Qi Si remembered that he once had a true friend.
That was eleven years ago. There was a silly little kid who happened to be his deskmate. He happened to be friendless like him, so he naturally approached him, sharing snacks, chatting and joking around with him.
At that time, Qi Si was only eleven years old. Although he was no longer a normal person, at least he had never done anything illegal or criminal.
He was used to An'an quietly in a corner, flipping through some bloody and dark forbidden books, imagining the tragic fate of the characters in the books, until his pale face regained color and his breathing became rapid.
His "friends" couldn't understand his hobby, yet they still sat beside him, struggling and watching with difficulty, trying to comprehend his excitement and joy.
"Qi Si, why do you always look at these things?" a "friend" asked Qi Si once.
"I'm choosing how I die," Qi Si said.
He held a book explaining the relationship between love and appetite, without looking up. "I've always been curious about how I'll die and where I'll go after I die."
The friend gasped, "You're only eleven years old, why are you thinking about these things?"
"Because I'm bored," Qi Si said. "The world is like it's been programmed; everyone and everything has a fixed pattern of behavior, and joy, anger, sorrow, and happiness can be precisely measured, but I have nothing."
"Then how do you know the afterlife won't be boring?"
"I don't know, but it's like a blind box; there's at least a chance it'll be interesting."
The "friend" stood there dumbfounded for a while, then suddenly started telling some nonsensical jokes.
Qi Si knew that his "friend" wanted to cheer him up, and according to conventional wisdom, he should be sensible and support him.
So he closed the book, listened quietly to the boring jokes, gave an exaggerated fake smile, and then told even more boring jokes in response.
At that time, he never told his "friends" that he had the thought of killing more than once.
In the hazy memories of his childhood, a voice at the bottom of his mind always tempted him, saying that missing emotions could be revived through the thrill of killing, that pale memories could be colored with the blood of the dead, and that a mad beast should dwell in the desolate depths of his heart...
But he told the voice that his "friend," such a law-abiding person, would talk about him for a long time if he knew he had become a murderer.
If nothing unexpected happens, Qi Si will probably try to pretend to be a normal person and gradually get used to this false mediocrity, letting the hidden desires in his heart fade away with the passage of time.
Unfortunately, his good fortune didn't last long. One day, some bored children discovered his strangeness and naturally started playing a monster-fighting game with him.
"Qi Si is evil, we must defeat him," the children said.
After they threatened, "Whoever plays with Qi Si again, we'll beat them up," his only "friend" got scared and would hide far away from him every time he saw him, as if avoiding a plague or a wild beast.
Even at the children's urging, his "friends" started spitting on him and throwing mud at him.
When his "friend" deliberately tore up his books again, a touch of human emotion finally wove into his empty emotional palace.
Sadness, pain, or anger—in short, it was an extremely negative feeling that undeniably formed his initial understanding of emotions.
To avoid being looked at with hatred by his "friends," he had no choice but to close those eyes that belonged to his "friends" forever.
From a young age, he was a very capable child, and killing someone his own age was not difficult for him, but the trouble that followed made him feel nauseous.
His parents were still alive at the time, so he couldn't take the body back with him; but leaving it outside risked it rotting and being discovered by the Public Security Bureau.
He had no choice but to eat his silly "friend" piece by piece, until he was completely full.
It tasted terrible; he never wanted to eat it again.
Thoughts touched upon the gray areas of memory, stirring up waves of dust and haze.
Qi Si pursed his lips, taking in the expressions of everyone, and basically confirmed his previous guess.
The details he described perfectly matched the manner of the victim's death, yet no one identified him. There was only one possibility—the players saw different corpses.
Qi Si looked at Charlie and politely asked, "May we take a short break to discuss the details about the body?"
"Of course!" Charlie's cheerful laughter muffled beneath the mask. "It seems Mr. Number One has already discovered the foreshadowing I left! Excellent, very dramatic!"
Upon hearing this, the players forgot all about Qi Si's bloody narration.
The hint couldn't be clearer.
Dong Xiwen murmured, "The corpse I saw was a young boy with multiple fractures and his face covered in brain matter."
"No, that's not what I saw," Heyi said, her face pale. "I saw a fat man..."
Qi Si laughed, resting his chin on his hand and tapping his jaw casually. "Do you guys remember the premise? 'We are all guilty,' but there might not be just one murderer."
"I understand now. We're all murderers; we all saw the first person each of us killed." Hansen grinned maliciously. "You guys were really good at pretending. If Zhou Ke hadn't pointed it out, were you planning to vote me out as the murderer and send me to my death?"
The answer is clear, neither confirmed nor denied, and needs no further discussion.
Charlie said that the truth doesn't matter, as long as someone is voted out, even if voting wrong has indirect consequences, it's better than being voted out and executed.
"We can all abstain, it's not like we have to vote," Dong Xiwen muttered to himself.
Charlie, hearing this, chuckled and added, "If you all get the same number of votes, then everyone will be executed! I've devised an artistic way to die for each of you; you're all guilty, and each of you deserves a try!"
Dong Xiwen's eyes widened. "But we're all murderers! How can we vote? Each of us vote for ourselves, and then we all commit suicide to atone for our sins?"
No one responded.
If everyone is the murderer, and voting for any one of them is acceptable, then the most economical choice is to select a scapegoat and have everyone vote that person out.
Cynthia pondered for a moment, then smiled and said, "Since we're both murderers, there's no need to worry about the truth. I think we'll know who to choose after Charlie asks his third question."
Everyone looked at Charlie.
Under the watchful eyes of everyone, the Puppet- like NPC trembled dramatically and burst into a maniacal laugh, "Third question, what are your professions and contributions? Perhaps those who are valuable can atone for their mistakes and avoid death—who knows!"
