Ch. 261Passing the Blame to Percy
Key plot points
- Hermione refuses to give Ginny the cabin key, determined to keep her from seeing Little Red eat an earthworm. She pulls the tearful Ginny along, and Percy intervenes, assuming Hermione has bullied his sister.
- Hermione asks Ginny to deny it, and Ginny says Hermione did nothing wrong, though her frightened, sobbing appearance makes the situation look suspicious.
- Luo Bin defends Hermione and turns Percy’s accusations back on him, suggesting that Percy’s protective comments may be reinforcing Ginny’s timidity. Hermione adopts Luo Bin’s claim that Percy is psychologically manipulating Ginny, using the term “PUA.”
- Percy angrily denies controlling Ginny. Ginny defends him, but Hermione insists she may not recognize such influence herself.
- Percy draws his wand, apparently intending to frighten Hermione. Snape disarms him and warns that attacking a younger student would bring severe punishment. Percy leaves with Ginny, glaring at Hermione and Luo Bin.
- Luo Bin tries to use the approaching bell as an excuse to leave. Snape instead announces that Lockhart is unwell and Defense Against the Dark Arts will be a study period. Hermione dislikes this prospect but quickly pretends to welcome it and asks to visit Lockhart.
Character developments and interactions
- Hermione is stubborn about keeping the key and, once Percy accuses her, becomes defensive and frustrated. She joins Luo Bin in accusing Percy, though their evidence is mostly interpretation.
- Luo Bin calmly supports Hermione and cleverly reframes Percy’s protectiveness as potentially harmful. He also recognizes that Hermione’s excuse about the bell will not fool Snape.
- Ginny is caught between Hermione and Percy: she denies being bullied by Hermione, remains visibly frightened, and then firmly defends Percy.
- Percy begins as an overprotective older brother but loses his composure when accused, drawing his wand and bringing Snape’s intervention.
- Snape acts decisively to stop Percy and control the situation, then dryly redirects the students’ attention to class.
Significant themes
- Protection versus control: The chapter questions when concern for someone becomes a force that limits their confidence or independence.
- Appearance and misinterpretation: Ginny’s tears lead Percy to assume Hermione is guilty, while Hermione and Luo Bin interpret Ginny’s fear around Percy as evidence against him.
- Power and authority: Percy’s attempt to intimidate Hermione is halted by Snape, whose authority immediately changes the balance of the confrontation.