Arc 2The Lord Apostle's Path

Subaru recovered his memories and learned that Louis had hidden part of herself inside him, while Ley and Roy remained a threat. The screen then showed another Subaru clearing a path for Emilia by using the Witch Cult, former enemies, and repeated deaths, leaving the watching group troubled by how far he had gone.

  • Subaru restored his memories through his Book of the Dead, while Louis endured Return by Death and broke down in the Corridor of Memories.
  • Subaru warned his companions that Ley and Roy would bring witchbeasts to the tower, and the screen began showing another future branch.
  • The screen showed Subaru killing three men after eighty-eight failed attempts to reach Satella, then watching Reinhard defeat Elsa and rescuing her for his own plans.
  • Subaru recruited black-robed followers, learned Emilia was a royal selection candidate, and resolved to clear her path to the throne without seeking recognition.
  • Subaru used knowledge from hundreds of loops to kill Petelgeuse, then gave Emilia the credit for defeating the Sin Archbishop of Sloth.
  • After the White Whale erased Crusch and her memories from the expedition, Subaru found Ferris and promised to help him fill the emptiness left by his loss.
  • Subaru recruited Ferris as the Blue Mage, while the watching group challenged his willingness to treat his deaths and others as tools.
  • Subaru watched Elsa kill Regulus in the burning mansion, then used Ferris to poison Julius and reach Anastasia, before leaving with the gray-haired merchant Otto recognized as himself.
Chapters 26–50 Vol. 1 Read

Ch. 26You are no longer a tool, but a person true to your name

Natsuki Subaru returned from the Gluttony Route exhausted, while Beatrice received a bond that let her sense his presence. Shaula’s reward helped her recognize her own feelings and wishes, and she left to find Subaru after he acknowledged her love.

  • Natsuki Subaru emerged from the vanished screen, and Beatrice and Emilia helped him to the stone bed.
  • Beatrice received the Hearts Bound Together reward and told Subaru she would find him if he disappeared again.
  • Shaula began to understand her own emotions and wished to stay with Master when he cried, then confessed that she loved him.
  • Natsuki Subaru acknowledged Shaula’s feelings and promised to remember them, while Beatrice affirmed that he must remember her choice too.
  • Ram warned Subaru not to push himself to collapse again and mentioned Rem, and Subaru promised to be careful.
  • Shaula wiped away her tears and ran toward the green room.

Ch. 27Shaula's embrace

Natsuki Subaru tried to leave the green room despite his exhaustion, while Betty, Emilia, and Ram watched over him. Shaula came to see him, urged him to keep living, and carefully hugged him as he began to regain his composure.

  • Natsuki Subaru asked to go outside, but swayed when he tried to stand, so Emilia supported him and Betty and Ram warned him not to overexert himself.
  • Shaula peeked into the green room and waited for Natsuki Subaru to come out before approaching him in the corridor.
  • Shaula asked whether Natsuki Subaru was dying or about to pass out, and he insisted that he was only thirsty and still recovering.
  • Shaula told Natsuki Subaru that he had to keep living, and he promised to try.
  • Shaula asked Betty and Emilia for permission to hug Natsuki Subaru, then embraced him gently as he patted her back.

Ch. 28Shaula was learning

Natsuki Subaru recovered with Shaula, Emilia, Betty, and Ram nearby, and Shaula carefully learned how to care for him. Subaru then decided to investigate Reid's Book of the Dead in the library, and Shaula joined the group after he entrusted her with leading the way and watching over everyone.

  • Shaula asked to stay beside Subaru, and he agreed before Emilia, Betty, and Ram insisted he rest.
  • Shaula tried to bring Subaru a basin of water, then learned to use a cup instead and remembered the lesson.
  • Subaru said he wanted to visit the library to investigate whether Reid's Book of the Dead had caused his memory loss.
  • Shaula noticed that the others were worried about Subaru and asked to accompany him; Subaru agreed after setting rules against reckless behavior.
  • Subaru asked Shaula to lead the way and watch over Emilia, Betty, and Ram, and Shaula accepted the mission.

