Nothing but Pawns! Will You Hand Them Over, or Shall I Do It Myself?
Upon hearing Charle's question, Hagrid reacted as if he had heard something utterly absurd, forgetting even his anger.
He shouted.
"You ask me how great Dumbledore?"
"By Merlin, isn't that what everyone agrees on?!"
Charle asked with interest.
"I don't like any generally accepted opinions because they are often exaggerated and contain elements of misinformation."
"Just tell me, what do you think is the greatest thing about Dumbledore?"
Hagrid answered without hesitation.
"Dumbledore is the banner of justice. He led the fight against the mysterious person. Everyone knows that the only person Wizarding World the mysterious person fears is him!"
"Without Dumbledore, the mysterious person would be completely invincible in the Wizarding World. Isn't that a great thing?"
Charle shook his head.
"You said Voldemort was afraid of Dumbledore, and I admit that."
"But I want to ask you, how did you come to the claim that Dumbledore led the fight against the mysterious person?"
"I have indeed heard that Dumbledore has a secret society, I think it's called the Order of the Phoenix, right? Hagrid, you must be a member of the Order of the Phoenix too. How many people are in the Order of the Phoenix?"
Hagrid was taken aback, not expecting to hear the Order of the Order of the Phoenix from Charle.
He shared in the glory of the Way.
"That's right, I am a member of the Order of the Phoenix."
"I can't tell you exactly who the Order of the Order of the Phoenix is, but there are at least ten people in total."
Charle nodded, interrupting Hagrid.
"So the Order of the Phoenix has only a dozen or so people from beginning to end. Let's say you have twenty people. You shouldn't have any peripheral members like the Death Eater."
"After all, given Dumbledore's style, you probably don't have much funding and will have to bring your own rations to fight."
"How many Death Eater are there? The core members are about the same as yours, but there are at least several hundred peripheral members and those Dark Creature. Your Order of the Phoenix is so strong, how can you take on a dozen or twenty Death Eater at once, even with the core Death Eater on your side?"
Hagrid paused for a moment.
"No, no, that's not true..."
Charle chuckled.
"Then I'd like to ask, your Order of the Order of the Phoenix only has enough manpower to deal with a few insignificant Death Eater. If a large-scale battle breaks out, who will fight the Death Eater?"
Hagrid thought for a moment, then said with some hesitation.
"The Auror from the Ministry of Magic will also participate in the battle, and their numbers will be even greater, enough to fight against many Death Eater."
Charle nodded, then asked a question in return.
"The Order of the Phoenix's role is at most to restrain a small number of Death Eater; the real battles are fought by the Auror of the Ministry of Magic."
"Did Dumbledore lead the Auror? Which Ministry of Magic Director position did he hold, or did he act as Minister of Magic during wartime? Which large-scale battle did he participate in the strategic planning of?"
"Why do you make it sound like the fight against the Death Eater is all thanks to the Order of the Order of the Phoenix and Dumbledore? What about the Auror and other resistance groups? You've taken credit for them?"
Before Hagrid could answer, Charle continued to ask.
"Voldemort was involved in numerous battles during the previous Wizarding World Wars, committing arson, murder, and looting, earning a fearsome reputation; those he killed dared not even utter his name." "Then I'd like to ask, what Dumbledore?"
"Since he is so powerful, the only person Voldemort fears in the Wizarding World, in this chaotic world, Dumbledore should step forward, raise the banner, and unite all the forces of resistance under the banner."
"He should have taken over as Minister of Magic based on his reputation, led the overall operation, and taken the initiative to wipe out the Death Eater that they wouldn't dare mention his name. But where was he then?"
"Why is he still at Hogwarts? Why is Dumbledore rarely seen taking action? The number of Auror under the mysterious person's command is countless. How many Death Eater does Dumbledore have under his command?"
Hagrid was speechless for a moment.
"Because the young wizards at Hogwarts need Dumbledore's protection..."
This made Charle laugh out loud.
Are you kidding me?
"The descendants and relatives of the Death Eater also attend Hogwarts. Slytherin House is part of Hogwarts. What are they doing here, slaughtering young wizards at Hogwarts before even dealing with the Auror and the Rebellion?"
"If Dumbledore was in charge of Hogwarts, it would make sense if he were using the descendants of the Death Eater from Slytherin House as hostages to intimidate the Death Eater and force them to surrender quickly. But did Dumbledore do that?"
