At other times, McGonagall would be happy to discuss this entirely new topic about Animagus with her best student.
But now that Silvan is in fifth grade, which is one of the two most important milestones for Wizard, McGonagall is less inclined to continue talking to Silvan about things unrelated to the OWL exams.
But Silvan did not leave; instead, he spoke again.
"Wait, Professor, there's something else I want to say."
"Then you'd better hurry," McGonagall glanced at her watch. "I need to review the assignments you just handed in as soon as possible..."
There's something wrong with Sirius!
McGonagall's voice trailed off. She turned her head in confusion and asked, "Wait, what did you just say?"
"There's something wrong with Sirius," Silvan said again. "I think he might not be Sirius, or rather, someone might be impersonating him."
"That's impossible," McGonagall asserted. "Headmaster Dumbledore brought him into the school; no one can deceive Dumbledore with Magic."
"Um, I don't think so..." Silvan muttered to himself.
"You really should go get something to eat," McGonagall continued. "Besides, many of the professors at Hogwarts are old acquaintances of Sirius, including myself, but we haven't noticed anything wrong with him. And Potter, he wouldn't mistake his godfather, would he?"
That's even harder to say... Silvan thought to himself.
Upon closer examination, Harry and Sirius didn't spend a very long time together. They were certainly close, but how well-acquainted were they before?
That's not necessarily true.
"But Professor, Sirius has forgotten my pet cat," Silvan said again. "If it were him, he wouldn't have forgotten."
"A pet cat?" McGonagall frowned. "What does that mean?"
"Tom, my pet cat," Silvan explained. "I'm sure you know, Professor, that Sirius is also an Animagus. He was able to stay in Hogwarts by transforming into an animal."
McGonagall nodded.
Although this matter has not been made public, it is no secret to many people, and she certainly knows about it as well.
"That's the key point," Silvan said. "When Sirius came to Hogwarts, he was given a good beating by Tom, and ever since then he's become Tom's sidekick."
"But when he was talking to me, he didn't even know I had a pet cat, and he didn't recognize it when he saw Tom either, which is obviously very unusual."
The amount of information was overwhelming. McGonagall blinked, feeling her head buzzing.
If she remembered correctly, Sirius's Animagus was supposed to be a dog, and a large one at that... but it got beaten up by a cat after sneaking into Hogwarts?
No... now is not the time to think about these things.
McGonagall quickly noticed the second half of Silvan's sentence.
"You mean, he's completely forgotten about your cat?"
"That's right." Silvan nodded. "This is unusual, isn't it?"
McGonagall's expression gradually turned serious.
"Are you sure?" she said. "This isn't something to joke about. Are you sure the Sirius we're seeing now is someone else impersonating him?"
"To be honest, I'm not entirely sure," Silvan said, his mind drifting back to the Marauder's Map.
Actually, the Marauder's Map is the simplest and most direct method. As long as they take the map and open it, they can immediately expose each other's identities, unless that person's name is also Sirius Black.
But that's highly unlikely, considering the Black family is so small, you could count them on one hand. Even if we take a step back, who would choose a name that sounds like "the shame of the family"? And if someone did, they'd probably have changed it long ago.
Indeed, Sirius is a disgrace to the Black family, as evidenced more than once by Mrs. Black's portrait and the House-elf of their old house.
For a long time afterward, McGonagall remained silent, simply looking down as she paced aimlessly back and forth in the classroom, lost in thought.
After what seemed like an eternity, she finally stopped and said, "I need to tell the principal about this."
When in doubt, consulting Dumbledore is arguably the safest course of action.
"I've been meaning to say this," Silvan said, spreading his hands, "But by the time I realized it, Headmaster Dumbledore had already left the school."
"So when you asked me about the headmaster's whereabouts that day, it wasn't actually to ask about the time he was going to Hogsmeade?" McGonagall asked.
"That's part of the reason," Silvan said. "Back then, I also needed a few owls that could fly long distances to deliver messages, and the ones at school weren't quite up to par."
After another long silence, McGonagall said nothing more, only telling Silvan to hurry up and have lunch in the Great Hall.
"I will continue to observe him," Silvan said as he walked to the door.
"No." McGonagall rejected the suggestion without even thinking.
"No, Silvan," she said seriously, "If it's really as you say, Sirius is an imposter, then what you're doing is far too dangerous."
"Quite the opposite, Professor." Silvan shook his head. "Given the nature of my relationship with Sirius, it would be strange if we suddenly became distant; it would likely arouse his suspicion."
"I said, no!" McGonagall had no intention of listening to Silvan's explanation and refused again with a stern face.
Even though she knew perfectly well that Silvan was right, it wasn't enough for her to agree to let a student Silvan risk his life to get close to the unidentified Sirius.
"I can assign more homework," McGonagall said. "Fifth graders already have a lot of work, so this will give you a good reason not to go see him."
Silvan felt a chill run down his spine...
Add homework?
They already had so much homework they were about to finish. In the common room, the fifth-year students who were still rushing to finish their homework in the early hours of the morning were so resentful that even ghosts wouldn't want to approach them... Silvan had a premonition that if this matter were to be exposed one day, he might never be able to leave the gates of Hogwarts.
Those fifth-graders, blinded by rage, will kill him.
"Ah, McGonagall, I suddenly realize you have a very good point." Silvan cleared his throat. "I'll avoid Sirius from now on. As for more homework... I don't think it's necessary. The current amount of homework is more than enough to use as an excuse."
Before McGonagall could say anything more, Silvan dashed out of the classroom, closing the door behind him.