Ch. 29Cognitive Obstruction

Natsuki Subaru opened Reid Astrea’s book and met Louis Arneb in the white space, using Cognitive Obstruction to make her reveal her plans. He left the conversation asking about the place and Louis’s brothers.

  • Natsuki Subaru entered the library with Emilia, Betty, Ram, and Shaula and found Reid Astrea’s book.
  • Natsuki Subaru opened the book and encountered Louis Arneb, who identified herself as the Witch Cult’s Sin Archbishop of Gluttony and admitted she had eaten his memories.
  • Natsuki Subaru used Cognitive Obstruction to lower Louis’s guard and learned she planned to make him reject his original self so she could eat him again and take Return by Death.
  • Louis revealed that part of herself was hidden inside Natsuki Subaru and that she had called her two brothers to lure witchbeasts toward him.
  • Natsuki Subaru dismissed Louis’s suspicions that someone else was present and asked what the white space was and who her brothers were.

Ch. 30Rem's hero was the greatest in the world

Natsuki Subaru learned that Louis had split herself, with one part hiding inside him and another waiting in the Hall of Memories to steal his Return by Death. After Louis tried to break his resolve, Rem’s encouragement and the Greed Witch Factor helped him resist her and jump through a rift back toward his companions.

  • Louis explained that she and her brothers Ley and Roy could devour names, memories, and lives, and use what they had eaten.
  • Louis revealed that she had split herself, with one part inside Natsuki Subaru and another waiting to repeatedly steal his memories and Return by Death.
  • Louis told Natsuki Subaru that he could recover his stolen memories through Books of the Dead left by his deaths, but warned that his past self might swallow his present identity.
  • Natsuki Subaru attacked Louis, but she taunted him with doubts about which version of himself he wanted to save.
  • Rem appeared and called Natsuki Subaru her hero, strengthening his resolve as the Greed Witch Factor awakened and protected him from Louis’s brainwashing.
  • Natsuki Subaru jumped through a rift toward his companions, while Louis shouted that Gluttony would devour him.

Ch. 31Julius pledges his loyalty

Natsuki Subaru woke in the library and learned that Anastasia feared Gluttony would make her forget Julius, but she chose to recognize him as her knight anew. He revealed Gluttony's plans and decided to search the library for his own Book of the Dead, hoping it could restore the memories Gluttony had taken.

  • Natsuki Subaru woke with Betty holding his hand and Emilia supporting his head, while Shaula watched over him.
  • Anastasia explained that returning to the outside could make Gluttony erase her memories of Julius, but she named him her knight and agreed they would start their relationship anew.
  • Julius pledged to prove himself to Anastasia again and serve her as her knight.
  • Natsuki Subaru told the group that Louis Arneb had waited for him in the Corridor of Memories and hidden another part of herself inside his body.
  • Natsuki Subaru warned that Lye Batenkaitos and Roy Alphard would come to the tower with mabeasts, targeting him and Return by Death.
  • Natsuki Subaru said ordinary people could not easily recover memories eaten by Gluttony, but his repeated deaths might have left Books of the Dead bearing his name, so he would search for one.

Ch. 32Finding Natsuki Subaru's Book of the Dead

Natsuki Subaru realized his Book of the Dead might be written in the characters of his own world, so he showed everyone how to recognize them. Shaula found the matching book, and Subaru confirmed it was the one that could bring him back.

  • Natsuki Subaru asked for paper and wrote his name in the characters used in his world.
  • Natsuki Subaru explained that his Book of the Dead might bear those characters, and Emilia, Betty, Ram, Julius, Anastasia, and Shaula resumed searching for their shapes.
  • Shaula found a book whose cover matched the written characters and brought it to Natsuki Subaru.
  • Natsuki Subaru confirmed that the book could bring him back and thanked Shaula for finding it.
  • Shaula said she had remembered Natsuki Subaru's name and would find it again next time.

Ch. 33Natsuki Subaru, reporting for duty

Natsuki Subaru entered the Book of the Dead and reunited with his forgotten self, accepting that an ordinary person’s love for others had made him a hero. He returned to the library with his memories restored, while Louis broke down after experiencing his deaths.

