Ch. 61I Really Don't Recommend This Method
Chapter Summary: “I Really Don’t Recommend This Method”
Key Plot Points and Events
- Sandman and the Emperor discuss the future of faster-than-light travel. Sandman confirms that the problem has effectively been solved, though the technology will require time to develop.
- The Emperor asks whether true interstellar travel and communication will also be solved. Sandman warns that reliable long-distance communication remains dangerous because it could expose humanity’s information to hostile powers.
- Sandman suggests the Necron Pharos Lighthouse as a possible communication solution. The Emperor rejects it because:
- The Necrons are dormant rather than extinct.
- Using their technology would expose the Imperium to them.
- The Lighthouse’s activation historically attracts the Tyranids, creating a catastrophic future threat.
- They discuss the Astronomican, the Emperor’s own psychic beacon. It guides Imperial ships through the Warp but is unreliable because it depends on the Emperor’s power and fails whenever something goes wrong with him.
- Sandman recommends continuing to rely on Astropathic Communication rather than using the Pharos Lighthouse.
- The conversation shifts to religion. Sandman takes a pragmatic position, endorsing both the Emperor’s Imperial Truth and the future Lectitio Divinitatus, arguing that religion will eventually emerge regardless of Imperial policy.
- Sandman attempts to leave, but the Emperor traps him inside the golden psychic chamber and demands that he help recover the lost Primarchs.
- Sandman becomes interested, seeing the opportunity to establish his own version of a Second Imperium.
Character Developments
- Sandman remains irreverent, cynical, and unwilling to become the Emperor’s permanent adviser. He gives useful information but mocks the Emperor’s questioning and avoids taking responsibility for major decisions.
- He demonstrates strong strategic insight, recognizing the dangers of the Pharos Lighthouse and the limitations of the Astronomican.
- Sandman’s attitude toward religion is revealed as highly pragmatic: he is willing to support contradictory ideologies if doing so is useful.
- The Emperor becomes increasingly dependent on Sandman’s knowledge of the future. His questions show that he is eager to exploit every possible advantage, but he still rejects solutions that threaten the Imperium on too great a scale.
- His willingness to imprison Sandman and force him to cooperate reveals his controlling nature and desperation to accelerate humanity’s development.
- The Emperor’s opinion of Korax improves considerably because of the benefits Sandman has provided, and he no longer cares about Sandman’s earlier trick involving the Power Whip.
Significant Themes
- Short-term solutions versus long-term consequences: The Pharos Lighthouse could solve communication problems immediately but would ultimately bring the Tyranids and endanger the entire galaxy.
- The dangers of technological dependence: Both the Necron communications system and the Astronomican offer immense benefits while creating severe vulnerabilities.
- Pragmatism over ideology: Sandman argues that neither science-based Imperial Truth nor organized religion can simply be imposed or rejected; political survival requires flexibility.
- The burden of foresight: Knowledge of the future does not make decisions easy, since every solution may create an even greater disaster.
- Power and control: The Emperor treats Sandman as both a valuable resource and a captive, emphasizing the authoritarian nature of their relationship.
Character Interactions
- Sandman repeatedly treats the Emperor with sarcasm, comparing him to an unreasonable question machine and criticizing his systems.
- The Emperor listens carefully to Sandman’s advice, but he challenges or rejects ideas that threaten Imperial security.
- Their relationship is built on mutual usefulness rather than trust: Sandman wants freedom and independence, while the Emperor wants to exploit his future knowledge.
- The chapter ends with the Emperor compelling Sandman to help recover the lost Primarchs. Sandman accepts the opportunity because it may allow him to create his own powerful political order, the Second Imperium.