speed, every signal urging the rider's heart to beat has to struggle to keep up with the body, just like that ball of light. By the time you've finished your entire day on the ground, that ball of light has only just collided with the Broomstick head with a 'ding,' and the signals from his brain have only just caught up with his heart, making his heart beat its first real beat."
Gavin withdrew his finger and summarized softly:
"When he stopped Broomstick and landed back on the ground, it wasn't a trick of the eye—a whole day had truly passed on the ground, while his heart and Pocket Watch had truly only ticked for a second. The faster you fly, the slower time seems to flow."
Croaker tightened his grip on the Quill, dipped it in ink without a word, and quickly added the deduction about "high speed and slow time" to the bottom of the Parchment.
Gavin, looking at the old man who hadn't refuted him, was genuinely curious:
"Did you really understand, Professor?"
"To be honest--"
Croaker's pen never stopped moving.
"No."
Gavin's lips twitched. "So you remember it so happily?"
"It's never a problem to write it down first." Croaker didn't care at all.
After a while, he seemed to remember something, and looked up. "Did you invent this theory yourself?"
Gavin shook his head:
"If I had that kind of brain, I'd already be redefining the rules of the entire world."
Croaker raised an eyebrow and moved the Ink -dipped Quill to the blank space at the very top of the Parchment:
"Which wizard came up with that? Does this theory have a name?"
"Of course, this theory is called --"
Gavin looked at the suspended pen tip and slowly uttered a few words:
"Theory of Relativity."
"Author: Bert Einstein."
"By the way, he's a Muggle."
"Einstein..." Croaker muttered to himself, "Muggle?"
"Professor, you don't have any prejudice against Muggles, do you?" Gavin curiously.
Croaker paused for a moment, then chuckled, "Of course not, it's just that I never imagined Muggles would have such an interesting perspective on time."
Is it just funny?
Gavin chuckled inwardly. This academic giant was good at everything, except for his stubbornness.
As the old scholar carefully inscribed his name at the top of the Parchment, he casually asked:
"When did this theory originate?"
"1905, I think."
Croaker paused in his writing.
He looked up, scrutinizing the boy opposite him with suspicion:
"Almost ninety years? But I've never heard of this theory before—we have Muggle-born Unspeakable here, and they've never mentioned it."
Can they be the same?
Most young wizards have just finished sixth grade at Muggle primary school—or even United Kingdom primary school—and haven't even mastered basic addition and subtraction of fractions before they arrive at Hogwarts, so naturally they haven't been exposed to the Theory of Relativity.
Meeting the inquisitive gaze of the elderly scholar, Gavin said in a serious tone:
"Maybe it's because I'm relatively smart, though slightly less so than Einstein."
There was a two-second silence behind the desk.
Croaker's eye twitched.
In the end, the old man said nothing, bowed his head, blew away the last drop of ink, and put the Quill back on the pen holder.
When he looked up again, a hint of the stubbornness and sharpness of a top scholar appeared on the old man's face.
"A very interesting theory, Mr. Gu —whether it came from Einstein or from someone only slightly less accomplished than him."
Croaker reached out and patted the stack of old files, which was about half a foot thick, on the corner of the table, then pushed it to the center of the desk.
"But this is the Department of Mysteries. In this room, any theory that wants to gain a foothold must first pass the test of facts that have already occurred."
On the yellowed kraft paper cover, a striking title was written in dark red Ink—
The original files of the Iloise Minton Reversal Accident of 1899.
That was one of the most infamous time-traveling tragedies in the History of Magic.
The Unspeakable woman was unexpectedly trapped for five days in 1402. After being forcibly dragged back by Sly, she aged five hundred years and died in St. Mungo's's, causing a major disruption to London's timekeeping. This is the origin of the ironclad rule that "time travel cannot exceed five hours."
Even if flying to its maximum speed could slow down time on Broomstick, Minton stayed underground in London back then and didn't go anywhere else.
Croaker's withered fingers pressed heavily on the cover of the file, his gaze fixed on the boy opposite him:
"Could you explain to me how Iloise Minton in 1899 managed to stretch Tuesdays into two and a half days and shorten Thursdays to only four hours? If time doesn't exist, then what is this?"
Gavin looked down at the stack of files.