  • Betty, Emilia, Shaula, and Ram asked Subaru to return safely before he opened the Book of the Dead bearing his name.
  • Subaru relived his deaths and met his amnesiac self in the white space, where they reconciled and acknowledged that they were the same person.
  • Subaru’s forgotten self thanked him for saving their friends and family and asked him to look after Meili and Shaula.
  • Louis broke down after sharing Subaru’s deaths and drove him out of the Corridor of Memories.
  • Subaru returned to the library with his memories restored, apologized for keeping everyone waiting, and said he was back.

Ch. 34Louis Breaks Down

After Natsuki Subaru vanished, Louis tried to take Return by Death from her other self, who had already experienced it. When the two Louises merged, Louis was overwhelmed by the deaths and suffering, leaving her broken and begging for help.

  • Louis realized her other self had already tasted Return by Death and went deeper into the white space to find her.
  • Louis found her other self curled on the floor, terrified and warning that Return by Death was hell.
  • The corridor Louis accused her other self of hiding the experience and seized her, forcing their bodies to merge.
  • Louis experienced repeated deaths through Return by Death and rejected the life she had coveted.
  • The two Louises fused and broke down together as Louis curled up, pleading for someone to save her.

Ch. 35I'm back

Natsuki Subaru returned to himself and reunited with his companions in the library, then warned them that Ley, Roy, and the witchbeasts were still a threat. As they agreed to face the danger together, the mysterious screen of light appeared and announced that it would begin observing a future branch.

  • Betty, Emilia, and Shaula welcomed Natsuki Subaru back with relief, while Ram, Meili, Julius, and Anastasia each acknowledged his return.
  • Natsuki Subaru told Meili he would stay as he was, and apologized to Julius for forgetting him.
  • Natsuki Subaru said Louis had broken down after experiencing his memories and would be unable to act for now.
  • Natsuki Subaru warned that Ley and Roy remained outside with the witchbeasts, and he and his companions agreed to face the threat together.
  • The screen of light appeared again and announced that observation of a future branch would begin.

Ch. 36Satella, I swear I'll save you

The library's observers learned that screen playback took far less time in reality, then watched a version of Natsuki Subaru who had died eighty-eight times and had grown brutally efficient at clearing obstacles. The chapter ended with him renewing his vow to save the girl he knew as Satella.

  • Otto explained that little time passed in reality while they watched the screen, easing Emilia's concern that Gluttony and the witchbeasts would arrive during the playback.
  • The screen showed Natsuki Subaru in the royal capital, where he ambushed and killed three men who had repeatedly blocked his way.
  • Natsuki Subaru revealed that he had encountered the trio eighty-eight times and treated killing them as a way to save time.
  • Betty, Emilia, and the others reacted to his exhaustion and learned that he had died many times while trying to reach Satella.
  • Natsuki Subaru left the alley and renewed his vow to save the girl named Satella.

Ch. 37Heroes and mortals

Natsuki Subaru’s attempt to stop Elsa by gathering guards ended in a slaughter, until Reinhard van Astrea arrived and defeated her. Subaru watched Satella’s fate change, but felt grief realizing a true hero had achieved what his repeated deaths could not.

  • Natsuki Subaru sent guards to stop Elsa, but she cut through them and left him convinced the attempt had failed.
  • Reinhard van Astrea arrived in the slums and blocked Elsa from continuing her attack.
  • Elsa struck at Reinhard, but he dodged her blade and sent her crashing through a wooden wall with one swing.
  • Reinhard repeatedly evaded Elsa’s attacks and overwhelmed her until she lay motionless in the wreckage.
  • Natsuki Subaru realized Satella had been saved, but cried as he understood that a hero had solved the problem he had died trying to overcome.

Ch. 38Saving Elsa

After Reinhard arrived following eighty-eight deaths and defeated Elsa, Natsuki Subaru diverted the guards and rescued the wounded Bowel Hunter so he could use her in the future. He brought Elsa to a safe house in the slums, where a blue-haired girl greeted them and left him wary of what lay ahead.

