Clearly, the news that Duncan suddenly broke had a shock to the popes' values—they were stunned for a long time and still couldn't quite recover.
After concealing information related to the Alice Manor, Duncan briefly recounted his interactions with the Black Sun and the Abyssal Lord to Rune and the others.
He wasn't worried that this intelligence would "contaminate" those who remained at the scene. On the one hand, his followers had all been baptized by his "spiritual fire," which proved to give them extremely high resistance to spiritual pollution. On the other hand, the popes present usually dealt with spiritual pollution almost every day, and their resistance was quite high. They wouldn't go crazy just because they heard a few words of ancient gods muttering—he certainly wouldn't have mentioned these things if the bishops' council had still been there.
Helena and the others exchanged glances, and after a moment of thought and hesitation, all three gazes fell on Rune.
The short, stout Elf old man looked a little embarrassed. "... Why are you all looking at me?"
"You are the most knowledgeable among us," Helena said sincerely.
Banster nodded in agreement. "You often have unique insights and a prophetic keenness in the difficult field of occultism."
Frem didn't say anything, he just kept staring at Rune without blinking.
Rune remained silent for a few seconds with a subtle expression. After a moment of thought, he seemed to suddenly realize something and turned to look at Duncan, who was watching the scene unfold. "Are you sure you heard the clear and rational voices of the Abyssal Lord and the Black Sun?"
"Of course I'm sure," Duncan said, spreading his hands, "Just as rationally as we're talking right now."
"Then the second question," Rune pondered for a moment, his expression becoming exceptionally serious, "... Since returning to the Real World from the Subspace, have you encountered any 'chaotic creations' that you find completely incomprehensible, impossible to communicate with, and utterly indescribable?"
Duncan paused for a moment upon hearing this, then vaguely understood what the old pope meant. After a moment of contemplation, he spoke, "... I have encountered many 'chaotic, disorderly, and uncommunicative freaks' by worldly standards, but almost every time... I have heard useful information in their noisy roars... Sometimes, I even feel that they are intentionally talking to me."
He stopped, but there was still half a sentence left unsaid—he had always thought this was normal!
Rune's expression changed noticeably upon hearing Duncan's reply; his brow furrowed instantly, and Helena, standing beside him, realized what he meant as, "Wait, so..."
"...In the eyes of the 'Captain,' there are no ancient gods who are insane and out of control," Rune said slowly, looking into Duncan's eyes with a serious expression. "You can understand those voices that have completely deviated from the 'basic rationality' in any situation. Even those beings that would drive mortals crazy at a glance are probably understandable and communicable to you."
The hall fell silent for a moment. Apart from Alice, who wasn't thinking straight, and Shirley, who wasn't thinking at all, everyone instantly began to subconsciously think about what this meant and the "reason" behind this incredible "phenomenon".
As he pondered, Morris broke the silence in a low voice. "If we follow your 'cognitive deviation' hypothesis, then it means the captain..."
"No matter how far things deviate, they are still within his cognitive range," Rune nodded slowly. "It's a bit like... wait, wait, I need paper and pen!"
Morris immediately realized. "It's here."
A piece of paper was quickly laid out on the table. Rune picked up a pencil, bent down under the curious gazes of everyone, and began to sketch patterns on the paper at lightning speed. However, to Duncan's surprise, it was neither a complex and mysterious mystical rune nor a difficult mathematical formula. Rune drew was just one seemingly loose and random circle after another.
He drew many circular patterns—they were randomly distributed on the paper, some overlapping each other, some with only slightly overlapping edges, and some completely independent.
"Remember the Great Annihilation? And the speculation about how the New World formed after the Great Annihilation..." Rune said quickly as he drew, "Many worlds collided together, and their debris piled up to form the foundation of the New World. I call these piled-up debris 'Primal Ashes,' and these ashes initially carried the 'rules' of their respective worlds. We consider ashes that share the same set of rules as such a circle..."
"Yes, the concept of a set. The 'Primal Ashes' left over from each world are a subset. Do you see these intersecting rings? Those intersections are the 'compatible' parts of the Primal Ashes..."
"During the Third Long Night, the compatible Primal Ashes were reorganized, forming the Deep Sea Era we inhabit now... The 'intersection' of the collection, yes, it's right here..."
