Seeing the situation reach a stalemate due to Class A's clear Silent Strategy, Toudou Shizuya, who had been keeping quiet as an observer, finally broke the silence.
He leaned forward slightly, his sharp gaze fixed on Machida Koji, his tone carrying an unavoidable questioning tone:
"Machida, your explanation of the Silent Strategy just now sounded logically sound and seemed impeccable."
But if I may be frank—didn't your Class A consider that this practice of everyone remaining silent throughout might actually make it easier for the 'VIP' whose identity is still unclear to hide, or even win easily?"
His words were like a pebble precisely thrown into a calm Lake Surface, instantly creating ripples and shattering the closed atmosphere of "rational optimal solution" that Class A was trying to create.
This forced everyone present to refocus their attention on the core contradiction of the test: the "VIP" issue.
Machida Koji stopped tapping his fingers.
He looked up at Toudou Shizuya, not directly answering the pointed question, but instead posing a counter-question, his tone carrying a hint of calm as he tried to steer the conversation toward a deeper level of consideration:
"Toudou, before we delve into how those VIP might act, you might want to consider a more fundamental question first."
In this test, what outcome should all of us, the participants, strive to avoid most?
He deliberately slowed his speech, trying to steer the conversation back onto a familiar track of strategic assessment.
Sitting in the Class D area, Karuizawa Kei immediately grasped the key point. She frowned slightly, and took over the conversation in a clear voice, with a hint of uncertainty in her tone:
"What we should most avoid is someone seeing through the VIP's identity and then choosing to betray the class for their own benefit, causing the entire team to lose points?"
Her words struck a chord with the underlying concerns of most people present, and many nodded subconsciously.
"That's very accurate." Machida Koji immediately agreed with her statement, sitting up straighter and scanning the room with a confident look that suggested he had the whole situation under control.
His tone carried an undeniable certainty. "For our Class A, the most dangerous thing is to speculate and doubt about whether a specific person around us is VIP through open discussion."
Once such a seed of doubt is planted, it can easily trigger a chain reaction within the group, leading to mutual suspicion and internal friction.
Ultimately, some people may act rashly due to incomplete information or misjudgment, making irreparable mistakes.
Compared to the information delays that might result from remaining silent, the collapse of internal trust and the resulting loss of points are far more damaging to the class and much harder to recover from.
He reiterated that silence was a necessary means to avoid the greatest risks, attempting to use the shield of "avoiding internal friction" to solidify the rationality of Class A's strategy.
After listening, Toudou Shizuya nodded slightly, his tone softening somewhat as if to indicate understanding, but his intention to press for answers remained unchanged:
"From the perspective of risk aversion, I partially agree with the concern expressed by Machida."
Suspicion is indeed a major taboo in teamwork, and avoiding unfounded suspicion is valuable.
But then he shifted his focus, his gaze no longer fixed on Machida, but sweeping over the representatives of all the classes present, and posed a new, more threatening question.
"However, we now have a fundamental problem that we cannot solve—none of us know who the VIP are."
If everyone follows Silent Strategy, without any information exchange or strategic coordination, the final result will likely be nothing more than maintaining the status quo.
The point difference between classes will not only not decrease, but may even become entrenched.
"What if..." He paused deliberately, emphasizing his words, "I mean, what if the School Authority, when allocating VIP, has some considerations that we don't know about?"
What if they are distributed extremely unevenly, or even highly concentrated in a particular class?
"Wouldn't the other classes then have no chance to resist or fight back, and be forced to passively accept this disadvantage determined by the initial allocation?"
"You don't need to worry too much about this."
Machida Koji retorted almost without thinking, his tone conveying an unwavering conviction in the fairness of the School Authority's rules, as if it were an indisputable axiom.
The principle of "fairness and consistency across all classes" was already demonstrated in the last Deserted Island Special Exam, and this has always been the bottom line that the School Authority adheres to.
The allocation of VIP is unlikely to be highly concentrated in one class; the most probable scenario is that Average Score among the four classes.
This is a reasonable judgment made by our Class A after in-depth analysis of the Exam Rules."
His words revealed Class A's confidence in information analysis.
"Average Score does sound reasonable, but rules are rigid, while people's hearts are flexible."
Toudou Shizuya did not back down at all. He stared intently at Machida Koji, his tone carrying a hint of doubt.
"Well then, Machida, let's make this assumption: what if, I mean what if, the VIP happens to be assigned to Class A, due to some personal reason..."
They accepted a private deal with other classes, choosing to betray the collective interests of Class A.
He/She deliberately slows down the discussion, or worse, leaks key information to the outside world, disrupting the overall balance.
By that time, the premise of 'Average Score' that you relied on will be broken from within.
Can your carefully maintained Silent Strategy resolve this crisis caused by 'internal betrayal'? Can silence prevent betrayal from happening?
Just as the atmosphere between the two was becoming increasingly tense, Ichinose Honami's gentle and soothing voice rang out once again at the opportune moment.
She skillfully eased the tense atmosphere, yet also incisively pointed out the core difficulty of the collaboration:
"I think both of your points have merit—silence can indeed mitigate internal friction caused by suspicion to some extent, and remaining vigilant against potential betrayal is also essential."
She sighed softly, her eyes filled with a sense of helplessness in the face of reality. "However, it is extremely difficult to truly carry out the ideal state of 'no doubt, no betrayal' to the end."
This is not something that can be achieved by relying on the self-discipline of a single class; it requires all first-grade students participating in the test to firmly uphold the bottom line of cooperation.
This is almost... an idealistic requirement.
(Because the first few episodes of the second season were similar to the dialogues of the werewolf game test characters, they were relatively weak. In fact, it was also introduced later that each group was arranged by the academy according to the rules of the class names and the VIP.)
(Please excuse the somewhat watery content)