In the parallel world, he had only read the conclusion of this famous incident in the summary of "The Calamity of Quicksand".
Now that he had the original records kept by the Department of Mysteries, he casually flipped to the first page.
At the top is a page of annotations summarizing the accident, left by the old Unspeakable of the previous generation; the dark red ink has long since turned black.
Gavin's gaze lingered for two seconds on the third line of the annotation: "[Five hundred years of retrospection caused the collapse of time flow: Tuesday's time accumulated to sixty hours; Thursday's time flow broke, twenty hours of daylight were lost, and sunset arrived abruptly]," and he commented sincerely:
"The person who wrote this annotation must have rarely visited the Planet Hall next door back then."
Croaker's eye twitched:
"The first three chapters of that textbook and this overview were written by my teacher."
Gavin paused for a moment, then calmly turned the page to Chapter Three:
"No wonder the logic became much clearer starting from Chapter Four."
Croaker stared at him for two seconds, then let out a soft snort that was hard to tell if it was an exasperation or a laugh, and tapped his knuckles on the table.
"Don't change the subject. What does this have to do with the Planet Hall?"
"I wasn't born in 1899, so I can't make a definitive conclusion about what actually happened there."
Gavin pointed to the phrase "[the sun sets suddenly]" on the file and looked up.
"But let's start with a simple Astronomy calculation—why does the sun set?"
Croaker frowned:
"The Earth rotates once, that's common knowledge taught in first grade at Hogwarts, and you're testing me on that?"
"Since the alternation of day and night is due to the Earth's rotation around its axis, let's rule out the first possibility: that Thursday for the entire world was indeed shortened to four hours."
Gavin held his teacup by the handle and gently twirled it in the saucer.
"For the sun to set in four hours, the planet beneath our feet would suddenly go crazy and increase its rotation speed to six times its normal rate."
"Astronomy only taught about the cycles of celestial bodies; they probably didn't calculate how fast the Earth's surface carries seawater."
The boy's voice was flat:
"If the Earth were to actually complete a full rotation in four hours, the Atlantic Ocean would be thrown into the sky due to its inertia, creating a tsunami hundreds of feet high, which could sweep the entire Britain into the North Sea to feed the Merpeople within half an hour."
Gavin looked up at the intact black vaulted ceiling above him and spread his hands:
"The fact that London is still standing still means that on that Thursday, the Earth did indeed take 24 hours to complete its rotation."
Croaker's eyelids twitched slightly, then he snorted coldly, flipped to the middle section of the investigation record in the file, and slammed it on the table:
"Of course the Earth rotates normally on its own axis! Back then Scotland and Paris were fine; the anomaly only occurred in London!"
The old man pressed his fingers heavily on the Parchment, amidst the densely packed signatures:
"But precisely because the sun outside has been shining for twenty-four hours, while the dozens of Pocket Watches, water clocks, and magic hourglasses on this side of London, along with the physical sensations of the Time Hall and the hundreds of people in St. Mungo's's, have all experienced only four hours in a very real way—"
Doesn't this precisely prove that Minton tore apart the flow of time over London, causing our neighborhood to fall into a 'time Time Fold is only one-sixth of that outside?
"I don't doubt the phenomenon itself that the so-called 'six-fold slowdown in local time flow' in the London."
Gavin nodded and pointed to the sugar jar on the table:
"Minton was indeed in the same spot back then, not anywhere else, and not on a speeding Broomstick, but perhaps speed wasn't the only factor that altered time?"
"What do you mean?" Croaker didn't understand.
"What if we replaced that incredible speed with overwhelming Magic?"
"Magic?"
"That's right, Magic." Gavin nodded.
His gaze then fell back to the page of testimony:
"Professor Croaker, you've always assumed that it's because Minton spanned five hundred years and triggered some kind of 'backlash from the River of Time,' that Thursday in London has shrunk to four hours."
"But could this file have conflated the variables of 'time' and 'Magic' from the very beginning?"
Croaker frowned. "What do you mean?"
"When the Gears of Pocket Watch, the hourglass, and a person's metabolism all slow down in sync, it is indeed that localized time in that area slows down."
