Ch. 1061What We Should Oppose
Harry and the students struggled to define what they opposed about Umbridge’s demanding academic rules, since the schedule was exhausting but had also improved some students’ performance. Umbridge believed her rules had contained their discontent and was planning to use her results to advance her Ministry ambitions when someone entered her office.
- Harry joined Hermione, Ron, Ginny, Neville, and other students as they debated what to write beneath the heading “Oppose,” but could not settle on a clear grievance.
- Hermione argued that Umbridge had tied useful improvements to painful demands, while Ron said he wanted room to breathe and Ginny said a slogan needed to persuade people at a glance.
- Dean told the group that students were fed up but unsure whether to blame Umbridge, the system, the teachers, or their own desire to get ahead.
- Harry took Ron’s quill but still had not written anything when the clock struck nine.
- Umbridge reviewed club applications and decided that the rules gave students an outlet while letting her blame any missed activities on their lack of time.
- Umbridge considered using the Review Committee’s growing momentum to impress Fudge and expand her influence, but a sudden visitor pushed open her office door.