  • Reinhard reflected that his late arrival had cost Natsuki Subaru eighty-eight deaths, while Subaru resolved not to waste the outcome he had finally reached.
  • Subaru decided to keep Elsa alive and slipped through the slums, misleading the guards with false information, gold coins, and noises.
  • Subaru found the wounded Elsa and carried her away, telling her he still wanted to kill her but needed her alive for now.
  • Subaru brought Elsa to a small house in the southeastern slums, where a blue-haired girl thanked him for returning Big Sister Elsa.
  • Subaru recognized the girl as Elsa's little sister or associate and realized that this route was only beginning.

Ch. 39A reason to live

After the loot-house confrontation, Natsuki Subaru gained the loyalty of a fanatical group who called him the Witch’s Apostle and ordered them to investigate Satella and the royal selection. Two months later, after learning Satella’s real name was Emilia, he resolved to help her win the throne by finding the weaknesses of her rivals.

  • After Elsa and Meili left the royal capital, Natsuki Subaru returned to the loot house and confirmed Satella had survived and recovered her insignia, while Felt and Old Man Rom had been taken by the guards.
  • Natsuki Subaru found black-robed figures in the warehouse, and they knelt to him after he called Satella by name, declaring him blessed by the Witch and calling him their Lord Apostle.
  • Natsuki Subaru ordered the figures to find Satella, learn the silver-haired half-elf’s real name, and investigate the royal selection and anyone who might oppose her.
  • Two months later, the black-robed figures reported that the half-elf was Emilia, a royal selection candidate living at Margrave Roswaal L. Mathers’s mansion, and named the other candidates as Crusch Karsten, Anastasia Hoshin, Priscilla Barielle, and Felt.
  • Natsuki Subaru ordered the figures to investigate the other candidates’ weaknesses, associates, and whereabouts, resolving to help Emilia reach the throne even if she never knew.

Ch. 40An unfamiliar Natsuki Subaru

The people watching the screen saw an unfamiliar Natsuki Subaru use Witch Cultists, Elsa, and Meili while planning to clear the royal selection candidates out of Emilia’s way. Emilia wondered why he had sacrificed so much for her, and then asked the Subaru beside her whether he, too, had died many times.

  • Felt, Anastasia, Priscilla, and Crusch realized the Subaru on the screen viewed every royal selection candidate except Emilia as an obstacle.
  • Julius and Otto warned that Subaru was turning the royal selection and former enemies into tools, while Meili wondered whether he would use her too.
  • Garfiel asked how many times the Subaru with them had died, prompting Beatrice and Shaula to look to him for an answer.
  • Emilia realized the Subaru on the screen had remembered Satella’s name and died eighty-eight times to save her, despite barely knowing her.
  • Natsuki Subaru told Emilia that the other Subaru’s choices were wrong and that she should not blame herself for them.
  • Emilia asked Natsuki Subaru whether he had also died many times.

Ch. 41Sin Archbishop of Sloth

Natsuki Subaru admitted to his companions that he had died many times, and Betty and Emilia confronted the pain he had carried alone. In the light screen, Subaru had spent two months embedded in the Witch Cult when Petelgeuse arrived and proposed attacking the Mathers Domain to sacrifice Emilia and revive the Witch of Envy.

  • Natsuki Subaru revealed that he had died repeatedly in the royal capital, the mansion, the demon beast forest, and other places, describing several of his deaths.
  • Betty told Subaru that his previous deaths mattered, while Emilia apologized for not knowing what he had endured.
  • Subaru reassured Betty, Shaula, Emilia, Garfiel, and Otto that he was no longer alone.
  • The light screen showed Subaru living among the Witch Cult for two months, posing as someone favored by the Witch.
  • Petelgeuse Romanee-Conti visited Subaru and proposed attacking the Mathers Domain to sacrifice Emilia and bring back the Witch of Envy.

Ch. 42400 loops

After more than four hundred loops spent learning Petelgeuse’s habits and powers, Natsuki Subaru killed him and stopped his attempts to escape through possession. Subaru ordered his followers to dispose of the body, focused only on keeping Emilia’s path to the throne clear.