Gavin pointed to the records in the case file regarding the forced recall ceremony and calmly offered a conjecture:
"But the source of this localized slowing of time may not be some taboo about going back five hundred years. Is it possible that when you forcibly pulled her back, it triggered some kind of large-scale Magic out-of-control situation, which forcibly slowed down the 'local time flow' of the surrounding blocks by six times?"
"In other words, even if no one travels back in time today, as long as a similarly high density of runaway Magic gathers underground in Whitehall, the clocks and people on the street above will still slow down."
There was silence behind the desk for a few seconds.
Croaker's fingers tightened slightly on the pages of the book.
He suddenly realized that this conjecture made a lot of sense, if the theory of Theory of Relativity was true and reliable.
Although it hasn't been tested, the existence of the Reverse-Time Charm explains a lot.
The existence of the Reverse-Time Charm itself demonstrates that Magic can influence time.
Regardless of the nature of time, this influence is objectively real.
"So you mean that there's no rule governing time reversal, and it's just that Magic causes localized time in London to shorten or lengthen?"
"That's right."
"But that's just your guess."
The old scholar shook his head, his eyes sharpening again, and tapped his fingertips on the table:
"How can you prove that what slowed down London time back then was some kind of Magic, rather than a break in the flow of time itself?"
I cannot prove it--
Croaker chuckled, speechless. "So that was just your guess after all—"
But I have a direction.
"..."
Croaker suddenly realized that he really disliked people who spoke with a heavy breathing tone.
"Which direction?"
"Magic has a limited range, right?"
What are you trying to say?
"If we liken the range of Magic's effect to a 'field,' we can simply call it Magic field."
Gavin extended his index finger and lightly tapped the center of the table, then drew a faint circle that radiated outwards:
"Formed spells like 'Finite Incantatem' or protective barriers do indeed have a clear boundary; but if what leaked out back then was purely a chaotic and dissipating Magic, then the intensity of this Magic field would likely decrease little by little with distance as it spreads outward."
The boy withdrew his finger and looked at Croaker opposite him:
"The Ministry of Magic is located underground in Whitehall, St. Mungo's's is near Charing Cross Road. The two are less than a mile apart as the crow flies, both situated in the central area, so the travel time to either is naturally four hours."
"But just over five miles southeast of Whitehall is the Greenwich Royal Astronomy Tower Muggle observatory. Back in 1899, they were using telegraph lines to calibrate the clocks at all the train stations and post offices in London every day."
Gavin didn't give a definitive answer, but only pointed out a possible approach to the investigation:
"You could have someone look through the old newspapers and telegraph records from the Muggle neighborhoods along that October. If that Magic really did escape freely back then, you might be able to find traces of the clocks between Whitehall and Greenwich slowly returning to a 24-hour timetable."
"Of course, this is all just speculation."
Gavin shrugged and put on his armor.
Croaker's breath hitched slightly as he stared at the invisible circle on the table.
Sixty years.
From his master's generation onward, the Time Hall had checked the Scotland astronomical charts, examined the most sophisticated Alchemy hourglasses in the city, and assumed that London was a single collapsed time fault line, but no one had ever thought of going out to the Ninth Underground Levels to look through the clock ledgers left by the Muggles on the streets above.
"But if it's chaotic Magic, why is London always four hours, instead of a chaotic mix of different times?"
Croaker found a loophole.
"Have no idea."
"I don't know?" Croaker frowned.
Gavin waved his hand. "I wasn't responsible for that accident."
"..."
Croaker's lips twitched.
Gavin smiled innocently, "That's why I said it was just a direction."
After a moment of silence, Croaker picked up his Quill and wrote a note. The quill paused on the words "[Muggle Newspaper]", then expressionlessly crossed them out, leaving only "[Greenwich Telegraph Time File]".
Gavin glanced at the ink line. "Aren't you going to check the newspapers from that time?"
"Checking won't help."
Croaker dried the ink, his tone calm and composed:
"That October, the entire team of Obliviator on the Third Floor worked non-stop for half a month. According to the final case report filed by the department, on that Thursday in 1899, London was simply hit by a 'Hypnosis fog of unprecedented density,' and all the Muggles in the city took a twenty-hour nap standing in the streets."
Gavin: "..."
Croaker put down his Quill, stared at the line of ink for two seconds, and remembered what Gavin had said earlier:
"So, according to you, even if the difference in speed between Tuesday and Thursday really was caused by some kind of ' Magic field'—then was Minton's return to 1402 also an illusion woven by some immense Magic? Or what you call a hallucination?"