"It seems he doesn't. In other words, what positive impact could his presence at Hogwarts have on the battle against Voldemort and the Death Eater?"
"Voldemort ran around everywhere, killing people indiscriminately, striking fear into the hearts of all. Dumbledore, the only one who could rival Voldemort, spent most of his time maintaining order at Hogwarts. Is that what you call making a huge contribution?"
Hearing Charle's mocking laughter, Hagrid trembled with rage.
"Nonsense, you're talking nonsense!"
"Dumbledore credit for the defeat of the mysterious person!"
"I can say that, "Charle said calmly.
"The Harry Potter family made the most direct contribution to the defeat of the mysterious person."
Was Dumbledore present at the time? No, he probably wasn't. So what contribution did he make in defeating the mysterious person?
"Could it be that Dumbledore also deserves some credit for Harry Potter?"
Hagrid was speechless.
Charle shook his head.
"So I've always been quite puzzled by how you Order of the Phoenix talk about how you've made such great contributions, how many Death Eater Dumbledore killed, and how many times you've defeated Voldemort. You're quite good at patting yourselves on the back."
"Dumbledore made an inspiring contribution, providing a pillar of support to the Auror and resistance groups in the Wizarding World. I acknowledge that contribution, but what else is there?"
"If an ordinary Auror possessed Dumbledore's power, perhaps he could accomplish far more."
"Perhaps he will shoulder the responsibility of leading the Wizarding World, instead of having great abilities but staying at Hogwarts and not even daring to take on the position of Minister of Magic."
"Perhaps he will hate Death Eater even more. Wherever there are Death Eater, there he will be, waving his Wand and shooting out golden flames. When he encounters a difficult enemy, he will take care of it himself instead of ordinary Auror risking their lives."
"There would be far fewer deaths and injuries in the Wizarding World, the Death Eater would be much more cautious, and the Wizarding World would not be filled with despair and fear, to the point that no one dares to mention the name of the Voldemort now."
"Ask yourself honestly, did Dumbledore do what he was supposed to do given his abilities?"
"Or let me put it another way, Hagrid, if you had Dumbledore's power and saw your Order of the Order of the Phoenix members die in battle, what would you do?"
Hagrid answered instinctively.
"Of course, we're going to eliminate the Death Eater and defeat Voldemort..."
Charle countered with a question.
"Did Dumbledore do that? Did he actively seek out Voldemort, or actively kill the Death Eater?"
Hagrid was speechless for a long while before finally managing to utter a muffled sentence.
"Dumbledore has his own considerations; some battles belong to us."
These words made Charle shake his head.
"So even the final battle that ended Voldemort's reign was made by Harry Potter, this baby? Where was Dumbledore's battlefield?"
"Alright, I won't repeat how great Dumbledore was when the war broke out."
"Perhaps Dumbledore's greatness lies in his handling of the aftermath."
"I ask you, how much compensation did those fallen comrades of the Order of the Order of the Phoenix receive?"
Hagrid looked as if he had been insulted.
"Pension?"
"We're not fighting for that; we're fighting for peace and justice!"
"It's happening, "Charle said calmly.
"What will their families do to survive after they die in battle?"
"The Order of the Phoenix hasn't even made a single statement?"
"Okay, I understand. The Order of the Order of the Phoenix is an unofficial, loosely organized society with no source of funding."
"So they also made great contributions to the fight against Voldemort. Auror who sacrificed their lives received compensation and official honors, which are considered as dying in the line of duty. Did Dumbledore advocate for the members of the Order of the Order of the Phoenix who died in battle?"
"In the official records of the Wizarding World, were they warriors who died fighting Voldemort and the Death Eater, or ordinary victims? These are two different things, aren't they?"
"Oh? Still nothing? The great Dumbledore didn't even fight for anything for his fallen comrades? Ha, how great, how noble."
"That's right, it's exactly the same as his attitude towards Harry Potter. Hagrid, you must know what kind of life Harry Potter has been living all these years, right?"
When this was mentioned, Hagrid's face showed anger, and his voice choked with emotion.
"Of course I know! I can't believe Harry Potter's relatives would treat him like that!"
Charle countered with a question.
"What else should Harry Potter's relatives do to him?"
"No matter how you treat him, what right do you have to say that?"
