Arc 29The Black Lake Trial

The champions joined Hogwarts students to breach Marauders Power’s defensive array, then faced the Black Lake Maze and its tests of skill, self-knowledge, and genuine care. Fleur won the task, Douglas explained its lessons, and the story turned toward the third task and the wider effects of his ideas.

  • Hermione and the champions organized a school-wide assault on Marauders Power’s array, but its prank protocols humiliated the attackers until Neville’s sword formation struck a weak point and opened a brief passage to the merpeople settlement.
  • Sirius promoted the company’s Family Patronus Series with Ministry backing, while Cedric, Pheobe, Krum, Harry, Hermione, and Ron prepared for the lake task and learned that the merpeople would fiercely defend their territory.
  • At the Black Lake ceremony, the Weasley twins presented international messages and announced the Horus Cup exchange tournament before Percy, disguised as Barty Crouch, set the champions a three-hour challenge to retrieve what mattered most to them.
  • Pheobe, Krum, and Cedric navigated the maze’s traps and trials, then solved a hot-pot riddle and defeated Mirror Combat Constructs modeled on Hermione, Cho Chang, and Gabrielle.
  • The champions found the three girls safe with the merpeople and joined them for a feast, refusing to let the hidden psychological test turn their rescues into demands for gratitude or suffering.
  • Fleur received 95 points and the Golden Egg trophy, and Douglas told the crowd that true protection meant wanting someone to live well rather than seeking validation for heroic deeds.
  • Krum accepted that he had lost to himself, Karkaroff protested the tournament to Dumbledore, and Hermione encouraged Krum’s new interest in Ancient Runes while Pheobe and Cedric speculated about the next task.
  • Snape recognized the sound reasoning in a Ravenclaw essay on Calming Draughts, then caught Fred and George arguing over a badly brewed potion and ordered them to be quiet.
Chapters 701–725 Vol. 8 Read

Ch. 701Glory and Courage-Call for Volunteers for a Coordinated Black Lake Exercise

After the champions’ earlier schemes failed to reveal the Black Lake’s defenses, Harry proposed a direct, schoolwide volunteer exercise, and the champions agreed to face the challenge openly. Their recruitment effort began with a bold speech but ended with an almost empty signup desk as students feared public failure and humiliation.

  • Hermione judged Operation Phantom of the Theatre a strategic success but admitted the champions had learned nothing about the Black Lake’s defenses, while Fleur, Krum, and Cedric rejected further trickery.
  • Harry proposed calling on the whole school for a frontal assault, and Pheobe, Krum, and Cedric quickly agreed.
  • Sirius approved the champions’ plan as Glorious Operation and promised volunteers priority reservations for hospital wing beds.
  • The champions posted their call and addressed the school, with Cedric announcing that applicants had to pass a spell accuracy and power test.
  • Krum rebuffed Draco Malfoy’s offer to fight, and most students avoided the deserted registration desk, wary of failing publicly after the Canary Choir Incident.
  • Fred and George sold Instant Courage Candy nearby, leaving Cedric, Pheobe, and Krum standing before the empty desk as students watched and laughed.

Ch. 702Neville: When it comes to thinking, I'm no match for Hermione

Neville’s support inspired Hogwarts’s strongest students to join the Champions’ assault on the defensive array, and Hermione’s team devised a coordinated plan. As the squad began its attack at dawn, Sirius activated the Artist Intervention Protocol to meet their challenge.

  • Neville offered his greatsword and led members of the Swiftwind Sword Club to join the Champions’ team.
  • A Ravenclaw counter-curse champion, a Hufflepuff, and other elite students joined, forming a spearhead squad of around twenty.
  • Hermione and Ginny planned a Chain Disintegration Curse around a weakness in the array, assigning Krum, Pheobe, Cedric, Neville, and others specific roles.
  • Sirius activated the Artist Intervention Protocol while the team prepared to attack the defensive array.
  • At dawn, Hermione ordered the squad to begin the operation.

Ch. 703Weasley Artist Intervention Magic Protocol

Hogwarts students launched a coordinated assault on the Defensive Magic Array, but its Weasley Artist Intervention Magic Protocol repeatedly turned their attacks into humiliating pranks. The vanguard ended the chapter demoralized and convinced the array had anticipated their every move.