Gavin glanced at the few fragments of the golden hourglass in the crystal dish on the corner of the table, and shook his head:
"I can't be sure about that. That's why I borrowed the Time-Turner in June, wanting to verify it myself."
Croaker perked up, immediately becoming interested, and leaned forward:
"That's exactly the question I wanted to ask you: where did you go for those twenty-one days?"
"Albus blew my roof off. I tried everything, turning every clock record in the United Kingdom upside down, but I couldn't find a trace of you."
"That's normal."
Gavin nodded.
"Because I went to another world."
Croaker frowned. "Another world... you mean?"
"That's right, a parallel world."
Gavin met the old man's gaze and nodded:
"A parallel world similar to this one, yet leading to a different ending. Over there, the survivors of the war twelve years ago are different from those here. There's a Gavin Goo at Hogwarts, and even in the Ninth Underground Level of that world, there sits a Professor Croaker."
For a moment, only the faint ticking of a clock from outside the door could be heard in the office.
Surprisingly, Croaker did not show the absurd expression one would expect when hearing such madness.
The old man stared into Gavin's eyes for a full five seconds, then suddenly muttered to himself:
"A world that is both similar and different... those people are definitely not just simply insane."
Gavin raised an eyebrow slightly. "Madness? What do you mean?"
"I handled two or three strange cases in my earlier years."
Croaker rubbed his temples, his tone somewhat heavy:
"In the old archives of the Time Hall and on the fourth floor of St. Mungo's's, there were a few unfortunate souls who died in time travel experiments. After waking up, they insisted that the Minister for Magic had been replaced, claiming that their long-dead relatives were still alive. All the Healers thought they had lost their minds and were suffering from delusions."
"I did suspect the possibility of parallel universes back then, wondering if these people came from other similar worlds."
Gavin only then seemed to realize something.
No wonder Professor Croaker from the parallel universe was able to realize within just a few days that he was an alien soul residing in Gavin's body.
Regardless of the timeline, this titan of time certainly had his own unique insights into various concepts of time.
With that in mind, Gavin casually posed a question that had been on his mind for a long time:
"You over there seem to have confirmed this conjecture, and that Professor Croaker has a Bronze Compass that can locate souls from other worlds. I used it to get back—we should have one here too, right?"
Croaker frowned upon hearing this, a strange look appearing on his face:
"You mean the 'Source-Tracing Compass'? There is such a thing. Before, when Albus forced me to find someone, I wanted to find it and try it out, but when I found it, I discovered that the compass was somehow damaged."
Damaged?
Gavin's heart skipped a beat, but he remained outwardly calm as he pressed on, "How was it damaged?"
"I don't know, this is very strange."
Croaker shook his head:
"The outer wooden box was perfectly intact, but the main axis pointer and the tracking silver ring inside were completely broken off from the inside, without any signs of external prying. After it was scrapped, it was stored in the old warehouse at the deepest part of the ninth floor."
"May I take a look?" Gavin asked immediately. "I have some experience in Alchemy artifacts."
"Then I'll have to find some time to have someone look for it. That warehouse has been storing things for hundreds of years; there's too much stuff, and it's too messy," Croaker replied casually.
Gavin was very helpful. "Do you need any help? I happen to have no classes this weekend."
Croaker glanced at him:
"No need. That warehouse is full of forbidden items that have gone out of control and been scrapped throughout history. Even the slightest scratch or bump would mean having to carry them into St. Mungo's's. It's extremely dangerous."
"Someone who went in before degenerated from the shoulders up to the size of an eight-month-old baby, and is still on the fourth floor of St. Mungo's's learning to wean off the pacifier again."
"I'm not afraid of danger, Professor," Gavin said sincerely.
"Is that so?"
Croaker narrowed his eyes, looked him up and down across the desk for two seconds, and looked somewhat suspicious:
"... Why do I feel like you're so enthusiastic about our company's warehouse?"
Gavin coughed lightly, his fist pressed to his lips, then sat up straight, his expression unchanged.
"Mainly because I'm a good comrade and have always been happy to help others."