Rune stopped and pointed to the center of the white paper with his pencil.
Several large and small rings converge there, and the area where the rings meet is only the size of a fingernail.
"This is our Deep Sea Era... Primal Ashes from the remnants of various worlds, capable of being 'compatible' with each other and barely 'established' under the same set of rules, together constructed this Boundless Sea and the many city-states on the Boundless Sea..."
"And beyond this 'intersection,' in the other non-intersecting parts of these rings, that is, their 'difference,' lie those things that we can access but cannot understand or control—they linger on the edge of our Real World, perhaps manifesting as anomalies, perhaps as abnormalities, or perhaps as other bizarre phenomena or Corruption Vessel..."
Rune thought for a moment, then pointed to the rings that were outside of all the other rings and did not come into contact with any other patterns.
"This is the location of the proto-desecration, the location of the Black Sun and other lost ancient gods, the exiled races. We can no longer understand their existence, and they are completely incompatible with the Real World. Some of them have completely disappeared into the darkness, while others... still wander in... some kind of spacetime that we cannot understand, in the form of Primal Ashes."
Looking at the simple yet clear diagram the teacher had drawn on the paper, Morris quickly understood. "We are within the 'intersection,' so we can only 'understand' information within the intersection. What's outside the intersection is indescribable noise and shadows to us..."
Rune nodded. "Yes, that's the 'fact' that this model demonstrates."
Morris continued, "But for the captain, both the 'strange shadows' outside the intersection and the lost ancient gods completely outside the collective system are understandable—in his eyes, there is no world 'outside the intersection'..."
"As you said..."
Duncan stood aside, listening silently to the discussion.
They were discussing him, trying to explain him with a set of logic, attempting to understand him, trying to comprehend him, trying to access his "true mystery".
But he didn't care.
He listened silently, seemingly lost in thought.
He gazed at the patterns Rune had drawn, at the intersecting, overlapping, and independent rings, at the "Primal Ashes" drifting and scattered across the ruins, and at the piece of paper.
For some reason, he recalled his recent experience in the Subspace, and the overflowing starlight he had seen in the eyes of the Pale Giant ...
Vana also came to the paper. Looking at the picture on it, she couldn't help but whisper, "Where is the captain...?"
Rune's expression was serious. "There is only one case in which a 'general set' can contain all the subsets that have appeared here, as well as all the subsets that have not yet appeared."
Vana thought for a moment, then gestured on the paper. "A larger ring that includes them all?"
"No."
Morris shook his head.
Then, the old scholar stepped forward and gently placed his hand on the paper.
"It's this piece of paper."
As soon as he finished speaking, he looked up and looked around.
Endless starlight filled his vision, his memory, and his understanding.
It filled the eyes of everyone in the hall.
Helena stared wide-eyed in the starlight. Amidst the monstrous waves of truth, she felt her mind teetering. She saw a undulating shadow, an outline, rising in the starlight, approaching her with a thunderous roar—
Isn't that incredible?
Rune stood frozen in the starlight, noise and tremors squeezing from his reason. "Truth... the ultimate beauty..."
Then, all the starlight vanished abruptly—the vast, undulating shadow shrank and collapsed into the Real World of the hall in an instant imperceptible to humans.
Vana barely managed to break free from the terrifying afterimages created by the starlight. In a state of intense dizziness, she saw the captain walk to the table and slowly roll up the paper.
"I have a suggestion for you," Duncan turned his head and looked into Rune's eyes, "Next time you discuss me, take more precautions."
The terrifying afterimage left by the starlight finally faded completely—the paper had been completely rolled up by Duncan and casually stuffed into his clothes.
As the "truth" was temporarily obscured, reason suddenly returned to everyone's mind.
Banster took a deep breath, instinctively took a step back, and then glared at Rune: "I should have kept my distance from 'scholars' like you from the very beginning!"
"You guys were the ones who made me do the analysis!" Rune gasped for breath, glancing at Duncan with lingering fear before turning to the three of Banster, "Tell me, was it effective or not!"
"Captain..." Morris turned to Duncan, a slightly embarrassed expression on his face, "I'm sorry..."
"It's alright, curiosity is human nature," Duncan laughed, his smile as gentle and tolerant as ever. "Fortunately, none of us are gone."