  • Fred and George monitored the array’s automatic responses from the command tent while Hermione coordinated the attack through the Thunderbolt Assistant.
  • Cedric’s feint team attacked the barrier, but the First-Phase Dance Floor Surprise Protocol made the lakeshore slippery and played clown music as the students fell.
  • Hermione recognized that the feint had not drained the array’s core energy and ordered the main team forward while Pheobe used emotional interference.
  • The array activated the Gardener’s Blessing Protocol, causing enormous singing sunflowers to bloom from the Ravenclaw counter-curse team’s wands and interrupt their spells.
  • For over an hour, the array disrupted the vanguard’s attacks with an escalating series of magical pranks, leaving the students humiliated and demoralized.
  • The Ravenclaw counter-curse champion concluded that the array had predicted their tactics and that the supposed 0.7-second opening was either nonexistent or a trap.

Ch. 704Neville, it's up to you

Hermione ordered Neville to activate Plan B, and the Swiftwind Sword Club used Professor Douglas’s Combined Sword Formation to strike the Magic Defense Formation with concentrated physical force. They created a visible crack in the barrier before it repaired itself, leaving Hogwarts stunned.

  • Hermione ended the magical feint and told Neville to take charge of Plan B.
  • Neville formed the Swiftwind Sword Club into a synchronized diamond formation and used the Combined Sword Formation taught by Professor Douglas.
  • Harry identified the weakest Physical Node in the defense using the resonance detected by the Thunderbolt Assistants.
  • Neville focused the club’s combined strength through his sword and struck the Magic Defense Formation’s weak point.
  • The strike opened a visible crack in the barrier, which repaired itself after three seconds while Hogwarts watched in disbelief.

Ch. 705He was always the one making the biggest splash

The Hogwarts Vanguard Team breached the Black Lake’s defenses using a physical attack, and Douglas declared their victory while crediting the wider lessons of Hogwarts. The stunt drew attention across the wizarding world, as Marauders Power announced a public presentation of its new defense system.

  • Pheobe recognized the Vanguard Team’s breach as the Water-Dividing Charm, and the rift revealed a passage to the merpeople settlement before snapping shut.
  • Douglas arrived at the lakeshore by hang glider, silenced the crowd, and declared the Vanguard Team’s victory.
  • Douglas praised Neville and said Hogwarts taught more than magic, prompting the spectators to erupt in applause.
  • Marauders Power sent Rita Skeeter’s press release to magical media and announced a press conference for the next day at the Griffin’s Nest.
  • At breakfast, students excitedly discussed Neville’s sword strike and predicted the Swiftwind Sword Club would attract many new members.

Ch. 706Run into a Dark Wizard? One slap would settle it!

The Daily Prophet turned Hogwarts’s security drill into publicity for Marauders Power’s defense system, drawing excitement from students and the wider Wizarding World. Later, the Champions and the Think Tank’s Core Members reviewed what they had seen beneath the lake and concluded they would have to prepare without the drill’s artificial passage.

  • Hagrid told Madame Maxime that Neville’s sword technique used a powerful strike against a weak point, surprising her with its forceful approach.
  • Hundreds of owls delivered the Daily Prophet, whose front page praised Marauders Power’s defense system and announced Sirius Black’s press conference for the following day.
  • Students eagerly discussed buying the system, while Fred and George admired how the company had turned their defeat into an advertisement.
  • Arthur Weasley felt pride and unease about the commercial spectacle, and Lucius Malfoy considered the system’s value for protecting Malfoy Manor.
  • Cedric, Pheobe, Krum, Harry, Hermione, and Ron met in the abandoned Transfiguration classroom to share what they had glimpsed beneath the lake.
  • Pheobe and Krum described the passage, merpeople buildings, and guards, and Cedric concluded the real task would lack the Water-Dividing Charm’s passage; Pheobe said they would have to rely on themselves.

Ch. 707Devil Black

Sirius Black presented Marauders Power Company's Family Patronus Series at a press conference, touting its home defenses and partnership with the Ministry of Magic. He left reporters and Auror officials impressed by a product designed to protect families while keeping enforcement authority with the Ministry.

  • Sirius Black addressed reporters and officials about the Hogwarts students who had challenged the company's defense system.
  • Sirius revealed that the students had faced a campus trial version with ninety percent of its functionality disabled.
  • Sirius unveiled the Family Patronus Series, which activated with a drop of blood and automatically shielded a home.
  • Sirius described its defenses against intruders and announced a partnership that would send alerts to nearby Aurors during serious attacks.
  • The attending Auror officials approved of the system because it protected households while leaving judgment and enforcement to the Ministry.

