Ch. 681Please Keep This Secret with Me, Professor
Key plot points and events
- After suffering backlash from attempting Legilimency on memories connected to the Department of Mysteries, Andrew is mentally disoriented when Professor McGonagall notices the manuscript he is holding.
- McGonagall asks to read it. Andrew hands it over automatically, then panics as she recognizes that it is a handwritten version of A Legend, the popular magazine story about Dumbledore.
- To avoid being exposed, Andrew quickly claims that updates have slowed because the publisher has sent him uninteresting material and he is busy preparing for exams. He turns the encounter into an interview, asking McGonagall to share stories about Dumbledore as a teacher.
- McGonagall reminisces about Dumbledore’s talent and preparation as a Defense Against the Dark Arts professor, while also describing his later eccentricity and reluctance to involve himself in the wider wizarding world.
- She realizes Andrew has been publishing A Legend since his first year. He explains that it began as a paid biography of Gryffindor, but the editorial office changed its subject to Dumbledore. The earnings helped cover his school expenses.
- Andrew reassures McGonagall that he will disguise interviewees’ identities and promises not to portray Dumbledore negatively.
Character developments and interactions
- Andrew shifts from terrified and mentally muddled to quick-thinking and opportunistic, using McGonagall’s surprise to redirect the conversation and enlist her cooperation.
- McGonagall moves from curiosity to shock, then relaxes into fond but candid reminiscences about Dumbledore before realizing the implications of what she has revealed.
- Their familiar, trusting office routine works in Andrew’s favor: McGonagall speaks freely, while Andrew records her comments as though conducting a formal interview.
Significant themes
- Secrecy and disclosure: Andrew’s manuscript risks exposing a private truth, while he tries to manage what McGonagall learns.
- Public image versus reality: A Legend’s polished portrayal of Dumbledore contrasts with McGonagall’s more complicated memories.
- Improvisation and self-preservation: Andrew turns an apparent disaster into an opportunity by changing the subject and controlling the conversation.
- Money and practicality: The celebrated story began as a way for a young student to afford books and other expenses.