Ch. 41A Miscarriage of Justice
Aya, Harry, Ron, and Hermione investigated the Chamber of Secrets and found an old report blaming Hagrid for a Muggle-born student's death. When they confronted Hagrid, he denied killing the student and revealed that she had died after seeing a big yellow eye, leaving the group with a possible clue about the Chamber's monster.
- Aya, Harry, Ron, and Hermione learned that Slytherin's Chamber of Secrets supposedly held a monster meant to purge those he considered unworthy of magic.
- Hermione found an old Daily Prophet report stating that a Ravenclaw student had died and Hagrid had been expelled after being blamed for keeping a deadly Acromantula.
- Hermione recognized the victim as Moaning Myrtle, and Harry, Ron, and Aya decided to ask Hagrid about the accusation.
- Harry, Ron, Hermione, and Aya went to Hagrid's hut, where Hagrid admitted he had kept a giant spider named Aragog but insisted Aragog had not killed anyone.
- Hagrid revealed that Moaning Myrtle had said she saw a big yellow eye before she died, and Aya connected the clue to the Basilisk she had encountered.