  • Petelgeuse raved about devotion to the Witch and attacked himself while Subaru watched without looking away.
  • Subaru stabbed Petelgeuse from behind, then evaded his Unseen Hands using knowledge gained across more than four hundred loops.
  • Subaru explained that he had mapped Petelgeuse’s attacks, Fingers, and possession tactics, while Elsa and Meili dealt with the remaining Fingers.
  • Subaru blocked Petelgeuse’s possession with a contract with minor spirits and killed him with a longsword.
  • Subaru ordered the black-robed figures to clean up Petelgeuse’s corpse and accepted their title of Lord Apostle without correction.

Ch. 43Meili's envy

After Meili helped eliminate the Sin Archbishop of Sloth’s Fingers, she asked why Subaru had not claimed the credit or enlisted the royal knights. The onlookers realized Subaru had endured hundreds of deaths to secure Emilia’s advancement without asking whether she wanted the sacrifice, while Meili envied the version of herself who was still needed and cared for.

  • Meili emerged after helping Subaru deal with the Fingers, and Subaru thanked her and offered her mayonnaise-flavored snacks.
  • Meili asked why Subaru had not told the royal knights about the Witch Cult or claimed the prestige of defeating the Sin Archbishop of Sloth.
  • Emilia rejected the credit, saying she did not want it if Subaru had bought it by dying repeatedly.
  • Crusch, Anastasia, and Julius recognized that Subaru understood the value of the achievement but had passed it to Emilia without asking her.
  • Meili admitted that she envied her on-screen self, who still had Elsa and someone who needed and remembered her.
  • Subaru left Meili with the snacks and looked toward the path he had cleared for Emilia, whose name he had pushed toward the throne.

Ch. 44Working with Roswaal

After Emilia’s victory over Petelgeuse brought her growing recognition, Natsuki Subaru met with Roswaal and offered the Emilia Camp’s records of the defeat so Emilia could receive all the credit. Roswaal accepted, while Subaru regarded him as useful for now and a potential obstacle to remove later.

  • News spread through Lugunica that Emilia had defeated Petelgeuse, shifting some people’s opinions of her.
  • Natsuki Subaru kept his name out of the victory and arranged to give Emilia all the credit.
  • Roswaal asked whether Subaru truly wanted no recognition, and Subaru said that becoming a hero was of little use to him.
  • Roswaal recognized Subaru’s determination and accepted the proposal to support Emilia publicly.
  • Subaru decided Roswaal was useful for now, but would become another obstacle to remove if he ever threatened Emilia’s path.

Ch. 45The Great Expedition

The Crusch Camp's expedition to slay the White Whale ended in disaster, and the beast erased Crusch from everyone's memories. Natsuki Subaru arrived after the battle and found what he called the spoils, leaving the meaning of his discovery unclear.

  • After Emilia Camp's victory over Sloth raised its standing, Crusch led a great expedition to defeat the White Whale and restore her camp's prestige.
  • The White Whale attacked through thick fog, overwhelming the expedition as soldiers vanished from both the battlefield and people's memories.
  • Crusch continued rallying her forces, but the White Whale swallowed her, leaving Ferris in tears without remembering who he had lost.
  • The Crusch Camp's expedition ended in defeat, and Anastasia and Julius explained that the White Whale erased more than its victims' lives.
  • Natsuki Subaru arrived with Meili after the White Whale had left, searched the wreckage, and declared that he had found the spoils.

Ch. 46Ferris

The scene showed Natsuki Subaru finding Ferris chained in a cavern, broken by the White Whale’s erasure of someone important to him. Subaru said he would keep Ferris from killing himself, leaving Ferris and the others to confront what that implied about unseen loops.

