Are wizards and Muggle considered the same type of people?
This is a very sensitive issue in the Wizarding World.
It's not that the problem doesn't exist, but rather that it has always existed, yet all wizards subconsciously ignore it. No one brings it up openly, and no one dares to address it directly. As a result, this obvious and thought-provoking problem has never appeared in the Wizarding World.
Here, it was just an ordinary fourth-grade class. Even if wizards outside heard that Fawkes was having students discuss such a question in class, they wouldn't react much.
It wasn't like they were directly publishing their views in the Daily Prophet; it was just a casual discussion in class.
After stating his argument, Fawkes continued.
"To boost your enthusiasm, although there are no exams for the Moral Education class, as a professor I still have the authority to award extra points. Every student who participates in the debate will receive 5 points for their college, and if your argument is accepted by most students, you can receive an additional 10 points for your college."
His words undoubtedly excited the already excited young wizards even more. In class, almost everyone raised their arms, wanting to be the first to speak their minds.
Fawkes first randomly called on one of the young wizards from Hufflepuff.
"Mundo Blido, first state your opinion, then explain why you think this way. You have three minutes."
The young wizard named Mondo was a burly boy. After standing up, he spoke without hesitation.
"I don't think wizards and Muggle are the same kind of people. It's actually very simple to prove this: wizards can use magic, but Muggle can't. One side can do it, but the other side can't. How can they be considered the same kind of people?"
His explanation was very simple and took less than three minutes. Although it was concise, this concise idea is what most wizards in the Wizarding World are thinking.
Those who possess magic and can use magic are wizards; those who lack magic and cannot use magic are Muggle; and those who possess magic but cannot use magic are Squib —these are people disliked by both sides.
Wizards are wizards, Muggle are Muggle. How can the two groups be considered the same kind of people?
After Mundo finished speaking, he sat down. As Fawkes had said at the beginning, no matter what his answer was, as long as he answered, he would add 5 points to Hufflepuff.
"This is the opposing argument. Okay, those who agree with what Mundo said don't need to raise their hands anymore. We need a positive argument now, so are there any students who disagree with him and want to refute him?"
This time, half the number of people raised their hands in the classroom, which is enough to show that quite a few people actually agree with what was just said.
Those who agree with this view may not necessarily discriminate against Muggle like Malfoy, and they can treat Muggle-born classmates with normalcy. However, according to their view, once you enter Hogwarts, you are separated from Muggle and become two different kinds of people.
Even some students from Muggle family think so themselves.
However, this idea is not universal. Among those who raised their hands, at least Harry, Hermione, and Ron were also opponents of this view.
Fawkes would naturally choose the Gryffindor student to answer the question this time, and as a result, he chose Hermione.
"Hermione Granger, you also have three minutes to present your argument."
Hermione stood up and first corrected Mundo's concept.
"Bredo's explanation of the terms 'Muggle' was wrong!"
"What is Muggle? The Ministry of Magic has an official explanation of this term, and Professor McGonagall has also explained it to Muggle-born students. The term Muggle refers to people who do not know magic and do not believe in its existence!"
"It's not just a general term for people who don't know magic. My parents don't know magic, but because of me, they believe in the existence of magic, so they can't be called Muggle. It's just that before I showed my magical talent, my family didn't know the reality of magic, and we had never been in contact with the magical world before that, so we were called Muggle family after entering Hogwarts."
"Therefore, it is clear that the terms wizard and Muggle are not a combined term for a single group. Wizards are people who believe in and can use magic, while Muggle can be understood as people who believe in and use science. Although they live in different ways and have different knowledge and beliefs, they are all human beings first and foremost."
"Apart from magic, wizards and Muggle share a common way of thinking, their social structures are basically the same, and even their concepts of territory and country are the same."
"Wizards and Muggle can fall in love and form families. The current trend in the Wizarding World is that fewer and fewer families are formed between wizards. More and more young wizards have at least one Muggle as a parent. Apart from magic being just a tool used to make life and work easier, what are the differences between wizards and Muggle?"
"Therefore, wizards and Muggle are truly the same kind of people because their thoughts are unified, and their concepts of family and country are also unified. The only difference is whether or not they can use magic as a tool."
"Normally, people wouldn't use the difference in tools they use to distinguish between different people. Like two farmers, one is used to using a hoe, and the other is more used to using a shovel. Can you say that these two people are not the same kind of people?"
Hermione's speech used up the three minutes Fawkes had allotted. Her words were sharper and her arguments more concrete, so when she finished speaking and sat back down, many of the young wizards in the classroom who agreed with her applauded.
Even Fawkes clapped lightly and also gave Hermione 5 points.
But Hermione wasn't exactly a master of persuasion; she wasn't at the level to convince everyone with just a few words. There were still quite a few young wizards who didn't agree with her views, so the debate continued in class.
Harry and his friends' first Moral Education class ended at the end of the afternoon.
Finally, Fawkes wrote the names of every student who had spoken in the class on the blackboard, and the students voted on their own. Hermione received the most votes in the end.
Fawkes also added ten points to Gryffindor, just as he had said at the beginning of the class.