Croaker snorted through his nose, clearly not believing a word of it, picked up his teacup, took a sip, and steered the conversation back on track:
"Alright, I'll follow up on the compass matter. Now that you've witnessed a parallel world firsthand—how has this trip helped your Muggle theory?"
Gavin glanced at the old man opposite him and thought for a moment.
Finally, he decided to tell the truth:
"It's been a great help, but there are some things that are difficult to explain to you clearly."
Croaker twitched his mustache and slammed the teacup down on the saucer.
"Don't look down on me! I've even memorized your theory about the constant speed of light and light chasing Broomstick head. Is there anything I don't understand? Speak!"
Seeing that the old man was getting stubborn, Gavin stopped refusing.
He first asked Croaker a question:
"Before you explain, Professor Croaker, have you considered one thing—"
"What's up?"
Do humans, or rather wizards, truly possess free will?
Croaker paused for a moment, his expression strange:
"What kind of talk is that? I can pick up the cup when I want to drink tea and put it down when I don't. Isn't that free will?"
"If time is truly a ceaselessly flowing river, and the future has not yet been born, then that is indeed called free will."
Gavin flipped the manuscript to the first page, then to pages 50 and 100, and looked at the other person:
"Based on the conclusions drawn from the Theory of Relativity, other people's 'present' can be used to probe our 'future' --"
"This suggests that perhaps the past, present, and future weren't drawn on the fly as we went along, but rather were a complete comic book that was laid out simultaneously from the very beginning."
"We, drinking tea today, are on page 50; we, ten years from now, are on page 100. It's precisely because the subsequent pages were printed long ago that the crystal ball in the Hall of Prophecy next door could foresee a child's fate more than a decade later, even before the child was born—a fate that was entirely unchangeable."
Gavin, noticing the slight change in Croaker's expression, spoke calmly:
"If there were only one comic book in the world, the picture of 'you picking up the teacup' on page 51 would already be printed on the paper before you even reach for it. Living is nothing more than turning the pages of a pre-drawn grid. So, when you pick up that cup, is it still your free will?"
There was silence behind the desk for a few seconds.
Croaker initially frowned, but then, as if struck by a sudden thought, his eyes lit up, and he slammed his hand on the table:
"Wait! If there's only one book, then the person is indeed a puppet—but didn't you just witness a parallel world?"
The old man leaned forward slightly, a hint of smug satisfaction on his face as he realized he had found a weakness:
"Since there's more than one comic book, when we reached the fork in the road, my version in this world chose the left, while my version in the parallel world chose the right—doesn't the existence of parallel worlds prove that humans have free will?!"
Gavin looked at the happy old man opposite him and remained silent for two seconds.
The time connoisseur is indeed quite insightful; although he doesn't understand the "many-worlds theory," he can immediately grasp this point.
But unfortunately--
That's not correct.
"Quite the opposite, Professor."
The boy's voice was very soft, as if it came from afar:
"If all parallel universes exist simultaneously, it proves that humans don't even have the last shred of free will."
"How could there not be?" Croaker retorted indignantly. "They chose different paths; isn't that a choice?"
"True freedom of choice means that the moment you decide to go left, the possibility of 'going right' is completely negated and erased from the world by your will."
Gavin looked at him calmly:
"But if a maze has forty-nine paths, when water flows in, whether it's a dead end or a way out, all forty-nine channels are destined to be filled without a single drop leaking out—when all possible outcomes are destined to happen exactly as they are, whether you go left or right is just filling in the channels that have already been dug."
"That's not right either!"
Croaker's scholarly stubbornness kicked in completely. He instinctively reached out his rarely used left hand, grabbed the Black Tea on the table, and stared intently at Gavin:
Even if all forty-nine roads are flooded, at this moment, my consciousness is only focused on this one body—the one holding the cup with my left hand! I can neither feel nor control the one on the right. Isn't this my own choice?
Gavin looked at the teacup suspended in mid-air in his left hand and gently shook his head.
"Professor, at this very moment, in another branch, Professor Croaker, who casually picked up his teacup with his right hand, is saying the exact same thing to Gavin over there—'You see, my consciousness remains only in the reality of holding the cup with my right hand. Isn't that my own choice?'"
"But at this moment, I know that I am the teacup held in my right hand."
Croaker frowned.
"Doesn't my ability to perceive my own consciousness at this moment count?"
