Is Gellert Grindelwald, like himself, a Prophet Animagus?
Jon found it hard to believe, yet when it came from Albus Dumbledore, he couldn't bring himself to doubt it.
"In fact, at the very beginning, I knew nothing about the Prophet Animagus ..." Dumbledore began slowly, "Until the spring and summer of 1945, after that duel in Berlin; Gellert dropped his Wand and told me the truth... He told me everything, and then asked for my forgiveness..."
"But I can't forgive him..." Dumbledore's eyes welled up with tears as he looked at the painting. "Because of Alan, because of Yusuf ... and because of Ariana ..."
The girl in the portrait gently shook her head at Dumbledore.
"You stopped him from being sentenced to death, didn't you?" Jon said softly. "I've read in The Modern Magical History that Minister Leonard Moon and Mr. Winston Churchill tried to execute him... but someone persuaded them, and in the end, the dark wizard Grindelwald was sentenced to life imprisonment without parole."
"There are many other ways to destroy a person that are far more cruel than death," Dumbledore, not denying it but simply explaining.
Jon nodded slightly and did not say anything more.
The Dungeon door was rudely pushed open, interrupting their conversation.
Aberforth Dumbledore burst in, carrying two dirty beer mugs filled with Butterbeer.
He slammed the two glasses of beer down on the table, then glanced at Headmaster Dumbledore was still sitting cross-legged in front of the painting.
"Don't dirty my floor!" Aberforth snapped.
"I understand... I will clean it up..." Albus Dumbledore wiped away the tears from the corners of his eyes as he answered, and sat back down at the table.
Aberforth walked out of the Dungeon without looking back, slamming the door shut behind him.
"My rude and impulsive brother..." Dumbledore sighed as he watched Aberforth's departing figure. "He deserves more respect and admiration than I do!"
"Mr. Dumbledore still trusts and respects you..." Jon said sincerely, "He's just not good at expressing his feelings."
"Yes!" Albus Dumbledore smiled. "I almost forgot that you Prophet Animagus' identity. Actually, you should know each other better than we do."
"Let's start from the beginning..." Dumbledore suggested.
"When I first saw you, at the Sorting Ceremony four years ago... I didn't pay much attention to you initially, after all, you were just an ordinary Muggle-born freshman... although Godric Gryffindor has always insisted that Muggle-born wizard is itself a remarkable talent..."
"I quite agree with Mr. Gryffindor's point of view!" Jon couldn't help but interject.
"... The Sorting Hat told me that you refused to go to Gryffindor and went to Hufflepuff instead!" Dumbledore ignored Jon's interruption and continued with a smile, "Please forgive an old man's selfishness; it made me a little unhappy at the time. And this might sound a bit boastful, because because I'm from Gryffindor, in recent years there have usually been a few more students who voluntarily choose to go to Gryffindor..."
"But you are indeed a perfect Hufflepuff, diligence and integrity are embodied in you to the fullest extent..." Dumbledore gave Jon a meaningful look.
"You started paying attention to me back then?" Jon asked, somewhat surprised.
"Of course not..." Dumbledore shook his head. "A headmaster can't possibly pay attention to every student every moment. To me, you're just a thriving little blade of grass, but it will take some time before you grow up to stand before me..."
"Later, the monster in the Chamber of Secrets appeared... You subtly hinted at Miss Weasley's unusual behavior and the Basilisk's whereabouts through a few clever tricks... I must say you did a very clever job, keeping your presence out of my sight; I searched the castle for months, but never imagined the 'culprit' would be a first-year student; I even thought it was all a coincidence..."
"If it weren't for that Boggart incident... I might have remained in the dark forever." A smile appeared on Dumbledore's face. "After that incident, and thinking back on everything that had happened, I understood everything."
"To be honest, I was shocked at the time..." Jon nodded.
"You and Gellert are very similar, after all, you share the same talent..." Dumbledore's expression gradually became serious. "You are meticulous, hardworking, and extremely diligent... However, compared to Gellert, you are not as cold and ruthless; you are much more upright and kind..."
"Honest and kind..." Jon was taken aback, not expecting Dumbledore to make such a comment about him.
"To prevent that Slytherin's monster from harming more people... you've been hinting at the truth to us, trying to guide us. If we had been wiser, there might not have been an attack after Mrs. Norris... It's just a pity we were too slow," Dumbledore said calmly.
"I don't know what will happen next. Without you... perhaps more students will be attacked, perhaps some will die, perhaps I will truly lose my headmaster's hat, and perhaps Hogwarts will even close down..."
"You stopped all of this from happening, Jon." Dumbledore raised his Butterbeer. "So now I must pay tribute to you, to the courage you held in your heart, and to your kind and upright heart!"
"To be honest, it might be a little embarrassing..." Jon smiled helplessly, "Actually, I was just trying to protect myself. After all, as a Muggle-born wizards, I could be attacked by the Basilisk at any time... When the nest is overturned, no egg remains intact."
"There are many ways to protect yourself, but you've chosen the one I admire most," Dumbledore gentle smile. "And of course, there was the matter of Miss Greengrass, how anxious and concerned you were when Miss Greengrass fainted during Defence Against the Dark Arts ..."
"So when I learned that you were a Prophet Animagus, I was very happy... because I knew very well that you would not become a second Gellert, even though you are very similar to him."