Ch. 708The Ministry of Magic's Endorsement

Sirius presented the Home Patronus System as a way to restore authority to the Ministry of Magic, and Rufus Scrimgeour formally endorsed its rollout on behalf of the Auror Office. The system would connect to the Ministry’s rapid response network, leaving the product established as the officially supported standard for home security.

  • Sirius introduced Rufus Scrimgeour, Head of the Auror Office, as a guest qualified to assess the Home Patronus System.
  • Scrimgeour said ineffective home defense magic and false alarms wasted Auror resources.
  • Scrimgeour explained that the system sent encrypted alerts, precise coordinates, and an intrusion analysis to the Auror command center.
  • Scrimgeour announced that the Ministry of Magic would support the system and connect every unit sold to its Rapid Response Magic System.
  • The audience applauded Scrimgeour’s endorsement more enthusiastically than Sirius’s presentation.

Ch. 709Hugging Him and Running Away-What Was That?

Remus Lupin packed Tonks's luggage as she prepared to return to the Ministry, and her impulsive embrace left him smiling after she ran off. Meanwhile, Hermione's research revealed that the Champions would face poisoned, fiercely territorial Merpeople in a narrow passage, leaving them to prepare for a brutal close-quarters fight.

  • Tonks told Lupin she had to return to the Ministry to report on Marauders Power Company's new products, and Lupin wished her a safe journey.
  • Tonks suddenly embraced Lupin, then blushed and fled the workshop; Lupin touched his cheek and smiled.
  • Cedric warned the Champions and their friends that the passage they had discovered might not appear during the actual competition.
  • Hermione reported that Merpeople weakened out of water but wielded tridents coated with the deadly poison Tears of the Siren.
  • Hermione concluded that the Merpeople would fight to the death to defend the passage, so the Champions would have to face them hand to hand in the narrow terrain.

Ch. 710The Second Task begins

The Black Lake was transformed into a grand arena for the second task as Cedric Diggory, Fleur Delacour, and Viktor Krum prepared for the dangerous underwater rescue. The champions took their places, and the opening ceremony ended with an unexpected series of congratulatory videos appearing on the screen.

  • The Ministry of Magic guarded the expanded competition grounds as representatives, reporters, and the Silvermane Academy delegation gathered above the Black Lake.
  • Cedric Diggory practiced the Bubble-Head Charm while thinking of Cho Chang, and Fleur Delacour used meditation to prepare for the water while worrying about Gabrielle.
  • Igor Karkaroff pushed Viktor Krum to attempt a dangerous partial shark transformation, while Douglas's warning about the rescued girls' unknown potion side effect hung over the task.
  • The three champions emerged from their preparation areas at nine in the morning as Harry, Ron, and Ginny watched from the stands, and Moody stared at Harry.
  • The Weasley Twins welcomed the crowd, but the water vapor screen showed congratulatory videos instead of the competition, beginning with the president of Egypt's Magical Association.

Ch. 711A chessboard from the world

The Weasley Twins introduced international endorsements for Hogwarts and the Marauders Power Company during the Triwizard opening ceremony. Amanit then announced a joint ancient-magic tournament in Egypt next year, leaving Hogwarts students cheering at the prospect of visiting Africa.

  • Fred and George unveiled a magical map of Europe and began the ceremony segment called “A chessboard from the world.”
  • Italian Minister Massimo Alberti praised Dumbledore and described Italy’s cooperation with Marauders Power as a bilateral relationship, angering Rufus Scrimgeour.
  • Alberti credited Douglas Holmes with ideas for resolving historical issues between species, prompting knowing amusement from Dumbledore, Lupin, and Percy Weasley.
  • The French and German representatives praised Hogwarts’ new educational philosophy, while Karkaroff scowled and Maxime recognized Douglas’s lecture as a strategic presentation.
  • Amanit announced that Uagadou and Hogwarts would host the inaugural Horus Cup Ancient Magic and Ruin Exploration Exchange Tournament in Egypt next year.
  • Harry, Ron, Ginny, and the Hogwarts students cheered the chance to visit Africa and take part in the new tournament.

Ch. 712Thanks to the masters for their guidance

The Weasley Twins showed messages from renowned scholars and Newt Scamander, whose advice emphasized wisdom, precision, and understanding over brute force. Their words reinforced the champions’ strategies, and the academic congratulations ended with the hosts thanking the masters.

