Currently, only Sirius among the three is still unable to accept it.
Sirius.
Dumbledore sighed, his guilt clearly visible in his azure eyes.
"This matter... is far more complex than simply a student's decision to stay or leave."
Sirius snorted coldly and didn't say anything, but he managed to control his emotions.
Dumbledore a deep breath, his gaze swept over the three of them, and finally settled on Harry, bowing once more.
"Harry, your trust makes me feel ashamed. Because this 'just cause' is precisely based on the injustice done to you."
He placed his hands on the table, his knuckles turning slightly white from the force.
"Hank Borgin's father, representing himself and... the network of influence that effectively controls at least half of Knockturn Alley's shady businesses, presented us with a condition we couldn't refuse."
"They promised," Dumbledore's voice was clear and solemn, "That they would completely abandon all illegal transactions in Knockturn Alley, cease smuggling, the manufacture of Dark Magic items, and all shady dealings. The entire power structure of Knockturn Alley would shift towards a more moderate, even beneficial, direction for the magical community."
For centuries, Knockturn Alley has been the center of all the dark dealings in the British Wizarding World.
This narrow, dirty street, hidden behind the glamorous Diagon Alley, is a haven for Dark Magic items, illegal potions, and...
A hub for lost incantations, secret techniques, and all sorts of shady information and services.
It is a product of the United Kingdom magical society's forced compromise with dark wizards and the Pure-blood families behind them.
Even though Harry turned it into ruins, the All-Seeing Eye remained hanging in the sky.
The transactions have simply become more covert.
Just as Dark Magic (Jinx, Hex, Curse) is an integral part of magic, this dark trade is an inevitable aspect of magical society.
Completely abandon illegal transactions?
This means that the massive gray market industry, which the Ministry of Magic has been unable to eradicate despite generations of effort, will disintegrate on its own.
This means that countless dark wizards lurking in the shadows will lose their most important channel for selling stolen goods and their sanctuary;
This means that the security landscape of magical society will undergo a radical transformation.
Even the nearby Hog's Head Inn, perpetually filled with the smell of mutton and owned by a grumpy boss, will have its ambiguous, black-and-white ecosystem, on which it depends for survival, fundamentally impacted.
This is no longer about a student, or even just about Hogwarts. This is a deal that will shake the very foundations of the British Wizarding World.
Therefore...
The office was silent; even Phineas Black in the portrait held his breath.
"And what they traded in return," Dumbledore continued, "Was merely Hogwarts reopening its doors to Old Borgin's son, a student who had committed a grave crime, offering him a chance to reform."
He raised his head, his gaze seemingly piercing through the castle walls, looking into the distance. "I might be able to refuse a villain's threat, but I cannot easily stop a father from making a decision that is almost a sacrifice for his child's future, even if that future is full of thorns."
"This heavy price will ultimately be borne by you, Harry... I am deeply sorry for this."
"Wait!" Sirius interrupted abruptly, finally realizing what was happening. "Old Borgin? What right does he have to make this decision on behalf of the entire Knockturn Alley?"
In his childhood memories, Old Borgin was nothing more than a sleazy businessman who hunched over and dared not even breathe loudly in front of his mother, Walburga Black.
There is absolutely no way someone could have the energy and audacity to make a profit by reselling shady trinkets.
"Qualifications?" Snape's smooth, icy voice rang out, tinged with his usual sarcasm. "Perhaps our esteemed headmaster is getting on in years and has begun to be too gullible about such... obvious facades."
"This is not some great sacrifice of fatherly love at all."
"More likely, it's just the most respectable, or rather, the least humiliating, excuse that those truly lurking forces in Knockturn Alley, under the all-pervasive surveillance of the [All-Seeing Eye], could find to surrender to the White Wizards after realizing they had nowhere to run."
His words were like venom-soaked daggers, striking straight to the heart of the matter.
Snape's suspicions were not unfounded.
Since the activation of the magical artifact [All-Seeing Eye], which hangs high in the sky like the eye of a god, the Ministry of Magic has been monitoring illegal magical activities to an unprecedented degree.
Apparition fluctuation tracking, large-scale Jinx energy detection, and even the clear delineation of the blurred boundary between Diagon Alley and Knockturn Alley...
The gray areas that previously relied on secrecy and chaos have been drastically compressed.
Even the most arrogant dark wizard must admit that the days of unbridled freedom are over, and the future holds either rotting away in prison or... seeking some form of "legitimization."
"Old Borgin," Snape said, a slight, unsmiling smirk forming a hollow smile, "Is merely a fig leaf they've put forward, a convenient excuse for a deal with someone you know well. A face-saving measure acceptable to both sides."
Sirius nodded and then shook his head. "No, Albus just always tends to think the best of others."
"Perhaps." Dumbledore didn't take their words to heart.
Deep within his azure eyes lay a calm, deep sea; he wasn't so senile as to be unable to discern whether the forces of Knockturn Alley were truly led by Old Borgin.
Why did Old Borgin suddenly possess such influence and power? He would naturally investigate the reasons behind it at the appropriate time.
In fact, admitting Hank to the school was part of the investigation.
Just like how they knew Voldemort was right behind Quirrell's head, yet still allowed him to enter Hogwarts.
All of this is prepared for immediate observation.
His guilt towards Harry stemmed largely from this.
Harry has once again become a victim in some sense.
Although...
Dumbledore couldn't help but look up at Harry again.
Harry's smile remained unchanged, like the warm spring sun; Hank Borgin and everything related to him did not trouble him in any way.
But...
"Harry, I..."
"Don't mention it again. I've already said it, he's just Hank Borgin."
Harry stood up abruptly. "If there's nothing else, I'll be going now."
Then he walked straight out the door.
Watching Harry's retreating figure, Sirius sighed, "Dumbledore, let me give you a heads-up: don't expect me to treat Hank Borgin fairly."
He was determined that once Hank Borgin enrolled next semester, he would use his power to deal with the kid properly.
Let this kid experience the same kind of tormenting methods the Marauders used to use.
Dumbledore did not speak.
Snape: How do you think Slytherin House Cup these past few years?