"At least within Class A, we can trust each other!"
Machida Koji seemed to have been touched on a sensitive spot by those words, and hurriedly spoke up to emphasize it, his tone carrying a hint of barely perceptible urgency.
As if eager to prove the specialness and reliability of Class A, "Our classmates have gone through multiple tests and selections before."
We've already established a sufficient foundation of understanding and trust, so the kind of internal betrayal you described would never happen.
His words revealed his confidence in the cohesion of Class A.
No sooner had he finished speaking than Toudou Shizuya suddenly chuckled softly. The chuckle was light, but it carried an undisguised mockery, instantly causing Machida Koji's face to darken.
"Can Class A truly trust each other completely?" Toudou Shizuya raised an eyebrow at him, her tone clearly skeptical.
"Then, may I ask why, in that Deserted Island Special Exam not long ago, the strong Class A was ultimately defeated by Class D?"
Moreover, I seem to have vaguely heard some rumors circulating—" He deliberately drew out his words, his gaze fixed on Machida, "The reason why Class A suffered an unexpected defeat was supposedly because there was a 'traitor' within the organization."
Someone secretly colluded with outsiders and leaked crucial intelligence, which led to the collapse of your entire strategy.
I wonder if there's any truth to this rumor?
His words were like a poisoned blade, precisely and ruthlessly piercing the deepest wounds and hidden pains of Class A that they least wanted to mention.
"So, now, Machida," Toudou Shizuya asked, his gaze sharp as a hawk's, intently watching the other's rapidly changing expression.
"After experiencing such an event, do you still dare to so confidently claim that there can be complete and unreserved trust within Class A?"
Is your trust truly so unbreakable?
Machida Koji's face turned ashen in an instant. His lips moved involuntarily, but it was as if something was blocking his throat, and he couldn't utter a single word.
What Toudou Shizuya mentioned was indeed an undeniable fact—the "traitor" incident during the last exam remains a shameful and painful memory that Class A keeps quiet about and is unwilling to let outsiders touch.
He opened his mouth, wanting to refute with feeble words, but found that any explanation was powerless in the face of the bloody facts, and in the end he could only clench his fists tightly.
He silently looked away, and the composure he had been trying so hard to maintain showed obvious signs of collapsing at that moment.
The discussion hadn't even ended when, on the other side of the Meeting Room, several girls from Class C were huddled together, whispering amongst themselves, their gazes occasionally drifting towards Machida Koji with complicated expressions.
One of them nodded slightly, his tone carrying a hint of practical consideration. "Actually... Machida's Silent Strategy does seem much simpler and easier than painstakingly guessing who the VIP are."
No need to bother observing, no need to worry about falling into a trap, and no need to be afraid of offending people by guessing wrong. Just follow everyone else, keep quiet, and wait peacefully until it's over."
The girl next to him frowned and retorted, appearing even more cautious. "But just because it's simple and convenient doesn't mean it's problem-free."
What if, as Toudou hypothesized, our class's VIP was found by someone from another class using other methods?
Or worse, what if someone within our own class succumbs to temptation and betrays us? Won't those of us who remain silent still suffer the consequences?
These few whispered comments perfectly captured the common struggle and unease in the minds of middle and lower-ranking classes like C and D.
On the other side, in Class D's area, Sotomura Hideo seemed to still be struggling to process the series of complex exchanges that had just taken place.
He turned to look at Yukimura Teruhiko, who had remained silent for most of the meeting, his tone filled with genuine confusion:
"Classmate Yukimura, I feel like... Machida's strategy doesn't seem to have any major problems, does it?"
If everyone could truly refrain from discussing these issues, wouldn't that fundamentally prevent suspicion and betrayal?
What's wrong with passing the test peacefully like this?
"I also think there's no problem." Yukimura Teruhiko was standing next to him, simply shook his head slightly, then let out a meaningful sigh.
He didn't explain immediately, but instead stared intently in the direction of Class A —clearly, he had noticed the hidden dangers behind the strategy earlier than the others from the Sotomura.
Just then, Ichinose Honami's gentle yet clear voice rang out again, breaking the hushed conversation in the corner and drawing everyone's attention back to the core of the meeting.
She looked at Machida Koji, whose expression was still not very good, and said in a calm but exceptionally clear tone, "Machida, please allow me to point out something."
The 'complete silence' strategy you just advocated is actually based entirely on your position and interests as a student in Class A.
For Class A, who are currently in the lead, maintaining their existing advantage and passing the test in the safest and least error-prone way is indeed the best solution for you."
She paused, her gaze sweeping over the representatives of Class B, Class C, and Class D, her voice gentle yet carrying an undeniable strength, "But please try to put yourself in their shoes."
For Class Points and desperately need an opportunity to reverse their rankings, this strategy of yours...
This effectively killed one of our few opportunities to acquire Huge Class Points by correctly identifying those VIP."
She further elaborated on the unfairness of the situation:
"Once everyone is bound to the unified strategy of 'no discussion, no action,' the final Class Ranking will most likely remain unchanged or even become fixed."
This is essentially a form of implicit unfairness for classes like ours that need to catch up and seize opportunities.
We were forced to relinquish our right to actively fight for it, all simply to cooperate with the leader in maintaining the 'stability' of their advantage."
Isn't your strategy also a form of 'unified action'?
Machida Koji immediately seized on a point in her words, his tone sharp and retaliatory, attempting to turn the tide.
"When you suggested that everyone collaborate and share information, weren't you trying to get everyone to act in accordance with the 'collaboration' direction you set?"
Why do you believe your "unity" is correct and fair, while my "unified silence" is wrong and unfair? It's simply a matter of different perspectives.
Before Ichinose could respond to this sharp question, Toudou Shizuya's voice suddenly broke in.
He looked at Machida Koji, his tone calm but carrying an undeniable reminder: "Machida, Ichinose obviously hasn't fully explained her point of view yet."