Malfoy did not use the Imperius Curse on Rosmerta, a result that was not too surprising to Silvan.
Harry, however, seemed unwilling to believe it, insisting that Malfoy was lying and that he was only saying this to clear himself of suspicion.
Rather than whether Malfoy was lying, Silvan was curious about his plan and why Snape told Malfoy that Crabbe and Goyle were not trustworthy.
Everyone at Hogwarts knows that Crabbe and Goyle are Malfoy's most loyal followers, always together wherever they go, their bond even stronger than that of the Gryffindor trio.
After all, Ron and Hermione would argue often, but Crabbe and Goyle wouldn't; their limited intelligence made it difficult for them to come up with different opinions on a particular matter.
But now, Snape tells Malfoy that Crabbe and Goyle are not trustworthy.
If we exclude deliberate lying and sowing discord, then there is only one possibility: Snape obtained some information from Voldemort that Malfoy was unaware of.
Silvan was a little curious.
Unfortunately, Snape didn't say it just now, and he couldn't possibly tell me anyway.
The two rushed back to the Gryffindor Tower before curfew. By then, there weren't many people in the common room, except for a few fifth-year students with slumped shoulders, still struggling with what seemed like an endless amount of homework.
"How lucky we are to be in sixth grade now," Harry said, seemingly lost in thought.
Fifth year was truly a nightmare for all Hogwarts students—endless homework, endless classes. He was so glad he'd made it through.
Hermione and Ron were also there; they must have been waiting for them.
"Harry, Silvan, where did you go?" Ron asked immediately.
"The Slytherin Common Room," Harry said. "You remember, on our way back from practice, we saw Snape going to see Malfoy."
"Of course I remember." Ron nodded. "But weren't they in the common room? How did you get in?"
"It wasn't me, it was Silvan. He used a very clever Transfiguration and heard it—" Harry told Ron what had just happened.
At this moment, Hermione looked up in confusion, scrutinizing Silvan from head to toe.
Could Transfiguration alone fool Snape and all of Slytherin?
Although Silvan's Transfiguration skills have consistently been the best among everyone, this is still a bit too exaggerated, unless----
Hermione frowned, then suddenly began shaking her head. This unexpected and strange behavior startled Ron, who wondered if she had eaten Acid Pops that had fallen on the ground.
They talked for a while longer, and soon it was 10:50.
With ten minutes to go before the agreed-upon class time, Silvan and Harry left the common room again and headed to the Headmaster's Office on the same floor.
The new password was "Toffee Fingers," and the Gargoyle immediately stood up and jumped to the side upon hearing it.
Dumbledore was already waiting for them there. Just like last time (the previous two times), the Pensieve was there, along with two small crystal flasks containing swirling memories.
Dumbledore first asked Harry about his homework, but Harry had clearly done nothing and stammered that Dumbledore had tried his best.
"You feel you've done your utmost, haven't you?" Dumbledore stared at Harry through his Half-moon Spectacles. "You've used all your intelligence and come up with every possible idea?"
Harry was speechless, unsure of what to say.
This disappointed Dumbledore.
"I thought you knew very well how important this was—I tried everything to make you realize that it's the most crucial memory, without which we'll just be wasting time."
Although Harry kept his head down and didn't say a word, Silvan could tell that his face must be frighteningly red.
So Silvan stepped aside—he knew nothing about it, and it had nothing to do with him.
Fortunately, their conversation was quickly interrupted by Armando Dippet's loud snoring.
"I'm so sorry, Professor Dumbledore," Harry finally mustered his courage and looked up. "I should have done more. I should have realized that you wouldn't have asked me to do it if it weren't truly important."
"Thank you for saying that," Dumbledore said calmly. "Then may I ask that you bring this matter up a little earlier? Without that memory, our lessons would be meaningless."
"I will, Professor, I'll find a way to get it," Harry said eagerly.
"Harry, sometimes it's a wise choice to enlist the help of your friends." Dumbledore looked at Silvan.
Silvan instinctively took a step back. "I'm not familiar with Professor Slughorn."
"It seems you already know," Dumbledore said kindly. "Actually, this was supposed to be a joint assignment for both of you, but due to some special circumstances, you missed a class. But that's alright, we can make it up today."
Silvan really wanted to refuse.
To be honest, he had no desire to see any memories related to Voldemort, nor did he want to learn about the Dark Lord's upbringing.
Silvan glanced at the dark night sky outside the window.
Dumbledore seemed to immediately realize what he was thinking.
"It is indeed a bit too late today." He glanced out the window as well. "But there's nothing we can do. Rosmerta's matter is a bit tricky, but we don't want to disappoint Slughorn. He desperately wants to know who wants to kill him."
"Then let's tell him." Silvan shrugged.
"But we haven't found the culprit yet," Dumbledore said softly. "The other party is cautious, Alastor needs more time to investigate."
I'm talking about the result, not the truth.
"Oh?" Dumbledore looked at Silvan thoughtfully. "And what do you think the outcome will be?"
"It's definitely Voldemort," Silvan immediately said. "He's afraid Slughorn will reveal the secret, so he wants to kill him to silence him—that makes perfect sense, doesn't it?"
After a pause, Dumbledore said softly, "It does sound reasonable. But will Horace believe it?"
"I don't know," Silvan said. "After all, I only made a suggestion."
"Then let's not talk about that now." Dumbledore looked at Harry, who looked completely bewildered.
"Continuing from where we left off in the story last time, do you remember?"
"I remember, sir," Harry said, snapping out of his reverie. "Voldemort came to Little Hangleton, killed the entire Riddle family, making it seem like his uncle did it, and then he returned to Hogwarts to—to Professor Slughorn —inquire about Horcrux."
Harry remembered the homework Dumbledore had given him, and his voice grew softer and softer.
But Dumbledore seemed genuinely unconcerned.
"Then let's continue." He picked up one of the crystal bottles and poured the memories inside into the Pensieve.
"About Voldemort after he turned seventeen."