  • Fred and George introduced a series of messages from Hogwarts’ distinguished academic guests.
  • Bathilda Bagshot urged the champions to combine courage with wisdom, while Wilbert Slinka advised them to seek the logical exceptions in defensive magic.
  • Miranda Goshawk stressed precise spellcasting, and Newt Scamander told the champions to understand magical creatures rather than attack them.
  • Pheobe and Cedric recognized how the masters’ advice supported their strategies, while Krum remained frowning.
  • Madame Maxime nodded approvingly, Karkaroff dismissed the messages, and Sirius winked at Douglas as the videos ended.

Ch. 713The Second Task of the Triwizard Tournament

Percy, disguised as Barty Crouch, announced that the Second Task was the Black Lake Maze, a three-hour underwater challenge designed by the Marauders Power Company. After the starting cannon sounded, Pheobe, Krum, and Cedric entered the lake using different methods, beginning the competition.

  • Percy, disguised as Barty Crouch, announced the rules for the Black Lake Maze and told the Champions to retrieve the treasure most important to them within three hours.
  • Pheobe reacted with disbelief to the time limit, while Krum welcomed the challenge and Cedric steeled himself for the task.
  • The Water Vapor Screen switched to a live view beneath the Black Lake as the three Champions walked onto the platform.
  • After the cannon signaled the start, Pheobe covered herself in a silver protective film and dove into the lake.
  • Krum transformed his head into a shark's and plunged into the water, while Cedric cast a Bubble-Head Charm and entered calmly.

Ch. 714Welcome to the Marauders' Amusement Park

The three Champions entered the lake maze and faced a first section full of prank traps that tested their patience and judgment. As Krum struggled through them, Pheobe and Cedric took more controlled approaches, and Harry realized the section was testing their mindsets rather than their magical strength.

  • Pheobe, Krum, and Cedric adapted to the lake and entered the maze as the Weasley Twins commentated for the spectators.
  • Krum charged through aquatic plants and was caught by tickling kelp until Pheobe calmed it with a spell.
  • Pheobe freed Krum, while Cedric avoided the kelp and proceeded cautiously through the maze.
  • The Champions encountered prank traps, with Krum triggering many, Pheobe gracefully avoiding most, and Cedric keeping his pace and readings steady.
  • Harry watched the Champions and recognized that the maze’s first section tested their patience and exposed their character flaws.

Ch. 715Hot Pot at the Bottom of the Lake

Hermione, Cho Chang, and Gabrielle watched the champions navigate Professor Holmes’s underwater trials while sharing hot pot. Krum struggled after choosing the courage passage, Pheobe solved a shifting maze, and Cedric advanced by following the instructions, leaving Hermione to sum up the Marauders Power Company’s design rules.

  • Hermione identified the dark green kelp as tickling kelp while Pheobe freed Krum from it with a spell.
  • Krum chose the passage marked for courage, Pheobe entered the rune-filled passage, and Cedric followed the instruction-manual route.
  • Krum fought illusions of Fire Crabs and Manticores, while Pheobe analyzed a maze of shifting currents.
  • Cedric used class notes on the passage walls to cross its traps safely and overtook Krum.
  • Hermione concluded that the trials favored psychological torment over physical harm and that contestants should always read the instructions.

Ch. 716The answer is hidden in the hot pot, so go ask about the secrets at the bottom

Cedric, Pheobe, and Krum reached the underwater altar where Hermione, Cho Chang, and Gabrielle were sleeping, then faced a riddle requiring them to make a hot pot base. Cedric deciphered the clue, and Pheobe identified three likely ingredients, leaving the challenge unresolved.

  • The three champions found Hermione, Cho Chang, and Gabrielle bound and asleep on the altar, but a bubble face blocked their way with a riddle and seven potion bottles.
  • Krum attacked the bubble face with a Blasting Curse, which bounced back and knocked him into a rock wall.
  • Cedric realized the riddle called for making a hot pot base and proposed creating a dry space around the altar.
  • Cedric, Pheobe, and Krum cast Bubble Rise together, forming a large air bubble and summoning a copper cauldron.
  • Cedric ruled out four flashy bottles, and Pheobe identified the remaining three as spicy, aromatic, and umami ingredients.

