Arc 1The Scarlet Spider Emerges
Toby shaped Peter into Spider-Man while uncovering the truth behind his parents’ deaths and Dr. Connors’s transformation into the Lizard Man. After Peter confronted the monster, Toby revealed his Scarlet Spider suit when the Lizard Man attacked the amusement park, leaving Gwen to learn his secret as he moved to fight.
- Toby massacred the Neon Gang, brought Okamoto Reiichi’s head to Kingpin, and accepted a paid partnership as the assassin Poison Spider.
- Toby returned to his family in Flushing, renewed his connection with Gwen, and brought Peter to Osborn Enterprises, where Peter completed Richard Parker’s lizard-serum formula.
- Toby stole Super Spiders from Osborn Tower and secretly arranged for one to bite Peter, awakening Peter’s spider powers.
- Toby trained Peter in combat, gave him a Spider Suit, and revealed that Norman Osborn had ordered Peter’s parents silenced over the Super Spiders.
- Dr. Connors tested his regenerative serum on himself and became the Lizard Man, while Toby stole the serum and Peter went out to stop him.
- Peter saved people on Manhattan Bridge but was badly beaten by the Lizard Man in the sewers, and Toby treated his injuries before leaving for a date with Gwen.
- Toby and Gwen grew closer during their date, and Gwen revealed that she had guessed Peter was Spider-Man and Dr. Connors was the Lizard Man.
- The Lizard Man attacked near the amusement park, and Toby revealed his Scarlet Spider suit to Gwen before leaping from the Ferris wheel to confront him.