"Then how can you be sure that your current consciousness is continuous with the consciousness you had a moment ago?"
Croaker's left hand, which was holding the teacup, froze in mid-air.
"You might feel that you are in every world, but your consciousness may be split up, and you may not be able to perceive the existence of another world at all."
Gavin released his grip, and the manuscript that had been standing upright on the table snapped shut.
Therefore, what we perceive as choices may only become clear when we turn to the next page and see exactly where we've been placed.
The office was eerily quiet, with only the occasional, very faint crackling sound of a candle wick.
After a long while, Croaker slowly put down the teacup in his left hand.
The base of the porcelain cup tapped against the tray, making a crisp, light sound.
The old man looked down at the cold Black Tea in his cup and remained silent for a long time.
We discovered that the time-flow scaling we've been researching for sixty years is mixed with Magic interference; at worst, we can just scrap it and start over.
But if you follow the parallel worlds all the way to the end, you'll discover that all living beings, including yourself, are actually puppets printed on countless pages, their fates predetermined even to the point of raising their left hand.
That bone-chilling cold was enough to shake the conviction that any scholar pursuing truth had built up over half a lifetime.
After a long while, Croaker slowly raised his head and asked in a hoarse voice:
"Is this the answer you deduced?"
"It's just a conjecture that currently connects all the clues," Gavin replied.
However, there was one thing he didn't tell Croaker.
According to the parallel branch deduction, the "Gavin Goo" in that world, like the Croaker who holds a cup in his left hand and the Croaker who holds a cup in his right hand, is essentially an extension of the same consciousness on different paths.
But during those twenty-one days of sharing a body, Gavin clearly felt—
He Gavin were completely separate consciousnesses; they were not the same person at all.
This, to some extent, proves that humans possess genuine free will.
Everyone has the power to control their own future.
But the problem is--
He's from another time.
Even he himself couldn't say for sure whether this difference was because people can truly break free from predetermined patterns, or simply because he, as an "outsider," was an exception.
My isolated case proves nothing.
But judging from your appearance—
Across from him at the desk, Croaker narrowed his eyes and said in a hoarse voice:
"You don't seem to like the answer you've derived yourself."
Gavin out of his reverie, his mind flashing back to the scene in the Hospital Wing, Cordelia asleep beside his bed, her eyes still wet with tears, and to that night in a parallel world when he had to say goodbye to everyone.
After a moment, the black-haired boy let out a soft breath and shook his head:
"No one likes to be just a pre-printed page, Professor Croaker."
Gavin looked down at his outstretched palm, then slowly clenched it.
"So I actually really hope that what I'm telling you today will one day be proven wrong."
Even if this comic book has printed all the paths completely, I still want to keep looking—to see if there's a page missing from the printed book.
Go and see if this world is truly as the Daoists describe it.
The Great Way is fifty, the Heavenly Evolution is forty-nine.
One of them escaped.
Croaker gazed silently at the boy before him.
For some reason, when the young man in front of him said frankly, "I hope I'm wrong," the chill in the old man's heart inexplicably dissipated by more than half.
He sat up straight again and pondered for a long time.
After a moment, Croaker tapped his fingers lightly twice on the table, his tone regaining its composure:
"That 1905 theory of Theory of Relativity you just mentioned, and all those subsequent conjectures—were they all written by Einstein? Are these manuscripts locked away in some secret archive of the Royal Society Muggles?"
There's no need to search the confidential archives.
Gavin blinked and answered sincerely:
"The part about clocks running fast or slow can be bought in Muggle bookstores outside London for about six pounds a book; they teach it in the first year of university. As for the later part about the debate on branches of history and free will, it's a paper published two years ago by a Muggle scholar from University of Oxford."
Croaker paused, his graying eyebrows furrowing, clearly having no concept of Muggle currency.
Six pounds... how many Galleons is that?
"One Galleon and three Sickles, and a few Knut too," Gavin did the math for him. "Put it in Diagon Alley, and that's about half a can of Flobberworm Mucus."
A long, deathly silence fell behind the desk.
Croaker stared, mouth agape, his entire old face frozen in shock.
"Half... half a jar of slime?"