  • Natsuki Subaru found Ferris wounded and chained in a cavern, where Ferris wept and asked why he felt such pain despite remembering nothing.
  • Ferris watched his suffering self and realized that losing someone important had left a painful emptiness even after the memories were gone.
  • Ram wondered why she had not broken down after forgetting Rem, then was unable to finish expressing her thoughts.
  • Natsuki Subaru explained that he could not learn what had happened between Ferris and the person erased by the White Whale, but called Ferris a pawn he had worked hard to find.
  • Natsuki Subaru touched Ferris's hair and promised to fill the cracks in his heart and find a way to keep him from killing himself.
  • Ferris realized that Natsuki Subaru had seen him die by suicide in other loops and struggled to answer whether he might do the same if Crusch disappeared.

Ch. 47A pawn-the Blue Mage

Subaru explained that his other self was turning Ferris, Meili, and Elsa into pawns because he could no longer see another way to help Emilia become king. In the cavern, he persuaded Ferris to take his hand and become his Blue Mage, while the Subaru beside Emilia promised Betty he would not treat his own life as expendable.

  • Wilhelm acknowledged Subaru's debt in the White Whale battle but said the Subaru on the screen had gone too far.
  • Emilia asked Subaru why his other self was making everyone suffer, and Subaru said he was trying to clear Emilia's path to the throne and make every death meaningful.
  • Betty told Subaru she did not want him to put himself on the chessboard or treat his deaths as worthwhile, and he promised he would not.
  • Subaru told Ferris he did not know what Ferris had lost but would help him find it, and asked him to help Emilia become king.
  • Ferris took Subaru's hand, and Subaru claimed him as his new pawn, the Blue Mage.

Ch. 48Sin Archbishop, Representing Greed

Natsuki Subaru and Elsa Granhiert confronted the powerless Regulus Corneas as the mansion burned, while the women he had imprisoned sacrificed themselves to help bring him down. Subaru chose to let Regulus die slowly in the flames, and he and Elsa left as the mansion collapsed.

  • The women in Regulus Corneas's burning mansion died after defying him, and Elsa Granhiert kicked and mutilated him after his protection failed.
  • Regulus blamed Natsuki Subaru for destroying his family and continued insisting that he had only wanted a quiet, happy life.
  • Elsa explained that she had left Regulus alive and injured so he would understand the women's resolve.
  • Subaru told Elsa to take her time, and she carried Regulus into the fire while he screamed and cursed.
  • Regulus's voice finally ceased, and Subaru and Elsa turned away as the mansion collapsed.

Ch. 49Led astray

After watching Subaru and Elsa burn Regulus alive, the onlookers condemned the cruelty while wondering how many deaths and failed attempts had led Subaru there. The screen then shifted to a quiet tavern, where Julius sat beside a downcast Ferris.

  • Emilia said she hated Regulus but did not want to see Subaru kill someone that way, and Betty told Subaru she would keep him from becoming like that.
  • Felt, Reinhard, Otto, Anastasia, Priscilla, and Al discussed Regulus’s deserved death, Subaru’s choice to watch him die, and the danger of Subaru losing his sense of boundaries after repeated deaths.
  • Meili pointed out that Subaru had never revealed how many times he had died during the Greed incident, and Otto and Julius suggested he had repeatedly failed to learn Regulus’s weaknesses and save the imprisoned women.
  • Garfiel told Subaru not to become like the person on the screen, and the burned mansion scene ended in silence.
  • The screen changed to a quiet tavern, where Julius sat beside a downcast Ferris.

Ch. 50Julius's death

Natsuki Subaru poisoned Julius and manipulated Ferris into helping, then arranged for a gray-haired merchant to dispose of Julius’s body. The gray-haired man refused to give Subaru his name, while the audience recognized him as Otto.

  • Julius drank poisoned wine at Ferris’s invitation, and Ferris apologized as Natsuki Subaru revealed himself and comforted him.
  • Natsuki Subaru explained that he had targeted Julius to reach Anastasia, while Ferris obeyed his praise and Julius died watching his friend grieve.
  • A gray-haired merchant arrived to collect Julius’s body and refused to tell Natsuki Subaru his name, saying friendship with him was too risky.
  • Natsuki Subaru left the tavern, telling the merchant that obstacles remained and he would have plenty to do; outside the screen, Otto recognized the gray-haired man as himself.
Arc 2 of 2
Arc 2 of 2