"From the time Harry Potter was a baby to the present, did anyone in the Wizarding World ever take care of him for even a single day? Did they ever buy him a diaper or a bag of formula?"
"You've paid for all the medical treatment he's had since he was a child? Don't you know how much it costs to raise a child?"
"In my opinion, his relatives have done their most basic moral duty and responsibility by raising Harry Potter to adulthood in good health."
"On the contrary, what did you, especially the great Dumbledore you speak of, do when you knew Harry Potter was there?"
"Putting everything else aside, is it so hard to allocate some funds to them? Is it so hard to visit them regularly and show concern for Harry Potter?"
"So, what exactly is the greatness of the Hogwarts Headmaster who slacked off during the war, who didn't provide compensation to his comrades after the war, didn't fight for their rightful honor and reputation, and didn't even provide financial support for Harry Potter, an orphan, leaving him to a Muggle family and ignoring him for eleven years? Why is Hagrid so devoted to questioning me like this?"
"I really want to hear it clearly. Go ahead and tell me, I'm all ears."
Hagrid's face turned from red to green and then to death.
He really wanted to yell at Charle and tell him that it was all nonsense.
But what Charle said didn't seem to have any problems; it wasn't a fabricated fact.
The members of the Order of the Phoenix who died in battle did not receive any compensation, and many of their merits and contributions were known only to members of the Order of the Phoenix and were not officially recognized by the Ministry of Ministry of Magic.
The Weasley family's impoverished life, Lupin's awkward situation as werewolf, and Lupin's own situation seemed to remain unchanged despite the Order of the Phoenix.
As for Harry Potter's childhood, that left Hagrid speechless.
Only now did he realize that his attitude toward the Dursley after his visit was indeed very inappropriate.
No matter how harsh they were, they genuinely took care of Harry Potter for eleven years.
Although Hagrid had no children, he understood that taking care of children was much more difficult than taking care of Magical Creatures.
Children get sick, cry, need their diapers changed every few hours, and need to be sent to school and for education...
Hagrid did nothing, so he has no right to criticize the Dursley.
But if Hagrid knew that Harry Potter was there, Hagrid vowed that he would do everything in his power to raise Harry to be healthy and happy.
Even if she had to sell all her possessions, she would still regularly send money to the Dursley, make sure they bought Harry new clothes and glasses, took Harry out to play, and never let Harry suffer the slightest grievance.
If only we could let him know even a little bit of information!
Dumbledore didn't tell him, but Dumbledore did nothing.
As the Hogwarts Headmaster, Dumbledore had to deal with children every day. Didn't he know that raising children costs money?
What on earth happened?
Hagrid looked bewildered and, looking lost, led Charle deeper into the Forbidden Forest.
He had even gone to the territory of the Acromantula -Acromantula, hoping that they would appear in front of Charle and give Charle a good scare.
In this way, the Charle might repent for insulting Dumbledore.
Right now, Hagrid was in a state of utter confusion and had no desire to make Charle repent.
He desperately wanted to banish Charle's words from his mind, but the scenes from the past kept replaying in his mind.
Yes, after being expelled from Hogwarts with his broken Wand, Dumbledore was the only person who believed in him. Later, he even found him a job as a gamekeeper and accepted him, Half-Giant, into the Order of the Phoenix. These were all things that made him extremely grateful.
At that time, Dumbledore was not the Hogwarts Headmaster, but a professor of Transfiguration, and could not clear his name.
Later, however, Dumbledore had become a renowned headmaster and the chief judge of the Wizengamot Court, and he was fully capable of clearing his name.
At least, I can have my own Wand again after so many years, right?
And then there's Lupin, who left after the war because there were no positions available for him.
But there were actually many job openings at the time. Many people had died in the Wizarding World, and everything needed to be rebuilt.
If Dumbledore were willing to give Lupin a letter of recommendation, act as his guarantor, and publicize Lupin's heroic deeds against the Order of the Phoenix, perhaps Lupin could get a job and wouldn't have to leave his hometown.
Then there's the Weasley family. Mr. Weasley missed out on many opportunities at the Ministry of Magic because of his involvement with the Order of the Phoenix.
If Mr. Weasley had participated in the Ministry of Ministry of Magic's organized battles, he could have become a temporary Auror. Based on his wartime achievements, many positions would have become available after the war, and his rank would have been at least two levels higher than it is now.