The voice of this titan of the Department of Mysteries was trembling:
"You mean, these secrets about time... are only worth half a jar of Caterpillars slime in Muggle bookstore on the street?! Are you kidding me?"
"If you happen to be there during the Christmas sales, maybe a third of a can will be enough," Gavin added thoughtfully.
Croaker took a deep breath, closed his eyes, and rubbed his throbbing temples.
Three seconds later, the old man opened his eyes, and without hesitation, flipped over the manuscript he had been working on for over half a month, pulled out Quill, and stuffed it into Gavin's hand:
Write down all the book titles for me!
The old man looked like he was gritting his teeth.
"Don't try to fool me with some amateurish, simplified version. Write down the title of the textbook and the paper!"
Gavin suppressed a laugh, took the Quill, and wrote down the book titles as instructed.
University Physics, Introduction to Special Relativity, the Feynman Lectures on Physics...
After finishing the last stroke, Gavin dry and put the Quill back on the pen holder.
Looking at the white-haired old man across from him who was leaning over to examine the string of English book titles, he suddenly had an idea and earnestly spoke:
"Speaking of which, Professor, it's actually quite difficult to just study from textbooks on your own. Why don't you just go to Oxford and study there? Anyway, there's no age limit."
Croaker's hand, which had just reached for the Parchment, froze in mid-air. Hearing this, he looked up at Gavin:
You want me to go to school?
Learning has no end.
Gavin nodded without changing his expression:
"There are quite a few older men at that school, so you'll blend in without standing out. I happen to know a professor there with connections; maybe I can pull some strings to get you in—just be careful if you fail your final exams, it might be a little awkward."
Croaker's eye twitched, and the absurd image of himself in his seventies sitting in Muggle classroom retaking his exams flashed through his mind. He decisively shook his head.
"No thanks. At my age, it would be a disgrace to the Department of Mysteries to be classmates with a bunch of young punks."
Gavin shrugged regretfully.
The attempt to fool them failed; the old lady was too wary.
The old scholar carefully folded the book list and put it into his inner pocket.
When he looked up again, his gaze fell back on the boy opposite him, and he looked him up and down.
"Besides, isn't there a teacher right here? I'll buy the book and study it myself first. If I get stuck on something, you can come and teach me when you have some free time."
I have to--
Gavin was about to decline, citing his busy schedule, when suddenly the image of the old warehouse filled with forbidden items in the deepest part of the room that Croaker had mentioned earlier flashed through his mind.
Is it possible to turn just the head into a baby's head?
That's so interesting!
In that case, having a legitimate reason to come to the Department of Mysteries doesn't seem like a bad deal, does it?
"Okay," Gavin suddenly agreed readily, "I'll come over when I have time."
"Then it's settled."
Fearing he might change his mind, Croaker immediately bent down, opened the bottom drawer of the desk, and took out a palm-sized, matte obsidian disc from a dusty wooden box, casually tossing it to Gavin:
"Take this, and you won't have to squeeze into that shabby phone booth on the street corner with strangers next time you come."
Croaker pointed to the dark patterns on the side edge of the disc.
"The third stall on the right in the underground public restroom at the south end of Whitehall. Just stick the sign on the door latch, stand in the toilet, and flush—it's much faster than a phone booth."
Gavin's hand, which was holding the obsidian disc, paused in mid-air as he observed it for a moment.
This appears to be just an ordinary obsidian item.
After a two-second silence, the boy calmly put the disc away.
"Thank you, Professor. But I thought that old phone booth had a pretty good view."
Moving towards flush toilets is a bit too ahead of its time; he needs to mentally prepare himself.
"Suit yourself," Croaker scoffed dismissively. "Once you get to the ninth floor, just swipe this to enter. Feel free to look at the archives in the Time Hall and the master clocks in the outer hall, just to avoid bothering them."
Gavin nodded, stood up, and took his leave.
"It's getting late, I have to go back to class, so I won't disturb your reading any longer, Professor Croaker."
"Go."
Croaker waved his hand, already impatiently pulling out the Parchment that read "Six Pound Muggle Textbook," and began studying it with a magnifying glass.
The heavy Oak door was gently pushed open, then closed behind him.
Gavin walked out of his inner office and through the long, still-tickling clock corridor.