Ch. 717Cooking Hot Pot Base in a Cauldron

The Champions used a hot pot base to awaken Hermione, Cho Chang, and Gabrielle, but the girls rose as hostile Mirror Combat Constructs and attacked them. As the stands learned about the constructs, Cho Chang watched her mirrored counterpart fight and wondered whether Cedric truly saw her as that powerful.

  • Cedric remembered the stirring technique, and Pheobe stirred the cauldron until its aroma awakened Hermione, Cho Chang, and Gabrielle.
  • Hermione attacked Krum with a Severing Charm, Cho Chang fought Cedric hand-to-hand, and Gabrielle trapped Pheobe in distressing illusions.
  • The spectators erupted when they saw the Champions fighting the girls, and Fred and George explained that the attackers were Mirror Combat Constructs made with Mindscape Mirror technology.
  • Cho Chang watched the construct modeled on her and blushed as she wondered whether Cedric thought she was that powerful.

Ch. 718The final choice

Krum, Pheobe, and Cedric defeated the mirror images of the people they loved and discovered that Douglas had created them as a trial, not as cursed captives. The exhausted champions entered the passage revealed beneath the sinking Black Tortoise Basalt Altar, still determined to confront Douglas.

  • Hermione explained that Professor Holmes's illusions tested the champions' willingness to abandon idealized images of their loved ones.
  • After taking a serious wound, Krum stopped holding back and defeated the illusion of Hermione.
  • Pheobe saw the other champions fighting, broke free of her illusions, and stunned the image of Gabrielle.
  • Cedric cast a wide-area Stunning Spell to stop the image of Cho Chang without using a lethal attack, then collapsed.
  • The fallen Mirror Combat Constructs dissolved, revealing that Douglas had created idealized projections for a trial rather than cursing anyone.
  • The champions helped each other up as the Black Tortoise Basalt Altar sank and revealed a dark passage.

Ch. 719Rescue them? Let whoever wants to do it!

Cedric, Pheobe, and Krum emerged from a trial into a Coral Village, where the Merpeople confronted them with the apparent absurdity of risking their lives to rescue people enjoying a hot pot. As the Champions struggled with the revelation, the Weasley Twins explained the hidden challenge to the spectators, who waited to see how the Champions would respond.

  • Cedric, Pheobe, and Krum swam through a passage and found Hermione, Cho Chang, and Gabrielle eating hot pot in a magical bubble at the Coral Village.
  • Muriel and the Merpeople showed the Champions visions of their ordeal and taunted them with the thought that their sacrifices were pointless because the people they meant to save were comfortable.
  • The Weasley Twins announced that the Merpeople had begun a hidden psychological challenge and explained how heroic self-image could distort a rescuer’s motives.
  • The Twins described the test’s central question: whether the Champions could focus on what the others actually needed instead of demanding that they suffer to validate a rescue.
  • The spectators watched the Champions’ pained expressions and waited for their answers.

Ch. 720This... was so Douglas!

Cedric, Pheobe, and Krum realized the Merpeople’s trial had exposed their motives and chose to turn their rescue into a defiant hot-pot feast for the watching audience. After the Champions earned loud applause and prepared to leave, Cedric worried aloud that Douglas might have planned another stage.

  • Cedric felt relieved when he saw Cho Chang safe, while Pheobe dismissed the idea that protecting Gabrielle required anyone’s approval and Krum recognized his need for validation.
  • The Merpeople chieftain led her people away and opened a path to the surface, but the three Champions joined the others for a hot-pot feast inside the bubble.
  • Cedric, Pheobe, and Krum toasted Professor Holmes and joked loudly for the audience, showing that they had seen through the trial and would not follow its script.
  • The crowd watched the feast on the Water Vapor Screen, then erupted in cheers and applause for the Champions.
  • After eating, the six prepared to rise, but Cedric asked whether Douglas had planned more stages, making the others go pale.

Ch. 721Krum finished fastest, Cedric came second, and Pheobe last.

The Champions’ Black Lake results were scored across five categories, leaving Cedric Diggory and Fleur Delacour tied at 90 points while Viktor Krum finished with 75. The committee then announced an additional bonus for Fleur’s understanding of the Heart-Questioning Trial, but the chapter ended before revealing its value.