If Dumbledore were willing to speak up for Mr. Weasley would definitely get a promotion and be living a much better life than he is now.
At least the Weasley family kids don't have to share old clothes or buy everything secondhand.
Every time Hagrid sees it, it breaks his heart.
All of this could have been changed; all it would have taken was for Dumbledore to say a single word.
But no, there was nothing.
Hagrid vaguely felt that they were like chess pieces on a chessboard, as long as they could play their role.
As for their own lives, Dumbledore didn't care at all.
Just as Hagrid was in a state of confusion, his hound, Fang, suddenly barked, bringing Hagrid back to his senses.
Under the glow of the Charle Lumos spell, shadowy figures wearing hoods could be seen in the shadows of the Forbidden Forest.
There were at least a dozen people surrounding Hagrid and Charle from all directions.
A sense of dread washed over Hagrid instantly.
This is Forbidden Forest; what kind of benevolent beings could appear here?
They're either poachers or dark wizards!
When he saw a faint golden glint flash across the shadows, Hagrid immediately understood the meaning of this display.
"Lucius Malfoy, I see you!"
"What exactly do you want by bringing your men to the Forbidden Forest?!"
Lucius, whose identity was exposed by the reflection of his hair, simply stopped pretending after Hagrid called him out.
He sneered and stepped out of the shadows, his eyes flashing with undisguised malice and murderous intent.
"What are we doing? A trial, of course!"
"Snape is dead, my son's bones were broken, and he's been traumatized. It's all that Mudblood's fault!"
"He did something like that, and he wasn't expelled from Hogwarts for breaking his Wand? Is that fair?"
"I will represent the Malfoy family and personally reclaim justice!"
Hagrid growled, putting his earlier argument with the Charle behind him.
He grabbed the umbrella he was using as Wand.
"I won't let you succeed!"
Lucius sneered dismissively.
"A Half-Giant, thick-skinned and tough, if he had Wand in his hand, I might be wary of him."
"Just with that lousy umbrella of yours?"
"Perfect! I've long disliked you, you filthy creature. Today, you and that Mudblood will be wiped out forever!"
He carried an arrogant, condescending air, as if he already held the lives of Charle and Hagrid in his hands.
"Of course, you can also try to struggle."
"I've prepared quite a lot for this moment. Look at these dark wizards from Knockturn Alley, I paid a lot of money to hire them. Each one is carrying Dark Magic Item and is fully armed."
"I've also prepared several powerful magical items here. If I can't even use them, wouldn't all my efforts have been in vain?"
"I look forward to testing their power on you."
Upon hearing Lucius's words, a hint of despair flickered in Hagrid's eyes.
He suddenly pulled a signal flare from his pocket and turned to Charle, giving him instructions.
"I'll create an opportunity for you in a moment. Don't look back, run!"
"Once this signal is sent out, it won't be long before Dumbledore and the other professors are notified that they are here and you are safe."
Next, Hagrid prepared to launch the signal flare into the air above the Forbidden Forest.
Upon seeing this, Lucius roared.
"Don't let him send a signal!"
"I'm going to prepare that Mudblood properly; I don't want it to end so soon!"
The next moment, the dark wizards of Knockturn Alley raised their Wand.
A dazzling red light flashed by, accompanied by a whisper.
"Stupefy!"
Hagrid was struck by a Stunning Spell.
This Stunning Spell seemed ridiculously powerful. The Half-Giant's magic resistance was practically nonexistent in front of it. Hagrid instantly lost consciousness, and the flare in his hand fell to the ground, failing to be sent successfully.
Lucius was overjoyed at the sight.
"A beautiful Stunning Spell!"
"Whoever posted this, I'm going to give them extra money!"
The dark wizards in Knockturn Alley just looked at each other, their eyes filled with doubt.
"Did you make a move?"
"No, I haven't had time yet."
"Besides, I can't use such a powerful Stunning Spell."
"Who's this big shot? They've been keeping a low profile!"
Just then, Charle's small, thin figure appeared beside the fallen Hagrid.
He grinned broadly, his smile radiant, his eyes burning with passion.
"Isn't the Stunning Spell pretty?"
"Don't bother looking, I put it there. After all, if Dumbledore comes, it won't be convenient for me."
"So, are you going to hand over the magical items yourselves, or do you want me to do it?"