As I passed the row of display cases on the outside, I saw Unspeakable named Bode in the corner, one arm of which was firmly bound by dark green vines. He was flipping through a book called "Indoor Ornamental Plant Pruning Guide" with one hand, looking very pleased.
Gavin's lips twitched.
He witnessed for the first time the superposition of death and immortality that Schrödinger had described.
Gavin walked straight ahead without looking to either side, arriving at the main entrance of the Time Hall.
He stopped, took the disc from his outer robe pocket, and opened the door.
Under light, the obsidian surface has no fancy decorations, except for a line of Latin text engraved in very light lines in the very center:
[Coadjutor]
Does "Coadjutor" mean assistant?
Gavin interpreted the Latin root literally, taking it as the nameplate for Croaker's temporary assistants.
Just as he reached for the doorknob, preparing to put the obsidian disc away, the door was pushed open from the outside.
Miriam Price, the Unspeakable woman who had just rushed back, almost bumped into Gavin at the door.
"I'm sorry, Mr. Gu."
Price stepped aside, his gaze inadvertently sweeping over the obsidian disc in the boy's hand.
The next second, the woman who Unspeakable froze in place.
The stack of documents she was holding fell to her feet with a "thud," but she was completely unaware, her eyes glued to the hand holding the disc, even her breath caught in her throat.
"Ms. Price?"
Gavin put the disc down and noticed the Unspeakable woman opposite him staring blankly at him, her face pale. He bent down to pick up the documents from the ground and handed them to her.
"I've already discussed your things with Professor Croaker."
"Ah... take your time, Mr. Gu..."
Price took the documents with both hands, nodding stiffly without even realizing it.
She simply watched blankly as the black-haired boy walked step by step through the revolving black door and disappeared at the end of the corridor leading to the elevator.
Price only snapped back to reality when the black gate completely stopped rotating.
She practically ran through the room filled with the ticking clocks, pushing open the Oak door without even knocking.
In the dimly lit office, Saul Croaker was holding a magnifying glass, studying with great interest the string of Muggle titles on the back of Parchment.
"Mr. Croaker!"
Price leaned against the doorframe, his voice trembling:
"You gave that thing to him?!"
Without even looking up, Croaker casually flipped through a page of the file on the table:
"Um."
Price's breath hitched. He stared at the open, empty wooden box on the corner of the desk, hesitated for two seconds, but couldn't resist:
"But... why give it to him?"
"Because he's a perfect fit." Croaker held the magnifying glass, not even lifting his eyelids.
Price didn't quite grasp it at first. "Appropriate?"
"When he was dealing with Bernard at the door, he didn't even take out his Wand. He forced the other man to come forward and beg for a beating with just three sentences—that's called having some skill."
Croaker extended his withered finger and gently tapped the Parchment on the table covered with Muggle book titles:
"As for scholarship... in terms of understanding time alone, he has far surpassed me."
"But he's still a child!" Price exclaimed urgently, "He's only in third grade!"
"It's precisely because they're only in third grade that they need to get ahead of everyone else."
Croaker snorted through his nostrils:
"By the time we give him the job after he graduates from Hogwarts, he'll have already been snatched up by other departments."
Price opened his mouth, still finding it somewhat hard to accept:
"Even if he's incredibly intelligent, we're the Department of Mysteries, the most prestigious department in the entire Ministry of Magic... Is this really necessary?"
"Have."
Croaker finally put down his magnifying glass, looked up at his subordinate, and slowly asked:
"I'm asking you, in all your years at the Ministry of Magic, when have you ever seen Albus Dumbledore far as to fight the entire Department of Mysteries for the sake of just one person?"
There was a two-second silence in the office.
Price hesitated for a moment, then tentatively whispered:
"... Grindelwald?"
Croaker's expression froze instantly.
The old man coughed heavily, expressionless, and picked up the magnifying glass again, using it to cover most of his face.
"In short, I think it's very necessary."
Price blinked, wisely refraining from continuing the conversation.
But then the scene she had witnessed at the door flashed through her mind again—
The boy casually stuffed the obsidian into his pocket like Knut, and I couldn't help but ask:
"Then... does he know what that means?"
Behind the desk, the white-haired old man looked up from behind the Parchment filled with Muggle textbooks.
He glanced at the empty doorway, and a long-lost smile reappeared in his cloudy eyes:
He'll find out.