  • Krum surfaced first with Hermione, followed by Cedric and Pheobe, while the crowd applauded the Champions’ performances.
  • Barty Crouch announced five scoring categories: base score, completion time, tactical style, knowledge application, and Ministry of Magic impression.
  • Krum received 75 points after losing marks for brute-force puzzle attempts and his Ministry impression.
  • Cedric received 90 points, including 18 tactical-style points for sacrificing himself in the Trial of the Heart.
  • Fleur received 90 points, earning perfect scores for tactical style, knowledge application, and Ministry impression despite returning last.
  • Crouch announced that Fleur would receive an additional bonus for her swift and complete realization that true protection meant wishing the other person well, but he did not reveal the number of points.

Ch. 722Dragon-Slaying Champion Syndrome

After Fleur Delacour won the Second Task, Douglas Holmes explained “Dragon-Slaying Champion Syndrome,” using the Champions’ reactions to question whether a hero’s efforts mattered when the person he meant to rescue was safe and happy. He left the audience wondering why the trial had been designed to feel so insulting.

  • Fleur Delacour received 95 points and accepted the Golden Egg trophy from Dumbledore as the Beauxbatons students celebrated.
  • Douglas Holmes stopped the departing audience and introduced the dilemma of a hero who slayed a dragon only to find the princess safe and enjoying afternoon tea.
  • Douglas explained how self-serving bias could make a hero resent the person he rescued for failing to perform helplessness and validate his efforts.
  • Krum recognized that he had felt anger and absurdity when he found Hermione safe at the bottom of the lake, while Pheobe and Cedric recalled similar disappointment.
  • Douglas condemned emotional blackmail and said that truly protecting someone meant wanting them to live well, even if they never knew of the danger.
  • Douglas asked why the organizers had devised a trial full of pranks that could be considered deeply insulting.

Ch. 723Harry: My Maternal Cousin Set Me Up So Many Times

Douglas’s lecture on “dragon-slaying champion syndrome” reframed the Triwizard Tournament as a debate about heroism and prompted Krum to confront his own failures. The next morning, Krum rejected Karkaroff’s demand for a protest, saying he had lost to himself.

  • Douglas told the crowd that a hero needed wisdom and self-understanding as well as power, and the three champions bowed to him.
  • Harry wondered whether his maternal cousin’s past schemes had been lessons meant to train him, while Moody considered the next step of his plan for the Dark Lord.
  • The day after the Second Task, Hogwarts students debated Douglas’s ideas, and Krum read a book on Ancient Runes that Hermione had lent him.
  • Karkaroff stormed into Krum’s cabin and demanded that he protest the alleged conspiracy against Durmstrang.
  • Krum calmly admitted that he had lost to himself, leaving Karkaroff furious as he went to complain to Dumbledore.

Ch. 724Professor Holmes was well suited to Slytherin

Hermione’s words helped Krum reconsider his pursuit of strength, while Dumbledore and Madame Maxime defended the tournament’s lessons against Karkaroff’s anger. As the students adjusted to these changes, Pheobe and Cedric began preparing for the third task, which they suspected would be a complex maze.

  • Krum returned Hermione’s Ancient Runes book and explained that strength gained its value from the rules and intentions behind its use; Hermione praised him for becoming a thinker.
  • Karkaroff confronted Dumbledore over the tournament, but Dumbledore and Madame Maxime defended its educational value, and Karkaroff left in anger.
  • Pansy told Draco that Hermione had demonstrated true power by making Krum reflect, and Draco felt isolated by the other Slytherins.
  • A Durmstrang owl sent Hermione a question about an Ancient Runes paradox, and Ron and Harry accepted Krum’s new interest in studying with her.
  • Pheobe and Cedric studied a map of Hogwarts and discussed the possibility that the third task would be a maze involving psychological challenges and magical traps.

Ch. 725Snape: Both of you, shut up

Snape resented Holmes’s influence at Hogwarts, but a Ravenclaw essay applying Holmes’s theory to the Calming Draught convinced him that the theory was correct. He took out his frustration on Fred and George during class, ending by ordering them both to be quiet.

  • Snape read a Ravenclaw essay arguing that Dragon-Slaying Champion Syndrome caused magical exhaustion and that the Calming Draught should guide rather than directly treat affected wizards.
  • Snape recognized that the essay’s reasoning was sound and that Holmes’s theories had uncovered a new use for the potion.
  • Snape abruptly stood and called out Weasley, then criticized Fred’s badly brewed Calming Draught.
  • Fred blamed George for the mistake, and George insisted Fred needed to study Potions; Snape ordered both of them to shut up.
Arc 29 of 48