Ch. 481Just a Joke—How Could That Count as Evidence?
At Hogwarts, Umbridge and Fudge questioned Aaron and Marietta about secret Defense Against the Dark Arts practice and alleged student gatherings. Aaron defended himself by claiming neutrality toward the Ministry, while Umbridge tried to use Marietta’s testimony as evidence.
- Fudge questioned Marietta, but she refused to say more after describing the Room of Requirement.
- Aaron explained that he had practiced Defense Against the Dark Arts because Umbridge taught only theory, and claimed his family required him to earn an O on his O.W.L.
- Umbridge accused Aaron and other students of organizing illegal gatherings, citing Willy Widdershins’s testimony, but Aaron said his remarks about Voldemort’s return had been a joke.
- Aaron persuaded Fudge that he had never publicly opposed the Ministry, and Fudge stopped Umbridge from pressing that accusation.
- Umbridge claimed Marietta’s nod proved the students had continued meeting, while Aaron challenged the claim and suggested her disfigurement did not count as evidence.