Assessing the value of life and using that value to determine life and death—this is yet another example of utilitarianism that divides people into different classes.
For no apparent reason, Qi Si thought of the two possible endings of "Double Happiness Town" --
"Sacrifices" and "Sever Calamity".
What is the attitude of the Eerie Game towards this kind of moral blackmail that sacrifices one person to benefit the majority?
Should we welcome it, or remain indifferent and watch from the sidelines?
Cynthia clasped her hands together and solemnly declared, "I am the governor of the Federal Silesia District. If you regularly follow social issues, you should know that I have advocated for improvements to the federal healthcare system and for protecting the rights of vulnerable groups. I also participated in rescue efforts during the mysterious global wildfires six years ago."
"If I survive this instance, I will continue to strive for the well-being of all humanity and continue doing what I have always done—fighting for women's rights so that all girls can grow up safely, happily, equally, and securely."
Qi Si understood that Cynthia's words were aimed at Heyi, and were similar in nature to the goodwill he had shown to Dong Xiwen before.
A vote involving life and death is bound to be impossible to satisfy everyone; it is enough to win the support of only a portion of the population.
"I don't believe a single word you politicians say! Who in that position doesn't have a few dirty deeds on their hands?" Hansen interrupted Cynthia with a sneer. "I'm a loan shark, just like you guessed. I've killed and set fires in my life; I haven't done many good deeds."
"I doubt you'd believe me if I said I wouldn't lend money again. But I can promise you, once I leave this instance, I'll destroy all the IOUs I have and let those deadbeats go. You probably know which is easier to fulfill: my promise or that old woman's empty check."
After Hansen finished speaking, he crossed his arms and leaned back in his chair, looking at him with an expression that said, "You guys figure it out yourselves."
After these two people spoke, the order of the answers became disordered.
Dong Xiwen was the third to speak, "I hope to live, because I still have things I want to do. But if I have to die here, then so be it; someone has to sacrifice. I just feel that no Sin should sit at this table and be judged in such an absurd way."
"I don't know how to answer Charlie's question. I don't have a job yet, and I haven't made any contributions. But I will try my best to be a kind and honest person, and if one day I can change the old order, I can guarantee that within my power, there will be no more oppressors."
"This might sound too idealistic, a bit pretentious, but I still hope you can believe me. Maybe if everyone were a little more idealistic, the world would be changed..."
His words came to an abrupt halt as Qi Si suddenly looked at Heyi and said weakly, "I remember that Dong Xiwen wasn't the only one among us who wasn't working."
Heyi nodded slightly. "Yes, I'm still in high school. But I can promise I'll never do anything bad again. I committed the Sin out of desperation; I wouldn't have chosen to kill if I hadn't been unable to bear it..."
Her voice grew softer and softer, until it became increasingly inaudible.
Qi Si interrupted Dong Xiwen mainly because he was afraid that the guy would continue to copy the Nine Provinces Guild's promotional material and launch into a long-winded speech.
At that moment, a question suddenly occurred to him. He smiled and looked around at everyone, "In your opinion, how should a person's value be defined? Sin and value cannot be quantified into specific numbers, nor can they be simply added or subtracted. How should we judge whether a person deserves to die?"
Seeing the players lost in thought, he continued unhurriedly, "To talk about contributions to the world is even more abstract. Besides humans, this world also contains lower animals, plants, microorganisms, and inanimate objects. From the perspective of nature as a whole, the growth and prosperity of the human population could be a devastating catastrophe for other creatures..."
"Are you an animal rights activist or an environmentalist?" Cynthia asked calmly.
"No, I'm just curious, from what perspective should we judge this so-called 'contribution'?" Qi Si glanced at Charlie sideways, his expression calm. "From the perspective of NPCs and other supernatural beings, humanity's greatest contribution might be self-destruction; from the perspective of ordinary people, the greatest contribution others can make is solving their basic needs like food, clothing, and shelter; from the perspective of far-sighted politicians, developing technology and exploring the future are the most meaningful things..."
"What exactly are you trying to say?" Hansen said impatiently. "We're all human beings. Do you expect me to think about things from a weird perspective?"
Qi Si looked at him, narrowed his eyes and smiled, "I just think it's meaningless to consider contributions outside of this instance. Who can control what you all do after you return to reality? Hansen, if you die in this instance, it will probably take a lot of effort to get back the loans you've made, won't it?"
Hansen scoffed, "Even if I die, as long as those IOUs remain, someone will always collect the debts."
Qi Si ignored him and continued, "I am a taxidermist. My contribution is to rationally analyze the situation and not do anything that harms the collective interest out of stupidity or cowardice."
"I will vote for Hansen. He is the only one among us who excels in violence, and judging from the first two questions, his intelligence doesn't seem very high. There's a possibility that he might use force to coerce us into doing stupid things with him. I think it's necessary to eliminate this unstable factor beforehand."
At this point, Qi Si inexplicably thought of Chang Xu, and the answer of "blowing up the tram."
All ideologies are nothing more than false propositions that will be crushed by absolute power.
To make the debate on ideologies take the lead in the situation, it's not difficult; all you need to do is use the Rules to eliminate those with absolute power.
Qi Si tapped the table with his index finger and said jokingly, "Only by throwing those muscle-bound idiots out the door can we 'civilized' people sit down and talk An'an peace, right?"
[Note] The Decameron is a collection of short stories by the Italian writer Giovanni Boccaccio. It tells the story of ten men and women who take refuge in a villa in the countryside during the plague in Florence, Italy. Each of them tells a story every day, and after ten days, they have told one hundred stories. The work embodies humanist thought and focuses on and promotes human value.